NGO'S Foreign Funding - A Security Threat

vampyrbladez

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2018
Messages
10,261
Likes
26,567
Country flag
Found something really interesting while observing world leaders.

Unless people are blind there is a clear pattern emerging against RW populist leaders.

Trump - Russiagate/Tax Fraud FDNY Attempted Replacement : Marco Rubio, Rand Paul

Modi - Rafale deal Attempted Replacement : Nitin Gadkari

Netanyahu - Corruption Attempted Replacement : Lieberman , Benny Gantz, Ayelet Shaked

Heinz-Christian Strache- Corruption/Russiagate Attempted Replacement : Norbert Hofer

Boris Johnson - Brexit Case Attempted Replacement : Nigel Farage
 

Jameson Emoni

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2018
Messages
1,473
Likes
4,250
Those Theoretical ideas of "Absolute democracy" don't work in real world. Moreover when you bring in the concept of Rich/Poor, you are actually talking about economy not democracy. If you are saying india needs to do better at income redistribution, then answer is yes. What does democracy has to do with it?

I always believe there is a bit confusion in the minds of people about democracy/government and it's utility. there is a misunderstanding that democracy and government is there to govern our lives, government should exist to govern only specific tasks of society so that it runs smoothly.

In my opinion things like income redistribution should be handled by the society itself.
For example : say you have a 1000 crore turnover company and you have a policy that all net profits are distributed among employees based on merit. nobody is going to stop you. here government has no role to play and government should not be forcing such rules on anybody else.
Democracy is fundamentally about rights of the people and rights of the people is not decoupled from their economic condition. Therefore it is naive to think that democracy and economy are not related. There is nothing wrong with a capitalist democracy; such form of governance is fine for some countries. Whether it is practiced in an authoritarian or democratic society, issue with capitalism is that it needs poor to support rich. In a country with smaller population and powerful military, capitalism may be able to support a larger rich population by exploiting international resources. This system is not going to work for a country like India which has an extremely large population and somewhat weaker military. Even if India had a very strong military, in order to support 1B rich Indians, the entire world population has to be convinced to part with their wealth. This is simply not possible. Therefore, India's rich can only be supported by India's poor. This leaves India with an extremely large population of disenfranchised people. This is not an ideal condition for any nation. The concept of wealth redistribution is a product of capitalist thought process because in a capitalist society there have to be poor and, if there are poor, there has to be a system of wealth redistribution to prevent widespread buildup of resentment.

India is in a unique situation and therefore it warrants a unique solution. Existing models of governance such as democratic capitalism, authoritarian capitalism, secular dictatorship, religious dictatorship, etc. are not ideal for India. India needs a system which I call socialist democracy. This system is not about wealth distribution or redistribution. It is about collective management of national resources under the auspices of a very strong democratic institution. Under this system, every person will work towards a collective goal. The family you were born in will provide neither advantage nor disadvantage.

I am practical enough to know that even mere proposal of such a system will ruffle some serious feathers but for India there is no other way out.
 
Last edited:

TejasMK3

Regular Member
Joined
May 13, 2015
Messages
610
Likes
3,454
Country flag
Even if India had a very strong military, in order to support 1B rich Indians, the entire world population has to be convinced to part with their wealth.
That is the challenge of statecraft. If the world can part with their wealth to support nobodies in Europe they can very well do the same for Indians. Not to forget, Indians were highly prosperous in the past and the world was perfectly okay.
 

Gaurav Rai

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Apr 10, 2017
Messages
307
Likes
508
Country flag
Those Theoretical ideas of "Absolute democracy" don't work in real world. Moreover when you bring in the concept of Rich/Poor, you are actually talking about economy not democracy. If you are saying india needs to do better at income redistribution, then answer is yes. What does democracy has to do with it?

I always believe there is a bit confusion in the minds of people about democracy/government and it's utility. there is a misunderstanding that democracy and government is there to govern our lives, government should exist to govern only specific tasks of society so that it runs smoothly.

