First of all, the problem is we are not discussing the trade between India and China, but India with ASEAN.
Exports channeled through ASEAN are literally chinese exports with minor value additions; so yes it entirely makes sense to talk about china. China's share in global trade of ASEAN nations is nearing 25% (up from <5% in the 90's) and ASEAN acts as a transit hub of chinese intermediates; with chinese value addition @ an weighted avg of ~ 13% (as of 2018) in finished goods consumed in ASEAN (up from 1% back in china's pre-WTO period). If exports originating from ASEAN are considered; especially textiles and electronics, the share of chinese value addition would go up many times (although the estimates vary from 25-30% to as high as 60% due to constantly evolving natures of supply chain post trade war and covid). Some portions of chinese supply chains were also relocating to economies like - IND, BAN etc and they still are but that is beyond the scope of this rebuttal.
The US admin knew they could not replace suppliers overnight. Hence, pushed whatever little pie they could into other economies and tariffs were specifically designed to hurt finished goods (were slated to be geared towards intermediates gradually).
Of course this is the picture post trade war and covid but as I already mentioned chinese supply chains were already being established in and around ASEAN even before 2010 and only idiots would fail to notice that.
Are you suggesting that India should avoiding any market that Chinese products show up?
That should have been an end goal in itself; it does not make any sense to play fair with a competitor. Does the chinese admin play buddies with JAP or Kor? It is precisely why India opted out of that RCEP shitshow; the interest of the GoI always lies in decoupling from china; to whatever extent it may be possible.
Secondly, yes, it is right that China imposes higher non-tariff barriers, but on the overall trade barriers (
including Tariff and non-tariff):
International Trade Barrier Index 2023
Source:
International Trade Barrier Index
Non-tariff barriers (the bigger, the better):
Vietnam: 1.33
China: 1.91
Russia: 1.96
India: 2.16
Australia: 2.49
US: 5.52
Yes, India is little better than China on non-tariff barriers, but if you look at the overall trade barrier index:
Overall trade barriers index:
Australia: 3
US: 4.23
Vietnam: 4.75
China: 4.8
Russia: 5.53
India: 5.99
Quote: "
India and Russia deployed the most trade barriers greatly restricting trade and imposing other economic and social costs. "
Yes, don't kidding yourselves.
Take a prinout of their report, pack it with some lubes and send it to your local ccp shakha for all I care.
From publishing arbitray quality control measures in chinese (so that cannot be translated easily), very often handwritten to flooding foreign markets with goods produced at dirt cheap rates (old school predatory pricing); from restricting foreign tech giants in the name of muh western propaganda to kicking out foreign IT/consultancy farms, from forcing joint ventures on outsiders to mandatory sharing of know-how' and know-why; from opaque export subsidies to routine dumping and rerouting of cheap (often counterfeit) products; from threatening foreign manufacturers to abruptly halting trades over some random territorial disputes; not to mention the shear scale of industrial espionage and then routinely crying hoax at WTO sessions - all these add up to trade protectionism and no index can measure its true cost. Crying over India's tariffs does not help; at least we are transparent. Even then these so-called thinktanks do not talk about weighted avg tariffs (at par with competitors) which is an even better indicator and bangs their heads over simple avg tariffs (anyway declining since 2020).
Also, did not really intend to compare trade protectionsim; you were subtly trying to act like a typical wumao shitposter and delivering lectures on how India should get chummy with ballooning imports from ASEAN and how we would not be beating chinese exports otherwise while simultaneously ignoring that ASEAN nations have been rerouting chinese products with/without minor value additions for years.
Ultimately, seems alright if we are indeed being unfair to exporters (read ASEAN aka china); it is about time someone shows them the mirror.
You were being arrogant and cocky; got replied in kind. You could consider writing posts on pakistani forums though; those mentally challenged self appointed custodians of Islam would anyway be happy receiving some copium materials amid an everlasting economic collapse or else, (as I already mentioned) pipe down.