New Assault Rifles for Indian Army

Which Contender`s Rifle has more chances of winning than others?


  • Total voters
    390

SilentlAssassin265

New Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2019
Messages
2,074
Likes
5,874
Country flag
OFB/ARDE alone must’ve showcased almost half a dozen different carbine designs over the last 20 years not to mention SSS’s portfolio but nothing is ever good enough for these guys

all hail the 1930s 9mm carbine
That ww2 gun with magzine on side which was used by Bollywood villains in 80's
 

Johny_Baba

अज्ञानी
New Member
Joined
May 21, 2016
Messages
3,966
Likes
20,402
Country flag
Sorry If I missed it any reason for killing DRDO assault rifle , The design looked promising. and suddenly everything went off the radar.

View attachment 187684
It was good but not without flaws, one of them likely be a very fatal one as i mentioned here in past...
BTW this pattern of exposed Camming Pin + Camming Surface that too on its Ejection Port was one of those things i immensely hated about MCIWS//AAR

View attachment 63788

Like seriously WTF these are among the critical working mechanisms of a self loading rifle and they are keeping it exposed ? Forget Inrange TV Pattern Mud Tests,it won't be able to tolerate dust or sand accumulation on its bolt carrier in sandy environment of Thar

Imagine designing a firearm in 21st Century and still making such elementary mistake of not keeping working parts or mechanisms sealed and safe from outside gunk :facepalm: oh and yes they aren't even providing a dust cover on its ejection port so making it even worser

If you'd compare it to AR-15 ( has got dust cover and even when dust cover is open its bolt carrier is sealed enough to keep outside stuff away from working parts ) and K-2 (doesn't have dust cover but bolt carrier is sealing its ejection port well enough) this is failing in both way. I would say even AK (or INSAS) is better sealed than this design as at least bolt carrier is effectively covering its camming surfaces sealed.
but yeah it very well could've become our Daewoo K-2 like rifle here
 

Johny_Baba

अज्ञानी
New Member
Joined
May 21, 2016
Messages
3,966
Likes
20,402
Country flag
Literally the Star Wars gun. Maybe IA generals think it’s space agency because they saw it in the films
got adopted much much before muh soywars thing,
saw action in '71 war too,
it mainly happened because we were following brits in small arms and tactics
- adopted 1A SLR
- adopted revolvers, later browning hi-power pistol
- adopted bren LMG
- adopted MAG 58 MMG
- adopted Sterling "9mm Carbine"
- adopted fookin' bayonet on fookin' everything
 

Hari Sud

New Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2012
Messages
3,945
Likes
8,863
Country flag
All the worthy military experts in this forum have not taken up the question I asked about a week, that is ….. Has the first AK203 rifle come out of the Indian factory at Amethi. Some round about answers were their but not with enough conviction of yes or no.

I am guessing that no AK203 has come out of Amethi. My question again is that …. Are Russians delaying the project implementation? Has Ukraine war anything to with that? Is inefficiency and bureaucratic muddle in India has anything to do with that? Did the Russians get the right price or they are struggling to come to the grips of selling their best rifle too cheap?

It is pain to find out soon that the project will not be implemented. Do we have a L2 in mind in case the Russians walk away, although I doubt it.

A smarter person is needed to answer these Questions.
 

SilentlAssassin265

New Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2019
Messages
2,074
Likes
5,874
Country flag
All the worthy military experts in this forum have not taken up the question I asked about a week, that is ….. Has the first AK203 rifle come out of the Indian factory at Amethi. Some round about answers were their but not with enough conviction of yes or no.

I am guessing that no AK203 has come out of Amethi. My question again is that …. Are Russians delaying the project implementation? Has Ukraine war anything to with that? Is inefficiency and bureaucratic muddle in India has anything to do with that? Did the Russians get the right price or they are struggling to come to the grips of selling their best rifle too cheap?

It is pain to find out soon that the project will not be implemented. Do we have a L2 in mind in case the Russians walk away, although I doubt it.