In my opinion things like income redistribution should be handled by the society itself.
For example : say you have a 1000 crore turnover company and you have a policy that all net profits are distributed among employees based on merit. nobody is going to stop you. here government has no role to play and government should not be forcing such rules on anybody else.
Best reply read today so far.

30 characters.................................
 

Gaurav Rai

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Apr 10, 2017
Messages
307
Likes
508
Country flag
Found something really interesting while observing world leaders.

Unless people are blind there is a clear pattern emerging against RW populist leaders.

Trump - Russiagate/Tax Fraud FDNY Attempted Replacement : Marco Rubio, Rand Paul

Modi - Rafale deal Attempted Replacement : Nitin Gadkari

Netanyahu - Corruption Attempted Replacement : Lieberman , Benny Gantz, Ayelet Shaked

Heinz-Christian Strache- Corruption/Russiagate Attempted Replacement : Norbert Hofer

Boris Johnson - Brexit Case Attempted Replacement : Nigel Farage
We all know that.
,.........................................
 

Gaurav Rai

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Apr 10, 2017
Messages
307
Likes
508
Country flag
Democracy is fundamentally about rights of the people and rights of the people is not decoupled from their economic condition. Therefore it is naive to think that democracy and economy are not related. There is nothing wrong with a capitalist democracy; such form of governance is fine for some countries. Whether it is practiced in an authoritarian or democratic society, issue with capitalism is that it needs poor to support rich. In a country with smaller population and powerful military, capitalism may be able to support a larger rich population by exploiting international resources. This system is not going to work for a country like India which has an extremely large population and somewhat weaker military. Even if India had a very strong military, in order to support 1B rich Indians, the entire world population has to be convinced to part with their wealth. This is simply not possible. Therefore, India's rich can only be supported by India's poor. This leaves India with an extremely large population of disenfranchised people. This is not an ideal condition for any nation. The concept of wealth redistribution is a product of capitalist thought process because in a capitalist society there have to be poor and, if there are poor, there has to be a system of wealth redistribution to prevent widespread buildup of resentment.

India is in a unique situation and therefore it warrants a unique solution. Existing models of governance such as democratic capitalism, authoritarian capitalism, secular dictatorship, religious dictatorship, etc. are not ideal for India. India needs a system which I call socialist democracy. This system is not about wealth distribution or redistribution. It is about collective management of national resources under the auspices of a very strong democratic institution. Under this system, every person will work towards a collective goal. The family you were born in will provide neither advantage nor disadvantage.

I am practical enough to know that even mere proposal of such a system will ruffle some serious feathers but for India there is no other way out.
Capitalism is the only way forward for betterment of lives of 1b people. We have had enough of experiments with us economically. Let us now grow in capitalist manner. Let some other nation try and experiment any unique solution, if it gets successful elsewhere then we may attempt it otherwise capitalism is the best way for now forward with free market economics. Only capitalism is the real "ism" rest socialism and communism are false constructs of deluded lazy minds. Capitalism is the most natural form of economics which has remained fruitful for nations since ancient times.
 

indiatester

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2013
Messages
5,856
Likes
20,249
Country flag
One step in right direction:


No foreign funds for farmer or student organisations participating in party politics
Bharti Jain / TNN / Updated: Nov 12, 2020, 09:11 IST



