Pakistan's Descent into Chaos: Terrorist & Drone Attacks

indiatester

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2013
Messages
4,463
Likes
12,725
Country flag
https://www.thefridaytimes.com/pakistan-is-losing-too-many-soldiers-in-ct-ops/
Pakistan Is Losing Too Many Soldiers In Counter Terrorism Operations
As I said to Gen Kayani and several other officers, far from taking pride in the courage of our men, I’d very concerned about why we are losing so many young officers and men.

Ejaz Haider
by Ejaz Haider

October 22, 2021

in Analysis

Pakistan Is Losing Too Many Soldiers In Counter Terrorism Operations
528
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

After a drop in casualty rates in the ongoing counterterrorism operations, this year has again witnessed a spike. The frequency of attacks has increased as have the numbers of security forces personnel (including police and paramilitary troops) killed and injured by terrorist groups ambushing patrol parties and other vehicular movement.
The Inter-Services Public Relations press notifications have become a near-daily occurrence. Here, I give two examples of those notifications that also show what modi operandi the groups are using to target security forces personnel:
“Terrorists fire-raid security forces post in District Kech, Balochistan. Troops responded promptly. During fire exchange, Sepoy X embraced shahadat. Area search in progress to hunt down perpetrators of the incident.”
“Security forces along with police conducted cordon and search operation late last night. During operation, an IED exploded in Dabrai, Bajaur District. Resultantly, 2 FC soldiers… and 2 police constables… embraced shahadat. Area clearance being carried out to eliminate any terrorists found in the area.”
There are many other examples but these should suffice. In fact, the press notifications raise a number of questions with reference to how operations are being conducted. According to data compiled by South Asian Terrorism Portal, in 2021 until October (the ongoing month), there have been 207 incidents resulting in the killing of 177 civilians, 158 security personnel (this includes police/paramilitary) and 185 terrorists. By all benchmarks, this is a very high casualty rate for friendly forces.
But before I get to why we should take this very seriously and how we can bring the casualty rate down, let me go back to 2010. During a briefing by General Ashfaq Perez Kayani, which was preceded by a presentation by a Brigadier, a slide presented figures on the sacrifices of our soldiers and with a lot of pride showed that our officer-to-jawan kill ratio is 1:8 — i.e., for every eight soldiers in combat, we are losing one officer. The explanation: our officers lead from the front.
The statistics left me deeply disturbed. As I said to Gen Kayani and several other officers, far from taking pride in the courage of our men, I’d very concerned about why we are losing so many young officers and men. When someone enlists, he knows that when the time comes he must be ready to kill, or get killed. There is no clean battle. Incoming fire has a nasty habit of finding its target. Yet, that’s precisely what professional armies train for, developing the capability to inflict maximum damage on the enemy while minimising own losses in men and material.
This is the essence of what US General George Patton is reported to have said: “No bastard ever won a war by dying for his country. He won it by making the other poor dumb bastard die for his country.” Patton was, of course, talking about a different time and a different war. Even so, his message remains constant for all types of war, including the irregular war we are still fighting, with no defined front and no rear, no clear zones of war and peace.
The enemy in this war is difficult to identify. He relies on kinship and ideological bonds, rarely offers a concentrated target, thereby blunting the advantage of a superior force, and can move from the sanctuary to the preparation area to the operational area with relative ease, both in terms of time and space. He has the element of surprise on his side. He can hunker down and wait for the opportunity. He can snipe at targets, use IEDs, raid isolated posts, and mount terror attacks in the cities. In effect, break the norms of fighting in order to gain an asymmetric advantage. The violence he generates is not great but consistent and incremental and creates a psychological effect to erode the resolve, if not of the army, then that of the civilian population.