A smarter person is needed to answer these Questions.
No
 

Kuldeepm952

New Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2019
Messages
947
Likes
4,969
Country flag
It's not started as ruskies are not providing spare parts, and do you really expect Import army or MOD babus to have backup plan
All this when ruskies have started to offer their new buttstock for AK203 rifle, mark my words that they will soon offer new trigger guard as well and call it AK203M.
My mind says that old generals have gone senile as the AK we are getting is neither Uber not so cheap, we are literally being milked, US gets its AR cheaper than we'll be getting these AKs and I don't expect price to go cheaper since ruskies need Mooney. All the MoD guys and Gernails went to Russia in Kalashnikov factory, saw all the AKs and decided to buy watered down AK203🤷‍♂️.
But serious question, does a 3 trillion dollar economy having a good enough growth rate for now has not enough money to get a gun which will be good for atleast next 20 yrs? Or maybe IA leadership thought what benefit in giving a modular gun to poor chap in infantry?

Representative picture of new buttstock and trigger guard on Ak12, also now offered on Ak203
1672374432102.png


RIP to our infantry guys, the most neglected branch in IA🥲. Everybody likes tanks, arty but nobody likes infantry 😭
 

SilentlAssassin265

New Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2019
Messages
2,074
Likes
5,874
Country flag
All this when ruskies have started to offer their new buttstock for AK203 rifle, mark my words that they will soon offer new trigger guard as well and call it AK203M.
My mind says that old generals have gone senile as the AK we are getting is neither Uber not so cheap, we are literally being milked, US gets its AR cheaper than we'll be getting these AKs and I don't expect price to go cheaper since ruskies need Mooney. All the MoD guys and Gernails went to Russia in Kalashnikov factory, saw all the AKs and decided to buy watered down AK203🤷‍♂️.
But serious question, does a 3 trillion dollar economy having a good enough growth rate for now has not enough money to get a gun which will be good for atleast next 20 yrs? Or maybe IA leadership thought what benefit in giving a modular gun to poor chap in infantry?

Representative picture of new buttstock and trigger guard on Ak12, also now offered on Ak203
View attachment 187723

RIP to our infantry guys, the most neglected branch in IA🥲. Everybody likes tanks, arty but nobody likes infantry 😭
And the worst thing is that same circus will be going on for 3 lakh+ carbine order as the army want 5.56x45 carbine.
We will be the only country in the world who will use russian rifle and western carbine in same force
 

Immanuel

New Member
Joined
May 16, 2011
Messages
3,605
Likes
7,574
Country flag
I think may be local production hasn't begun yet since we are asking for more improvements, I at least hope that's the case.
 

jai jaganath

New Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2022
Messages
5,975
Likes
10,474
Country flag
All this when ruskies have started to offer their new buttstock for AK203 rifle, mark my words that they will soon offer new trigger guard as well and call it AK203M.
My mind says that old generals have gone senile as the AK we are getting is neither Uber not so cheap, we are literally being milked, US gets its AR cheaper than we'll be getting these AKs and I don't expect price to go cheaper since ruskies need Mooney. All the MoD guys and Gernails went to Russia in Kalashnikov factory, saw all the AKs and decided to buy watered down AK203🤷‍♂️.
But serious question, does a 3 trillion dollar economy having a good enough growth rate for now has not enough money to get a gun which will be good for atleast next 20 yrs? Or maybe IA leadership thought what benefit in giving a modular gun to poor chap in infantry?

Representative picture of new buttstock and trigger guard on Ak12, also now offered on Ak203
View attachment 187723

RIP to our infantry guys, the most neglected branch in IA🥲. Everybody likes tanks, arty but nobody likes infantry 😭
After so many such incidences
One thing is clear that our gernails no idea about today's world
It feels they are completely out of touch with today's development even if they come in contact with it they ignore it by thinking that it's just show off
Basically superiority complex
Literally uneducated regarding comfort and accessories
Corruption infeciency comes next primary problem is they don't feel problem
 

fooLIam

New Member
Joined
Jan 25, 2016
Messages
871
Likes
2,806
After so many such incidences
One thing is clear that our gernails no idea about today's world
It feels they are completely out of touch with today's development even if they come in contact with it they ignore it by thinking that it's just show off
Basically superiority complex
Literally uneducated regarding comfort and accessories
Corruption infeciency comes next primary problem is they don't feel problem
First problem seems to be incompetency. Corruption comes later and it does seems these guys have no idea of industrial warfare let alone how to nurture MIC.These guys seems to be in their own la-la land.
While there is no acedmic study on Indian armed forces officer corps but I am in favour of overhauling entire officer cader and their training.
 

Articles

Top