NEW DELHI: After introducing a more stringent regime for foreign-funded NGOs and associations with recent amendments to the Foreign Contribution Regulation Act, 2010, the government has now revised the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Rules, 2011 to make them stricter.
The rules require all entities seeking registration or prior permission under FCRA to be in existence for three years and having spent a minimum Rs 15 lakh on its core activities for the benefit of society during the last three financial years.
Importantly, the new rules add a sub-rule to Rule 3, stating that organisations specified under clauses (v) and (vi) of sub-rule 1 -- which cover organisation of farmers, workers, students, caste and community-based organisations not directly aligned to parties but which advance political interests of such groups, as well as outfits that habitually engage in political action like bandhs, hartal, rasta roko -- shall be considered of political nature if they participate in party politics. Entites of political nature are barred from receiving foreign contributions.
The new rules have also increased the application fee for grant of registration under FCRA to Rs 5,000 from Rs 3,000, and for grant of prior permission to Rs 10,000 from Rs 5,000; also, the fee to be paid with application for renewal of FCRA registration has also been fixed at Rs 5,000. Such fee should be submitted through a payment gateway. If no application for renewal of registration is received or the application is not accompanied by the requisite fee before the expiry of validity of the certificate of registration, such validity shall be deemed to have ceased from the date of completion of five years from the date of the grant of certificate of registration, as per the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) (Amendment) Rules, 2020 notified on Wednesday.
The Central government, in exceptional cases or in cases where a person is controlled by the Central government or a state government may waive the conditions requiring entities applying for registration/prior permission under FCRA to be in existence for three years and having spent Rs 15 lakh on its core activities aimed at benefit of the society for past three years. If an entity wants inclusion of its existing capital investment in assets like land, building, other permanent structures, vehicles, equipment in the computation of its spending during last three years, then the chief functionary shall give an undertaking that the assets shall be vested henceforth with the person till the validity of the certificate and they shall be utilised only for the activities covered under the Act and the rules made thereunder and shall not be diverted for any other purpose.
A person seeking prior permission for receipt of a specific amount from a specific donor for carrying out specific activities or projects, under the new rules, must submit a specific commitment letter from the donor indicating the amount of foreign contribution and the purpose for which it is proposed to be given. For the Indian recipient and foreign donor organisations having common members, prior permission shall be granted to the person provided the chief functionary of the recipient NGO is not a part of the donor organisation and 75% of the office-bearers or members of the governing body of the NGO are not members or employees of the foreign donor organisation. In case of foreign donor organisation being a single individual that individual shall not be the chief functionary or office bearer of the recipient person; and in case of a single foreign donor, 75% of the office bearers or members of the governing body of the recipient person shall not be the family members or close relatives of the donor.
In the new rules, after rule 9, a new rule 9A shall be inserted to regulate permission for receipt of foreign contribution in application for obtaining prior permission. If the value of foreign contribution on the date of final disposal of an application for obtaining prior permission exceeds Rs 1 crore, the Central government may permit receipt of foreign contribution in such instalments, as it may deem fit: provided that the second and subsequent instalment shall be released after submission of proof of utilisation of 75% of the foreign contribution received in the previous instalment and after field inquiry of the utilisation of foreign contribution.”
The fee to be paid along with application for the compounding of an offence under Section 41 has also been doubled to Rs 3,000 from Rs 1,500 earlier, and shall be submitted electronically.
 

indiatester

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2013
Messages
5,856
Likes
20,249
Country flag

26 Bank Accounts of OM India & 6 other FCRA registered Christian NGOs frozen by Telangana CID
By
vskteam
-

http://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https://vsktelangana.org/26-bank-accounts-of-fcra-registered-christian-ngos-frozen-by-cid&media=https://vsktelangana.org/demo/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/OMFIm.jpg


The Economic Offences Wing of the Telangana Crime Investigation Department has reportedly frozen 26 bank accounts that belong to Operation Mobilization Trust and its group of Christian Charity organizations on 21st November 2020 based on criminal complaints lodged by Mr. Albert Lael, former Chief Finance Officer of Operation Mobilization India group of charities.

Mr. Albert Lael, who is also the National director of 103 Good Shepherd Schools, has filed criminal complaints with the Criminal Investigation Department against Mr. Joseph D’Souza, his son Josh D’Souza and several others. Mr. Joseph D’Souza is the President of Christian evangelical organization, Operation Mobilization, and several other entities such as ‘Operation Mercy India Foundation’, Dignity Freedom Network (erstwhile Dalit Freedom Network), Good Shepherd Schools and All India Christian Council.

As per a post made on the Facebook page named “OM Justice Seekers”, the Crime Investigation Department, in their notice vide notice no. U/S 91 & 160 Cr.P.C, stated that during the course of an earlier ongoing investigation, the CID Police found that the accused persons have received huge amounts from abroad in the name of donations for running their charity activities, which are deposited into FDs. In order to stop this misappropriation of funds and other further diversion, the CID Police has frozen the 26 bank accounts of eight FCRA-registered Christian Organizations, including OM India.

