India in talks to buy Iron Dome, David's Sling

youngindian

Senior Member
Joined
May 6, 2009
Messages
1,362
Likes
73
"Defense News" reports that India is in talks to buy Israel's ground-based rocket and missile interceptor systems Iron Dome and David's Sling.

David's Sling, designed to intercept medium-range missiles (70-240 kilometers range), is being developed by Rafael Advanced Defense Systems Ltd. and Raytheon Company (NYSE: RTN). The system is also n the Ministry of Defense.

Indian Ministry of Defence sources told "Defense News" negotiations between the Israeli and Indian governments on a deal for David's Sling had been going on for more than six months. The sources added that Israel was open to sales of David's Sling, but that it would not transfer the system's technology as part of a deal.

The sources said that India was developing its own missile interception system for short and medium range missiles (50-80 kilometer range), known as the PAD. However, this system cannot intercept low-flying cruise missiles. This may be the reason why India is interested in the Israeli system.

An Indian Ministry of Defence official said that neither its aging Russian-built air defense systems nor the PAD system can serve as the country' sole line of defense against potential missile threats from Pakistan or China. He said that the procurement of David's Sling or the Iron Dome would be a "pleasure".

http://idrw.org/?p=2462
 

Singh

Phat Cat
Super Mod
Joined
Feb 23, 2009
Messages
20,311
Likes
8,373
Country flag
"Defense News" reports that India is in talks to buy Israel's ground-based rocket and missile interceptor systems Iron Dome and David's Sling.

David's Sling, designed to intercept medium-range missiles (70-240 kilometers range), is being developed by Rafael Advanced Defense Systems Ltd. and Raytheon Company (NYSE: RTN). The system is also n the Ministry of Defense.

Indian Ministry of Defence sources told "Defense News" negotiations between the Israeli and Indian governments on a deal for David's Sling had been going on for more than six months. The sources added that Israel was open to sales of David's Sling, but that it would not transfer the system's technology as part of a deal.

The sources said that India was developing its own missile interception system for short and medium range missiles (50-80 kilometer range), known as the PAD. However, this system cannot intercept low-flying cruise missiles. This may be the reason why India is interested in the Israeli system.

An Indian Ministry of Defence official said that neither its aging Russian-built air defense systems nor the PAD system can serve as the country' sole line of defense against potential missile threats from Pakistan or China. He said that the procurement of David's Sling or the Iron Dome would be a "pleasure".

http://idrw.org/?p=2462
Iron Dome and David's Sling are designed to intercept rockets and artillery shells.
PAD/AAD is designed to knock out Ballistic Missiles.

And it would make plenty sense going in for Iron Dome and David's Sling when our arty is also modernized.
 

Patriot

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 11, 2010
Messages
1,761
Likes
543
Country flag
Rafael Confirms Offer of Iron Dome, David's Sling to Indian Armed Forces

2010-11-17 Mr. Lova Drori, Executive Vice President of Rafael Advanced Defense Systems has confirmed in an interview to India Defence that the Israeli defense major has offered two of its most advanced defensive weapon systems -- Iron Dome and David's Sling -- to the Indian Armed Forces.



"We have lot of products that would interest Indian armed forces and we are talking to them about that, but we can't share more specific details about those products or programs. All I can share is that we are offering Iron Dome and David's Sling to the Indian armed forces."


Iron Dome is a mobile air defense system in development by Rafael Advanced Defense Systems designed to intercept short-range rockets and artillery shells. The system is being created as a defensive countermeasure to the rocket threat against Israel's civilian population on its northern and southern border, and is expected to be deployed by the first quarter of 2011. It is designed to intercept very short-range threats up to 40 kilometers in all-weather situations.

David's Sling, also sometimes called Magic Wand, is an Israel Defense Forces military system being jointly developed by the Israeli defense contractor Rafael Advanced Defense Systems and the American defense contractor Raytheon, designed to intercept medium-to-long range rockets and slower-flying cruise missiles, such as those possessed by Hezbollah, fired at ranges from 40 km to 300 km



Interview with Mr. Lova Drori, Executive Vice President, Rafael Advanced Defense Systems
Interview with Mr. Lova Drori, Executive Vice President, Rafael Advanced Defense Systems 2010-11-17 Rafael Advanced Defense Systems is the Israeli authority for development of weapons and military technology and is a former sub-division of the Israeli Defence ministry. It is widely considered as the leader in defense innovation and development. In recent years, Rafael has developed an increasing presence in the Indian defense market.

Mr. Vishal Kansagra, Defense Analyst and Business Development Lead for India Defence recently spoke to Mr. Lova Drori, Executive Vice President for Rafael Advanced Defense Systems on a wide range of topics including Rafael's offerings to the Indian Armed Forces, Defense Offsets Policy, challenges faced before defense companies in India and the impact of global recession and economic downturn.

