Indian Woman for Combat Duties

[srevster]

The only time when women were stronger than me was was I was about 12-14, never seen a stronger women since

You should get out more and travel the world, make new friends

 

[Aspirant847]

That's why we test people before recruiting them, don't we ? To check the ground realities.
If women make past the tests then they should get in.

The larger debate should be that how do we structure them into the army if they do get in.

So now we have to structure our forces for a meagre amount of women, probably not even 100

 

[ArgonPrime]

The only time when women were stronger than me was was I was about 12-14, never seen a stronger women since

Precisely, now you probably could find a few outliers if you look hard enough but those would be the exceptions.

 

[Aspirant847]

you do not matter. India has chosen a side and you aren’t on the opposite side of the line.

India has not chosen that side, white knight pussy simps like you have

 

[ArgonPrime]

you do not matter.

I matter more than you do, rest assured, Xeno. I'm an officer serving the GoI after all!!

India has chosen a side

Only as an optics, ground reality is a whole different thing.

and you aren’t on the opposite side of the line.

Nope.

 

[srevster]

So now we have to structure our forces for a meagre amount of women, probably not even 100

Lol there are already 10k women officers and probably a lot more grunts

 

[ArgonPrime]

You should get out more and travel the world, make new friends

says the one who never took the time to greet a returning veteran!! Have some shame, Xeno but then again, you're a Xeno. How can anyone expect such human traits from the likes of you??

 

[Heat]

You display your lack of basic comprehension abilities yet again.

not everyone is like you, some of us actually can observe the ground realities

Let me ask you both a simple question, if a women is capable of passing the regular tests of Indian army recruitment, should they be allowed in ?

 

[Aspirant847]

Lol there are already 10k women officers and probably a lot more grunts

I'm talking about combat simpy

 

[srevster]

I'm talking about combat simpy

Thousands and quadrupling every 2 years

 

[ArgonPrime]

Let me ask you both a simple question, if a women is capable of passing the regular tests of Indian army recruitment, should they be allowed in ?

Only one?? No. Well, yes, if she agrees to share living, bathing, and dining facilities with her male colleagues. Otherwise, not worth the trouble. Anything else??

 

[ArgonPrime]

Lol there are already 10k women officers and probably a lot more grunts

And none of them are in active combat, that's the point.

 

[Heat]

Only one?? No. Well, yes, if she agrees to share living, bathing, and dining facilities with her male colleagues. Otherwise, not worth the trouble. Anything else??

See, it wasn't that hard to agree, was it ?

If everybody here agrees that women capable of getting in should get in, I don't know what we are fighting over then ?

 

[Aspirant847]

Let me ask you both a simple question, if a women is capable of passing the regular tests of Indian army recruitment, should they be allowed in ?

sure for normal duty, also their tests are different in the CAPFs

 

[Aspirant847]

See, it wasn't that hard to agree, was it ?

If everybody here agrees that women capable of getting in should get in, I don't know what we are fighting over then ?

because there are hundreds of strings attached, Imagine the headlines tomorrow, Women in combat can't even have their own bathrooms in ops, women in combat have to sleep together with men in bunkers.
This is just one small implication of letting them in, there are many more

 

[Heat]

sure for normal duty, also their tests are different in the CAPFs

If army is serious about this then they should use the same barometer for both men and women without lowering the standards. National security should not be compromised.

 

[Heat]

Women in combat can't even have their own bathrooms in ops, women in combat have to sleep together with men in bunkers.
This is just one small implication of letting them in, there are many more

Then this certainly was not the line of debate here. As I said, how we structure women into the army is the more important debate.

 

[Aspirant847]

Then this certainly was not the line of debate here. As I said, how we structure women into the army is the more important debate.

Women are already structured well in the army bro, they even have pc now. Women in combat is such a bad idea bro I can't stress it enough. Please actually try to meet soldiers or officers who've been in combat and ask them about this, I'm hoping to have a talk with some COBRa guy to know about the new women officer there, let's see

 

[Heat]

Women in combat is such a bad idea bro I can't stress it enough.

Please elucidate your reservations.

All of us forum members genuinely want to know these ideas. What are some fundamental limitations of women that hampers their operational effectiveness according to you ?

 

[srevster]

Please elucidate your reservations.

All of us forum members genuinely want to know these ideas. What are some fundamental limitations of women that hampers their operational effectiveness according to you ?

They mostly bring up strength and state that men are stronger biologically compared to women

they also don’t trust women to watch their six

they don’t believe women can do long missions that involve harsh weather conditions

they don’t think women can carry a lot of weight and will hurt themselves and get PTSD more often