Pakistan won this war at a great price. Along the way security forces learnt from their mistakes. It was long-drawn and painful but it worked. Pakistan won where, across the border to the west in Afghanistan, a large coalition of the most modern militaries failed. But it seems that we have let our guard down. Many officers and men who fought those battles and survived have retired. Is the institutional memory of lessons learnt being lost?
Pakistan has known and recorded the evolving situation for nearly two years now: disparate TTP groups reorganising and banding together; four Baloch terrorist organisations coming together to mount coordinated attacks; Islamic State-Khorasan cadres targeting security forces and Shia Pakistanis. Pakistan has also known, going by the dossiers made public by the government, that many of these elements are being supported and funded by India’s intelligence agencies. According to stories in the Indian media in 2017, the National Security Council Secretariat, headed by Ajit Doval, received a staggering 311% increase in funds. Some analysts have argued that this could be “to tackle issues at the intersection of cybersecurity and nuclear weapon delivery systems”, but that seems to be a stretch going by the traditional role of the National Security Council Secretariat.
Be that as it may, Pakistan has to be prepared, by its own reckoning, against Indian designs to foment trouble in its tribal districts as well as Balochistan. Simply referring to this as India’s perfidy will not do.
So, what should Pakistan do?
First, the operations and the losses must immediately be studied. Are we faltering on the training required for fighting this kind of war; is the enemy doing something different from what it was doing before and for which security forces developed countermeasures? What kind of organisational innovations are needed to tackle the evolving situation? Are the security forces employing new technologies to improve their intelligence, surveillance, target acquisition, and reconnaissance capabilities? The army has a lot of experience now in tackling IEDs; are those techniques being fully employed? Is there enough field and strategic intelligence on terrain, enemy resources, lines of communication, recruitment methods, training camps, concentration areas?
These questions are important. But even more important is whether military and other leaders are concerned about mounting casualty rate. Clearly, to address the issue would first require a deep concern about the safety and effectiveness of troops and policemen.
Pakistan has come a long way from the time it began fighting this war. It is decidedly in a much better position now than it was when this war began. As I noted above, lessons have been learnt and incorporated into training and manuals. The army also has better equipment, including drones both combat and surveillance. Are troops deployed in sensitive, vulnerable areas and points being provided the advantage of real-time ISR? There’s also a fence now. The ISPR calls some of these attacks fire raids: are these ambushes, long-distance sniping, shooting? Do patrol parties or other vehicular movement have the benefit of ISR? if not, why not? Are these attacks happening from the Afghanistan soil or do we have terrorists hiding in the population east of the border?
In this kind of war, as in any kind of war, intelligence is crucial. Is there effective coordination among intelligence agencies on the one hand and the fighting troops and agencies on the other?
There are many questions but very few answers. My own sense from having seen many operations is that the groups are not doing anything different. The Taliban, both in Afghanistan and here, have relied on ambushes, hit-and-run tactics, suicide bombings, IEDs. Where they can amass more men and firepower, they also go for flanking, encirclement and direct-fire engagement (what ISPR calls fire raids). Officers who have participated in previous operations also know that groups use generally the same spots and lines of communication for such attacks. It should not be too hard to prevent such attacks. The concerned officials must make clear how they are dealing with the situation and what data they are gathering. Putting out statistics and calling the fallen shaheeds doesn’t really cut and certainly doesn’t tell us what’s going on. It’s time to get some answers.
 