Vishal Kansagra: What are the products you are pitching to Indian armed forces?

Lova Drori: We have lot of products that would interest Indian armed forces and we are talking to them about that, but we can't share more specific details about those products or programs. All I can share is that we are offering Iron Dome and David's Sling to the Indian armed forces.

Vishal Kansagra: I remember that there were discussions about a joint venture with BEL to cater to Indian and global markets. What is the update on that joint venture?

Lova Drori: Joint venture with BEL needs more discussions as any such joint company will be under government control as BEL is a PSU.

Vishal Kansagra: Do have plans to form a joint venture with private defence companies in India?

Lova Drori: Definitely. We would like to form partnership with Indian private companies. Discussions are already going on with various private players for land systems. We already have a joint venture with an Indian company for electronics. I am sorry but I cannot reveal any more details due to commercial reasons

Vishal Kansagra: What is the update on SPYDER deal already signed between Rafael and IAF?

Lova Drori: As you might be aware, it was signed some time back. All I can comment is that SPYDER program is going on well. I cannot give out any more information.

Vishal Kansagra: What products will you showcase at Aero India 2011 to be held at Bangalore?

Lova Drori: Due to space constraints, we would showcase only a limited range of products. These would include air defense systems, communication systems, reconnaissance and targeting pods as well as tactical missiles including SPIKE family of missiles.

Vishal Kansagra: Let us talk about Rafael products for security forces. As you are aware, India is affected by terrorism in various areas like Jammu & Kashmir, North-East and naxalism in many other states. What plans do you have for products for para-military and police forces?

Lova Drori: I feel that market for civilian security products is as big as those of military products as India faces a constant threat of insurgency in form of terrorism and naxalism. We have various reconnaissance and EO payloads for use in insurgency infested areas. But I admit that we are not experienced enough with activities of security forces in India. We are not familiar with procurement methods of para-military forces and it would require lot of effort on our part.

Although the number of customers is large, number of suppliers in that field is also big. In many cases, due to budget restrictions and lower technology requirements, Rafael might find it tough to capture chunk of this market due to cutting-edge technology they offer and associated higher costs.

Vishal Kansagra: Since all defence deals above Rs. 300 crore have offset clause associated to them, what do you have to say about it?

Lova Drori: I feel that current offset regulations might be a big problem for companies involved in major defence deals. While offset clause only focuses on the value of the deal, there is no weightage given to quality of the technology provided. E.g. high-tech electronics system and machined components are assigned same value. There is no added bonus or incentive for companies to provide advanced technology when compared to mediocre components. 30% of deal amount actually comes out to be 50% of the actual hardware.

Another factor affecting such offsets is that huge investment needs to be made to raise infrastructure within a short span of time which is next to impossible. Even if a company manages to do it, value is calculated in Indian currency. Taking varying exchange rates into account, effectively offsets would amount to 60-70% of the total equipment cost. This is practically impossible. Some low-cost equipment (under Rs 300 crore) does not invoke offset clause.

Unfortunately systems offered by Rafael are high-tech with high acquisition costs. Alternately they could purchase Indian products, but their other customers also insist on offsets, making things tough for them. Another way out is JV with Indian companies where FDI is capped at 26% which is not encouraging. I hope that offset policy will be rationalized and if it is not then most of the major defence contractors will face similar problems not because they don't want, but because they can't.

Vishal Kansagra: Recently associations like US AIA, British ADS, French GIFAS, etc. got together and wrote to MoD to review defence procurement and offset policies. Do Israeli defence contractors have any similar association and have they raised same concerns?

Lova Drori: We do not have any such association of Israeli defence companies. Moreover as such corporations are bigger and their parent countries have more political influence, they can do much more. Rafael as a company has raised these issues at conferences and seminars and even in writing. Rationalizations in offset clause will eventually help Indian industry as it would allow infusion of latest technology.

Vishal Kansagra: What is the market scenario globally?

Lova Drori: Right now global market is in recession. US, EU and other developed countries are in recession and hence cutting budgets. Budget cuts affect new procurements in absence of any immediate threats. Some countries have their own programs and won't spend little on such systems as interim measures. India and Israel have constant security threats and require such systems at the earliest. East Asian and Latin American countries are not adversely affected by recession or have security threats.

Mid-east countries like UAE are on buying spree, but that is not our traditional market. India is not adversely affected by recession, has a big defence budget and security requirements, hence making it a lucrative market for Rafael.





http://www.india-defence.com/reports-4813
 
Last edited:

SHASH2K2

New Member
Joined
May 10, 2010
Messages
5,711
Likes
725
We donot have heavily populated boundaries with our neighbors .I don't think Iron dome with be very useful for us given short range of the system and huge boundaries that we have .
 

