Indian Woman for Combat Duties

[Heat]

Western women, on average are bigger, stronger and the terrain in the west is far less extreme

There are these guys called Gurkhas. You must have heard about them. Very effective against tall and well built Afghans and Pashtuns in combat.

 

[ArgonPrime]

There are these guys called Gurkhas. You must have heard about them. Very effective against tall and well built Afghans and Pashtuns in combat.

Yes, because of their genetic traits and the hardening effect of the Himalayas!! And they are MEN!! As I said earlier, you're in dire need of help.

 

[Aspirant847]

How is conducting a simple study on female capabilities in India going to put military readiness at risk ?
It most probably won't even require lots of funds to begin with.

when it has already been conducted professionally why do we need to do it again

 

[ArgonPrime]

when it has already been conducted professionally why do we need to do it again

He requires professional help.

 

[ladder]

How is conducting a simple study on female capabilities in India going to put military readiness at risk ?
It most probably won't even require lots of funds to begin with.

Study is on.

 

[Heat]

Yes, because of their genetic traits and the hardening effect of the Himalayas!!

Well you finally understood what I was saying. Nice.

As I said earlier, you're in dire need of help.

I am not the one afflicted with the medical condition known as "Circularosis"

 

[Aspirant847]

That's why the test, no ? If they pass, they get to go in. Let's make it so that enough women should pass that a unit can be built around them.
If that doesn't happen, then the debate ends and the status quo continues. Simple.

Why is this so controversial ?

What will that unit do huh? probably become practice targets for terrorists and our enemies

 

[Aspirant847]

Making a lot of assumptions right now.

Once you have the test results you have hard data to back you up. Army cares more about actual data than what some SJW or Feminazi thinks.

No it has already happened in US, and it'll happen here if we let 'em in

 

[Aspirant847]

There are these guys called Gurkhas. You must have heard about them. Very effective against tall and well built Afghans and Pashtuns in combat.

you are seriously comparing gorkhas with women

 

[Heat]

probably become practice targets for terrorists and our enemies

They did pass the tests right ? The unit gets created when it is actually feasible. Why would it perform poorly ?

 

[ArgonPrime]

Well you finally understood what I was saying. Nice.

Nope, it's you who do not understand science, at all.

I am not the one afflicted with the medical condition known as "Circularosis"

Well, still better than being afflicted with SJW syndrome.

 

[Heat]

you are seriously comparing gorkhas with women

Nope comparing size differences.

 

[Aspirant847]

Nope comparing size differences.

okay, you may actually be a bit dumb.

 

[Heat]

Well, still better than being afflicted with SJW syndrome.

Find one irrational SJWish comment I have made here and that would be it from my side.
It should be irrational though, remember.

 

[Aspirant847]

Find one irrational SJWish comment I have made here and that would be it from my side.
It should be irrational though, remember.

lol "women in combat"

 

[Heat]

lol "women in combat"

It's not unprecedented, is it ?

 

[ArgonPrime]

Find one irrational SJWish comment I have made here and that would be it from my side.
It should be irrational though, remember.

I don't know, drawing parallels between some women and the fucking Gurkhas seem to be a pretty gonk thing to do, in my opinion, that is.

 

[Aspirant847]

It's not unprecedented, is it ?

well neither is dropping nuclear bombs, so does it mean it's okay

 

[ArgonPrime]

It's not unprecedented, is it ?

No, but stupid. Just like the Earth being flat - it's an old hypothesis but that doesn't give it any credence, now does it??

 

[ezsasa]

If the discussion is going in circles, rather than going forward.

Take a break, comeback after a day.

Pages and pages of rhetoric doesn’t help the cause.