FalconSlayers

जयेम सं युधि स्पृध:
Senior Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2020
Messages
16,429
Likes
85,396
Country flag
Internal troubles for Pakistan will spiral out of control, Lot of fighting can be expected between TTP and Pakistan army. We may witness a lot of action scenes. Western neighbors who taunted us after every terror attack is going to weep a lot.
Pakistan's Taliban (TTP) annouces End of Ceasefire with govt; Says 'Be Ready'.
 

FalconSlayers

जयेम सं युधि स्पृध:
Senior Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2020
Messages
16,429
Likes
85,396
Country flag
Porkis were celebrating the killing of two Policemen of Jammu Kashmir Police SgCT Mohammad Sultan and Ct Fayaz Ahmed by the Pakistani terrorists, now Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan has taught them why shouldn’t you do wrong with innocents and then rejoice over it. Pakistanis killed thousands of Indians through their terrorists, now they’re gatting paid back.

Enjoy 😉
1639223602720.jpeg
 

Mikesingh

Professional
Joined
Sep 7, 2015
Messages
7,213
Likes
29,052
Country flag
Pak has morphed into a failed rogue nation on the brink of implosion! These madrassas are producing an evil reptilian race built on hate and bloodshed. It is not the so-called self-styled 'Land of the Pure' as the Pakis like it to be known but more the 'Land of Satan' where even young girls are taught how to kill non-Muslims!

 

rock127

Maulana Rockullah
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2009
Messages
9,968
Likes
18,450
Country flag
Lo ji... Sheej Phire is over! TTP Freedom Fighters needed some rest and ammo and now back to business. :lol:

Now TTP Freedom fighters can kill Pak Fauj with new josh! :shoot:

The best way for them is to start killing Polio workers and some police as warm up and then main course would be behead Paki SSG Commandos and play football with their muslim brothers's head! Umma Chummah! :rofl:


 

FalconSlayers

जयेम सं युधि स्पृध:
Senior Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2020
Messages
16,429
Likes
85,396
Country flag
Two Pak Army soldiers and two Pak military intelligence agents killed in an ambush in Bajaur tribal district of disputed KPK province. Two more Pak soldiers critically injured.

Meanwhile an official of Pakistan's Intelligence Bureau was shot died in another district of KPK.
 

LaIllahaSigmar

Regular Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2021
Messages
804
Likes
4,832
Country flag
Last edited:

Tshering22

Sikkimese Saber
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
6,064
Likes
11,130
Country flag
Follow these channels.



Might be exaggerated but with china you can never be too sure.

But do keep in mind that many "reality of china" channels are Falun gong cult funded.
Thanks for the link Falun Gong is that meditation group that makes Xinnie wet his pants isn't it? I really don't understand what grouse he has with the a bunch of peaceniks. Maybe the same that he has with HH Dalai Lama.

The thing with China is that most of its detractors come out to say the true levels of mess that happens there since the normal Chinese media does not allow anything to come out.
 

LaIllahaSigmar

Regular Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2021
Messages
804
Likes
4,832
Country flag
Thanks for the link Falun Gong is that meditation group that makes Xinnie wet his pants isn't it? I really don't understand what grouse he has with the a bunch of peaceniks. Maybe the same that he has with HH Dalai Lama.
Not xingping.

It was Jiang zemin who persecuted them.

My guess is that, when xinping is finally going to eliminate zemin finally, and if in need for some international good press, he will leak out details of zemin's actions and human rights violations.

Otherwise I like all CCP crimes, xinping will probably not adress this as it affects their image.

CCP already spends alot discrediting the Falun gong and going after their drama troupe Shen Yun.

Commies will go after any ideology or belief system that weaken their grip on people.
Thats why the CCP is going after Islam so aggressively and suppresses religion in general.
And Falun gong is a literal cult with many questionable beliefs.


The thing with China is that most of its detractors come out to say the true levels of mess that happens there since the normal Chinese media does not allow anything to come out.
True.
Chinese leadership admit issues only after they've become too big to hide.

Anyway, the china insights guy relies mainly on Chinese media, social media and Chinese experts to come to his conclusions.

china observer guy is less reliable.
 

Tshering22

Sikkimese Saber
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
6,064
Likes
11,130
Country flag
Pakistanis really seem to be rapidly losing control over their lands, don't they? Bajwa is truly inactive. He is literally doing nothing with the opportunity that is presented to him. It almost seems deliberate and that the Army wants someone like TLP and TTP to come to power. Sounds foolish but looks at their inaction.

No Paki Jurnail would sit it out so deliberately when their troops are dying in droves. How come they are not using their combat aircraft? If you remember, Raheel Sharif and Kiyani were not at all hesitant to use heavy weapons against Balochis and TTP and that subsided this war to some extent.
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

Articles

Top