- Joined
- May 26, 2010
- Messages
- 31,122
- Likes
- 41,041
3 large carriers ( Vikrant, Vikramaditya, Vishal ) , 4 small-medium carriers ( Amphibious assault ships ) ..
Kunal sir is correct we are not going to build anymore Huge Carriers for Next 20 years after completions of IAC 2 Vishaal. but we may invest in 20000 Ton LHD/LPD typeKunal I dont know whether you can operate LHD/LPD like A/C on year round patrol basis so I would have thought 2 Medium A/C (40000-45000 tonnes) in the Bay of Bengal and 2 Large A/C (65000 + Tonnes) in the IOR and Arabian Ocean.
Those 4 LHD/LPD are going to be special assault ops vessels so they have a different mission profile and functions!! I am however very happy that IN is going for them.... I hope and pray they have fixed wing Aircrafts besides the choppers and more capable
US provided the French with steam catapult to use in their AC .Do not put too much faith on DTTI in which the COTOBAR will be used. US has not parted with this technology to anyone. So hold your breath. Rejoice less and look for an alternative, if US does not give this technology. Otherwise it will be Raffale deal all over again and India will be left with no choices but delay beyond expectations.
Dear Sajeev,Kunal sir is correct we are not going to build anymore Huge Carriers for Next 20 years after completions of IAC 2 Vishaal. but we may invest in 20000 Ton LHD/LPD type
Problem with A/C is that to keep one on station, you need minimum three A/C in service so that refit and repair, training and other issues can work seamlessly. So six carriers mean, IN will be able to deploy two permanently in Bay of Bengal and Arabian Sea. Seems to me that IN is aiming to bring this operating ratio to 2:1.Dear Sajeev,
I read the below mentioned article where Rear Admiral (Retd) Ravi Vohra has been quoted saying IN wants 5 A/C!! That is why I said 4 will be more than enough...2 Medium and 2 Large (Nuclear + EMALS)
India eyes US aircraft carrier technology as arms ties deepen - Economic Times
India eyes US aircraft carrier technology as arms ties deepen
Reuters Feb 4, 2015, 03.40PM IST
NEW DELHI: India wants to use state-of-the-art US technology to boost the range and potency of a planned aircraft carrier, defence sources said, in a move that would tie their arms programmes closer together and counter China's military influence in the region.
The proposal, referred to only obliquely in a joint statement at the end of President Barack Obama's recent visit to New Delhi, is the clearest signal yet that Washington is ready to help India strengthen its navy.
Although the aircraft carrier in question would not be ready for at least another decade, such cooperation could act as a balance against China's expanding presence in the Indian Ocean.
It would also represent a shift away from India's traditional reliance on Russian military hardware, particularly if, as some experts expect, it leads to knock-on orders for US aircraft in the longer term.
After years of neglect, India's navy is in the midst of accelerated modernisation under Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
It inducted an old aircraft carrier from Russia in 2014 to add to an ageing British vessel likely to be decommissioned in 2018. Last year, soon after taking office, Modi cleared funds to ensure another carrier being built domestically was ready for service in 2018.
He also endorsed navy plans for a further carrier which would be its biggest, and it is this one that may be built with US technology, a defence ministry source and two former navy vice admirals with ties to the naval establishment said.
The joint statement by Obama and Modi spoke of a "working group to explore aircraft carrier technology sharing and design" as part of the Defense Trade and Technology Initiative.
Defence officials said this could lead to direct US participation in building the 65,000-tonne INS Vishal carrier.
"The US navy is the only one that operates large carriers today, so we are looking at what they can offer, what is possible," the defence source said.
MORE, BIGGER AIRCRAFT
Former vice admiral Arun Kumar Singh said naval planners want a carrier that can launch heavier planes, and the only way to do that is from flat decks which US carriers have instead of Russian "ski-jump" decks.
"The Americans, I believe, have said 'ok, we will help you design a ship and you also buy our catapults' to launch aircraft," he said.
Former rear admiral Ravi Vohra said the Indian navy's ultimate objective was a five-carrier fleet comprising a mix of large and small carriers.
At the heart of the proposed collaboration is a US offer to share the Electromagnetic Aircraft Launch System (EMALS) developed by General Atomics and which is now being installed on the Gerald R. Ford class of carriers that are joining the navy.
The new system means jets can launch off a flat deck at a faster rate and with less fatigue to aircraft.
US defence and industry officials said sensitivities over selling advanced EMALS technology to India meant any major movement on the carrier question was unlikely in the near term.
