Again creating excuses by cherry picking data to suite your narrative. No the reason for the conflict in the Northeast is due to influx of illegal muslim Bangladeshis and uprooting the culture there. The approach I advocate is entirely something else.
NRC, 1971 conflict and plight of East Pakistani Hindus once made India loose it's security, and get a never ending mess in East and Northeast whose trembles are even felt in Delhi.
Pakistani border meanwhile always remained tight with guns which allowed entry to barely anyone. Still many Pakistani Muslims secretly migrate to Punjab, live as Hindus (and sometimes get caught in some crime and are identified). Fall out of idiocy on western border will be far more catastrophic than that was in East.
Again you keep coming with made up or false narratives. Yes there exists a practical screening to separate the Hindus.
Explain with elaboration on process, accuracy, time period and financial viability.
Now who is coming up with fallacies? You think that the Indian civil service is not capable of weeding out the fake hindus from real hindus. You seem to think that Indian people are very incompetent. Again creating excuses for not doing anything.
Which world you are living in? Where dogs can sniff out anyone from their thing from miles away? Or where ISRO can land humans on moon tomorrow if has budget? This is not a cartoon animation or movie going on. You can't read a prepared imposter human. He will know more about Hinduism than those oppressed, uneducated and poor Hindus who don't have time for anything except arranging for their daily breads.
No, Indian services can't weed out Hindus from Muslims if Muslims or Pakistani state has decided to send them to India. They can't accurately separate Christians and Muslims within India itself. And this is not incompetency, this is a very difficult thing to do and isn't taken up anywhere in world. Fake passports, fake immigrants are a global reality and India will become a living furnace if Pakis become the migrants here. There will be nothing except blooded bodies of India Hindus on roads if such things go ahead.
Wrong. By protecting Hindus it helps the security of India and its citizens
No, it doesn't. What are you drinking?
because it sends a strong message to the rest of the world and its own citizens that India is fully capable and willing to protect Hindus just as Israel have done so.
Neither Israel nor India can and do anything more than expressing anger on plight on beyond the frontier Jews and Hindus.
Most of Western Jews and Hindus anyway disgust Israel and India. Nor there is any Indian state policy to be thekedar of Hindus everywhere. So sit down.
Whose fault is that? Certainly not BJP but at the hands of Congress.
It's fault of every party. Pakistani Hindus won't leave their property for 100 years if it isn't destroyed for 100 years. So India must open borders for 100 years LOL?
Bharat Mata is only a cash cow and land of opportunity only when there is no other way. Government needs to care more about people who migrated within first 10 years of partition and have built entire goddman cities with high revenue for them. There must be a state policy about criteria of accepting people who already have came in and borders must be closed thereafter so that a proper screening and census of Indian population can take place and India heads towards being a fully formalized and recorded developed country.
You conveniently left out Israel.
They don't do that.
And you left out certain examples where countries have taken certain tribes such as America rehabilitating tens of thousands of people from Somalia or the boat people from Vietnam. Making sweeping broad generalization does not help your argument.
LOL? West took in hundreds of Vietnamese and Somalis en-masse at once from their land without filtering. You wanna take Pakis en-masse?
This is what a weak man with no moral center will say. Always looking for a way out or excuses not to do anything. You have the mentality of a crab willing to pull others down because you are just afraid.
If this is all about moral characteristics, India must open borders for every supposedly oppressed community and turn this country into a bloody zoo LOL.
You are willfully acting as an idiot living in fairy tales who thinks everything is so simple and every potential problem is just an excuse. You just think that you have become smart and saviour of Hindus by questioning the intentions of world's largest Hindutva movement.
Ha ha ha ha ha ha!!!! Coming up with insults and looking to put down others who dare to propose solutions without offering anything and therefore keeping the status quo as it is. Sounds familiar?
This is intended not as an insult. You are actually having tone like a 12 years old.
And again, besides these words, I have elaborated every repercussion while you have conveniently rejected everything as an excuse and are dreaming of a simple solution.
Yes, this logical fallacy is a characteristic of kids before they become teenagers. All your post is pure emotional with absence of any kind of logics which makes me think you are an immature teenager or even younger.
Now I am laughing my ass off. Myopia means short sightness.
Well, are you dumb or what? You are replying just for sake of replying.
↓↓
At least be logical with your insults. Myopia is something what's lack of far sightedness.
And no I do not advocate open borders. I only advocate opening the borders for Hindus only screening the bad ones out. What’s so hard to understand about that? It seems to me that you are the illogical person.
You have to open borders to take people in en masse for screening them. And screening about religion many times more to disqualify a Hindu than a spy.
And you are being insensitive to the plight of Hindus outside our borders because you don’t want to do any heavy lifting or be bothered to do anything because you are safe and sound. You do not care about the others only about yourself. Contempt is reserved for you, let alone myopia.
I'm more inclined to not kill the Hindus who are already safe.
There is something called realism. There might be a solution for plight of Pakistani Hindus down the line which if I knew, I would have been a paid consultant to home ministry. Opening borders for screening is just straight out ass.
What a nice way of twisting words to suit your false narrative. I did nothing of such. I have said that we should only accept bonafide hindus and that means screening the bad/fake ones out. Nowhere did I say accept the hindus without any evidence. But that doesn't mean you should raise the barriers too high. First we establish a holding area where we can conduct more in depth interviews and let them in after they have passed the test. Those who have not passed the test can return back to Pakistan or go somewhere else.
Explained above.
If you do not know what I am talking about, then you have a very poor grasp of Indian history. Look up Ghazni King Prithviraj and how he let Ghori go even though he pledged to come back.
At least quote my complete post. Who established relations with caliphs and let their populations set in India? The larger cause of India's fall was implosion from inside.
You make no sense. I said nothing of letting in more muslims. Only hindus seeking refuge.
You can't differentiate.
That’s what a man of fallacious logic would say. Your arguments are full of holes and fallacies and therefore amount to garbage.
I haven't seen you pointing out any logical fallacy or holes in my arguments or present a counter argument. You are just calling everything excuse and singing your same unpleasant fairy tale solution.
Ha ha ha ha ha. Now you are just creating a false narrative and making up such bullshit so you can claim that you are the person of reason and such. You are the one that engaged in name calling in the first place. You were the one that made ad hominem attacks on me and you are the one responding to the tone of the argument in the first place and now you accuse me of doing what you are doing? And as for the thread being your favorite and wanting to keep free, well then you shouldn't be a moderator in the first place. It sounds like a fox being asked to guard a pen of hens. Either take your moderator gloves off or do not engage in the debate because it is readily apparent that you cannot keep an objective mind while engaging in debate.
And look at who’s writing long posts trying to justify his ad hominem attacks. Ain’t me.
Get real. Your arguments have no substance or importance. You just don’t like it when someone challenges your post. I have notice that you engage in the same kind of behavior when other posters challenge your posts and assertions. You go all out and start engaging in behavior highlighted in the meme you so posted.
No, it is you who made ad hominem attacks and strawman arguments first. All my responses with personal attacks in anger still had the argument written along while you were empty and emotional as always.You are still teasing me for being a mod but you haven't put up any counter arguments I have been asking you for.
Your second post is nothing but repitition of same nonsense.
And by the way moving this debate to this thread does not mean it affects internal security of India. it is about the actions of Pakistan towards Hindus. So I would request that these posts get moved back to the original thread. Your intentions are not viewed under a favorable light.
Allowing Pakistanis into India is very much a thing about internal security of India and the original thread is about online Pakistanis posting their L's online.