Parthy

Air Warrior
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2010
Messages
1,314
Likes
147
We donot have heavily populated boundaries with our neighbors .I don't think Iron dome with be very useful for us given short range of the system and huge boundaries that we have .
It would be helpful for us to learn some technologies which can be implemented in our PAD.. Can be improvised to a high-end system...
 

smartindian

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
614
Likes
58
Country flag
We donot have heavily populated boundaries with our neighbors .I don't think Iron dome with be very useful for us given short range of the system and huge boundaries that we have .
it can take out cruise missile , and even 155 caliber artillery shells ,
 

SHASH2K2

New Member
Joined
May 10, 2010
Messages
5,711
Likes
725
It would be helpful for us to learn some technologies which can be implemented in our PAD.. Can be improvised to a high-end system...
how many defence systems and projects we can pursue at the same time ? we have too many systems and they are all from diffrent countries. Integreting them all to one command center will be a worst nightmare . If we need to access some technology better to go for Joint venture instead of Buying a system that doesn't seems too useful for us .
 

Parthy

Air Warrior
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2010
Messages
1,314
Likes
147
it can take out cruise missile , and even 155 caliber artillery shells ,
David's Sling system, which is designed to intercept medium- and long-range rockets, the Iron Dome system, with which it will be used in conjunction, has also been developed in order to intercept short-range rockets (4–70 km), while the Arrow missile, designed to intercept ballistic missiles, is already in use.


source - wiki
 

smartindian

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
614
Likes
58
Country flag
David's Sling system, which is designed to intercept medium- and long-range rockets, the Iron Dome system, with which it will be used in conjunction, has also been developed in order to intercept short-range rockets (4–70 km), while the Arrow missile, designed to intercept ballistic missiles, is already in use.


source - wiki
yes my dear friend i agree , iron dome is designed for cruise missile and rockets , arrow series ABM for ballistic missiles
 

maomao

Veteran Hunter of Maleecha
Senior Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2010
Messages
5,029
Likes
8,260
Country flag
if we are buying Iron dome did we need to buy SPYDER???
Spider is particularly Anti-Air i.e Anti-Aircraft, unlike Dome and David which are against Artillery and Low-level Projectiles...they are two different systems from two different purpose!!
 
Joined
Feb 16, 2009
Messages
25,356
Likes
24,822
Country flag
Spider is particularly Anti-Air i.e Anti-Aircraft, unlike Dome and David which are against Artillery and Low-level Projectiles...they are two different systems from two different purpose!!
Not bad we are covered from ballistic,cruise missiles,planes,artillery and UAV's (and BARAK in the navy).
 

SHASH2K2

New Member
Joined
May 10, 2010
Messages
5,711
Likes
725
Not bad we are covered from ballistic,cruise missiles,planes,artillery and UAV's (and BARAK in the navy).
I personally feel Iron Dome will be overkill . we already have spyder, AAD and PAD is progressing well . We donot have civilian population near the border so that we need this system to protect them .
 
Joined
Feb 16, 2009
Messages
25,356
Likes
24,822
Country flag
I personally feel Iron Dome will be overkill . we already have spyder, AAD and PAD is progressing well . We donot have civilian population near the border so that we need this system to protect them .
I was thinking the same thing ,but when you think about how heavily Chinese are dependent on artillery; rendering it useless is worth the price of Iron dome.
 

SHASH2K2

New Member
Joined
May 10, 2010
Messages
5,711
Likes
725
I was thinking the same thing ,but when you think about how heavily Chinese are dependent on artillery; rendering it useless is worth the price of Iron dome.
I dont think our boundry with China support extensive use of artillery . India has much much larger boundry than Israel ans Singapore.
 

SHASH2K2

New Member
Joined
May 10, 2010
Messages
5,711
Likes
725
what role do you see for Iron Dome Shash??
Honestly speaking I am a bit confused. Iron dome was mainly designed for mortal shell and small missiles . its main purpose was to protect heavily populated civilian area. It donot have very high range as well . I really dont know where we fit in .
 

smartindian

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
614
Likes
58
Country flag
what role do you see for Iron Dome Shash??
iron dome is particularly against cruise missile like babar or protect against un-provoked rocket attack from Pakistani side (last year two rocket where lunched and fell in field of Punjab)
 

maomao

Veteran Hunter of Maleecha
Senior Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2010
Messages
5,029
Likes
8,260
Country flag
what role do you see for Iron Dome Shash??
Sorry to barge in!

I find them useful in protecting artillery and other assets near the border in the event of full fledged war against enemy's artillery, rocket and missile barrage against our positions!
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top