Two sources familiar with the issue added that the US response to Indian overtures had been cool until very recently.
"Things are finally beginning to look a lot more positive," said one of the sources, who was not authorized to speak publicly.
For India it is a big leap. Its existing carrier force uses ski-jump ramps to help planes take off and brings them in using wires to slow them down. For that reason, planes have to be lighter and are fewer in number.
With an EMALS system on a flat deck, India's navy planners hope to increase the number of aircraft on board the INS Vishal to 50 from 34 and field heavier fighter jets with longer reach as well as airborne early warning aircraft.
"EMALS is one of the most revolutionary things in carrier technology because it completely changes the way you fire a plane off the top of a ship," said James Hardy, Asia-Pacific Editor for IHS Jane's Defence Weekly.
"The Chinese have been talking about getting it for their carriers for a long time ... but it's quite a big technological ask."
CHINESE FORAYS WORRY INDIA
The Indian defence source said representatives of General Atomics showed the technology to members of a Naval Design Bureau working on the next-generation carrier back in 2013.
The defence ministry declined to comment.
China is operating a lone carrier, the 60,000-tonne Liaoning bought from Ukraine, but reports have circulated of a second carrier under development.
China wants to develop an ocean-going "blue water" navy capable of defending its interests as it adopts a more assertive stance in territorial disputes with neighbours in the South China Sea.
Modi has sought to improve ties with China, seeing it as a vital economic partner.
But the government has been rattled by Chinese naval forays in the Indian Ocean, including when a submarine docked last year in Sri Lanka.
Vijay Sakhuja, director of defence ministry-funded National Maritime Foundation think-tank, said US involvement in the flight-launch technology of an Indian carrier could lead to future deals for US aircraft makers.
"It is early days yet, but once we get this carrier deck technology from the US, maybe there will be a joint development of fighter jets to be operated out of it."
In India's case, the Bolded part (above) never happens. No threshold is ever breached in India's case, no matter what you do to us.Finally, irrespective of the hoopla around ASBM or cruise missiles, A/carriers would become the key platform for IN in future. No matter what the cynics say, sinking an A/Carrier with 5,000 personnel, multiple aircraft and immense national pride is difficult as well as a headache for any adversary, especially if the carrier owner is a nuclear weapon state. The nuclear threshold would become blurred in any such event.
Nice .. my Wishlist too :clap:Indian Navy is planning to have 6 Aircraft Carriers & 5-9 LPD/LHD by 2040. The size of 6 Aircraft Carriers will be :- 1,10,000 tonnes(IAC-V), 1,00,000 tonnes(IAC-IV), 85,000 tonnes(IAC-III), 65,000 tonnes(IAC-II), 45,000 tonnes(INS Vikramaditya), 40,000 tonnes(IAC-I). While Indian Navy will have 4 LPD/LHD of 30,000-40,000 tonnes, 3 LPD/LHD of 25,000 tonnes, 2 LPD/LHD of 15,000-20,000 tonnes. Indian Navy may emerge as a Global Blue-Water Navy & may pose a serious threat to other great rising naval power from Asia, the PLA-Navy beyond 2030.
Your numbers look right but size of ships look like a bhel-puri mixture. I don't think any acquisition in 20-30,000 ton for LPD/LHD is in process or expected to be. IN wants 40,000 ton LHDs straightforward, no smaller ones for learning business or such. In carriers, if IN goes for six types of deadweight, it will be a nightmare logistically. Do you have any proof of your statements?Indian Navy is planning to have 6 Aircraft Carriers & 5-9 LPD/LHD by 2040. The size of 6 Aircraft Carriers will be :- 1,10,000 tonnes(IAC-V), 1,00,000 tonnes(IAC-IV), 85,000 tonnes(IAC-III), 65,000 tonnes(IAC-II), 45,000 tonnes(INS Vikramaditya), 40,000 tonnes(IAC-I). While Indian Navy will have 4 LPD/LHD of 30,000-40,000 tonnes, 3 LPD/LHD of 25,000 tonnes, 2 LPD/LHD of 15,000-20,000 tonnes. Indian Navy may emerge as a Global Blue-Water Navy & may pose a serious threat to other great rising naval power from Asia, the PLA-Navy beyond 2030.
Someone should advise Admiral RK Dhowan that he needs to increase the size of INS Vishal to 85,000 ton full load. An aircraft carrier with 65,000 ton would be similar to Chinese Liaoning carrier which is facing problems in carrying enough Su-33/J-15 size fighters with their full load. Same problem is there with Russian Kuznetsov carrier. The fighter size is increasing day by day and in future, 30 ton fighters may be needed to fly from carriers. This 65,000 ton carrier is horribly unsuited for this role.