Curiously, none of the big media houses showed interest in reporting the huge financial fraud connected with foreign funds of Christian evangelical organisations, even after the CID officially froze their accounts.

 

sorcerer

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2013
Messages
26,919
Likes
98,471
Country flag
Amnesty International India's Assets Attached In Money Laundering Case





The Enforcement Directorate has attached the movable properties - worth ₹ 17.66 crore - of the global human rights advocacy group, Amnesty International, which had last year claimed that it was halting its India operation because of alleged "witch-hunt" by the central government. The action has been taken as part of a money laundering probe against the non-profit.

The central government says that the global rights watchdog had been receiving foreign funds illegally and that it had never registered under the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act.

The government has raided Amnesty India's premises several times in the last few years.

 

sorcerer

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2013
Messages
26,919
Likes
98,471
Country flag
FCRA approval for 6 NGOs suspended | India News - Times of India
Bharti Jain / TNN / Sep 13, 2021, 05:31 IST

3 minutes


NEW DELHI: The home ministry has over the past one-and-a-half months suspended the foreign funding licence of six NGOs, which includes Christian evangelist groups and Islamic charities allegedly linked to religious conversion or funds misutilization, citing violations of the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, 2010. With these actions, the total number of organisations whose FCRA registration has been suspended so far this year has gone up to nine.

 

tarunraju

Sanathan Pepe
Mod
Joined
Sep 18, 2009
Messages
9,080
Likes
40,077
Country flag
Why can't this plant be simply relocated to a friendlier state like Karnataka or Telangana, with railways handling ore transport?

If Modi was the fascist he's accused of being, he'd flip a bird at the SC citing national security, convert the entire taluq where the plant is located into a union territory, and deploy central forces with shoot-at-sight orders to secure the plant.
 

anoop_mig25

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2009
Messages
5,804
Likes
3,151
Country flag
Why can't this plant be simply relocated to a friendlier state like Karnataka or Telangana, with railways handling ore transport?
Those state in first palce should be ready to allot land for plant...

Considering negative PR associated with none of above state would come fwd anticipating similar protest.

Also Firm has not fought case in SC but is waiting for gov to binding for them which is not helping it

and even relocating might caught them more money so it is also no moving

Rest Indian establishment (read baboddom) are myopic one cannot help but simply bang there head on wall
 

Cheran

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 8, 2019
Messages
8,937
Likes
78,437
Country flag

Government puts ten foreign NGOs related to environmental and child labour activism, including Omidyar Network, under FCRA watchlist

When asked about the reason behind the inclusion of several environmental NGOs in the PRC list, an official was quoted saying that “global pressures are intensifying on India to raise the Nationally Determined Contributions”.

1631638863264.png


1631638906828.png
 

Blademaster

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2009
Messages
9,406
Likes
27,352
they are invaders from Asia. They are not native. They couldn't work metal so they certainly didn't make those big stone pyramids and cities. Pyramids of Egypt were made by the NOMES (Gnomes). Read about ancient egypt. btw Good luck with your cries of racism and equality...Dalits of India.
So that's your justification for subjugating those races that had been there thousands of years before you guys came? Wow talk about a double standard right there.

And you are just flinging out crap to deflect your own shortcomings that were rightly called upon.

As for the Dalits, they have rights and freedom under the constitution and have been represented in the Parliament and even reached the corridors of powers. And please don't tell me that they received better treatment under the British occupation. They didn't so you got no leg to stand on there.
 

Blademaster

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2009
Messages
9,406
Likes
27,352
Catholics slaughtered them. You can't even get that correct. Trying to deflect blame in an effort to live off of others. We see you. We see all of you.
No. Completely bullshit. There was no Catholics among the English settlers and they were mostly protestants. You are the one trying to deflect blame. Your country owns this genocide. We got it correct. And we completely see right through you.

You are no friend of India. You are one of those white people that seek to divide and conquer and keep us as "brown sepoys". You are trolling on this website and your ass needs to be booted off this forum and you go back to whatever racist group you come from.
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top