65,000 is just the approx proposed tonnage. Dont be surprised if the Carrier goes over 70,000 tons when the construction ends.Someone should advise Admiral RK Dhowan that he needs to increase the size of INS Vishal to 85,000 ton full load. An aircraft carrier with 65,000 ton would be similar to Chinese Liaoning carrier which is facing problems in carrying enough Su-33/J-15 size fighters with their full load. Same problem is there with Russian Kuznetsov carrier. The fighter size is increasing day by day and in future, 30 ton fighters may be needed to fly from carriers. This 65,000 ton carrier is horribly unsuited for this role.
Moreover, an aircraft carrier will have a life of 45-50 years and India cannot afford to go through building 45,000 ton then 65,000 ton and then 85,000 ton and finally 100,000 ton carrier in a row. It doesn't have that much of a defence budget for so many experimentational options to learn and perfect. Indian Navy will have to leapfrog in terms of technology, similar to what it is doing in terms of going for nuclear propulsion and EMALS.
An aircraft carrier with 85,000 ton full load will be able to carry 70+ aircraft which will be enough for Indian requirement. It will be nimble enough to maneuver while large enough to carry everything onboard. The incorporation of EMALS, nuke energy and heavy fighters will make it a force to reckon with. Indian Navy will not need to further experiment in increasing the size of its carriers. The experience gained in building INS Vishal of 85,000 ton can be used in further build of five more carriers of similar size. Then, INS Vikrant and INS Vikram can shift to local area/near seas sea control duties or supporting future 40,000 ton LHDs while INS Vishal class will become the flagship of Indian Navy.
So Mr. Dhowan, Indian Navy needs its INS Vishal to be of 85,000 ton size full load like USS Kennedy (CV 67 ) and not of 65,000 ton like CNS Liaoning.
Those Gentle man's Rohit and Divine is correct we don't know the design as of now, so how can we put the 65K weight line.Someone should advise Admiral RK Dhowan that he needs to increase the size of INS Vishal to 85,000 ton full load. An aircraft carrier with 65,000 ton would be similar to Chinese Liaoning carrier which is facing problems in carrying enough Su-33/J-15 size fighters with their full load. Same problem is there with Russian Kuznetsov carrier. The fighter size is increasing day by day and in future, 30 ton fighters may be needed to fly from carriers. This 65,000 ton carrier is horribly unsuited for this role.
Moreover, an aircraft carrier will have a life of 45-50 years and India cannot afford to go through building 45,000 ton then 65,000 ton and then 85,000 ton and finally 100,000 ton carrier in a row. It doesn't have that much of a defence budget for so many experimentational options to learn and perfect. Indian Navy will have to leapfrog in terms of technology, similar to what it is doing in terms of going for nuclear propulsion and EMALS.
An aircraft carrier with 85,000 ton full load will be able to carry 70+ aircraft which will be enough for Indian requirement. It will be nimble enough to maneuver while large enough to carry everything onboard. The incorporation of EMALS, nuke energy and heavy fighters will make it a force to reckon with. Indian Navy will not need to further experiment in increasing the size of its carriers. The experience gained in building INS Vishal of 85,000 ton can be used in further build of five more carriers of similar size. Then, INS Vikrant and INS Vikram can shift to local area/near seas sea control duties or supporting future 40,000 ton LHDs while INS Vishal class will become the flagship of Indian Navy.
So Mr. Dhowan, Indian Navy needs its INS Vishal to be of 85,000 ton size full load like USS Kennedy (CV 67 ) and not of 65,000 ton like CNS Liaoning.
@DivineHeretic you have summed up expected capabilities beautifully.Those Gentle man's Rohit and Divine is correct we don't know the design as of now, so how can we put the 65K weight line.
and you know the French Carrier which is less than 45 K running on Nuke Power can able to Handle 40 Aircraft in Combat operation mode
She is the tenth French aircraft carrier, the first French nuclear-powered surface vessel, and the first and so far only nuclear-powered carrier completed outside of the United States Navy.
Nope, French future carrier. They have been showing this particular model for years.INS Vishal:
With a 65,000 tonne displacement, Flat deck configuration, Dual-core Nuclear propulsion system and 65 aircrafts on board INS Vishal will be ready to rule Eastern Naval Command by 2020 !