India China LAC & International Border Discussions

[anand108]

1.) No global times tweet did any damage to China... It was US leaked report of 35 death which gave some sort of legitimacy that Chinese too had significant causality. Like Falcon said on other forum that number is highly doubtful. What GOI did wasn't out of planing but result of simply lake of idea about have happened.

2.) I highly doubt this Chinese POW theory, why would you hide it if we have soldier in our custody. The other theory might be true where we surrounded Chinese post with some significant number of troops in it, which China couldn't reinforce nor they could pull their troops out. We got our soldier released and not talking about because again we have nothing to show. (I am hoping 2nd is true otherwise we have made some sort of comprises which govt. will never revel)

3.) So that is what it was a smart lie, in name technicality.

4.) "Unka balidan vyartha nahin jayega" unfortunately this has become new "Kadi Ninda"(Hope I am wrong this time)

5.) Well unlike last time with Phathankot, public is not interested this time. There is no discussion at all, whatsapp, FB anywhere everyone is busy with Sushant Singh Rajput.

This round can be successfully concluded in favor of China. From last years episode China did learned you can immediately bring Modi on table if you have a POW(And our armed forces always deliver same to the leadership). China calculated it correct and we did went for negotiations.

Everyone can talk big and blame Nehru and MMS, Modi might be better then them but no where near 56 inches we talk about.

Will we retaliate only time will tell(Hope we do this time).

Stop this Dhooti Shivering.
This is not a cricket match where you will get ball by ball update.

Didn't you see the crowd at martyr's funeral or the burning of Chinese Mall ?

Do you want the KGB planted bar waitress to be the empress again?

 

[TheSeeker!]

So according to your immense wisdom Chinese released POW out of goodwill ?

We have big bargaining chip and that's why you are not hearing chinese victory bugules all over media. They have been trapped as a result forced to release our men. GOI is pretty confident of the outcome hence all party meeting announced beforehand.

Wait till the true story behind pow comes out... We have own this round . But it goes without saying chincoms will come back with more cunning next time, once they are out of the shock.

1.) No global times tweet did any damage to China... It was US leaked report of 35 death which gave some sort of legitimacy that Chinese too had significant causality. Like Falcon said on other forum that number is highly doubtful. What GOI did wasn't out of planing but result of simply lake of idea about have happened.

2.) I highly doubt this Chinese POW theory, why would you hide it if we have soldier in our custody. The other theory might be true where we surrounded Chinese post with some significant number of troops in it, which China couldn't reinforce nor they could pull their troops out. We got our soldier released and not talking about because again we have nothing to show. (I am hoping 2nd is true otherwise we have made some sort of comprises which govt. will never revel)

3.) So that is what it was a smart lie, in name technicality.

4.) "Unka balidan vyartha nahin jayega" unfortunately this has become new "Kadi Ninda"(Hope I am wrong this time)

5.) Well unlike last time with Phathankot, public is not interested this time. There is no discussion at all, whatsapp, FB anywhere everyone is busy with Sushant Singh Rajput.

This round can be successfully concluded in favor of China. From last years episode China did learned you can immediately bring Modi on table if you have a POW(And our armed forces always deliver same to the leadership). China calculated it correct and we did went for negotiations.

Everyone can talk big and blame Nehru and MMS, Modi might be better then them but no where near 56 inches we talk about.

Will we retaliate only time will tell(Hope we do this time).

 

[ladder]

"Missing in action (MIA) is a casualty classification assigned to combatants, military chaplains, combat medics, and prisoners of war who are reported missing during wartime or ceasefire. They may have been killed, wounded, captured, or deserted. If deceased, neither their remains nor grave has been positively identified. Becoming MIA has been an occupational risk for as long as there has been warfare."

From Wikipedia.

Is the technicality that it wasn't a declared war so they said none MIA?

Read the word 'may'.

 

[TheSaffron]

I am a benevolent mod. This thread is the most detailed chronicle of the Indian nationalist perspective of the situation at the LAC, on the internet. It's also a safe-space to say things you can't on Twitter, /ra/ndia (or even the uptight old-fart BRI). Where I step in is when there are bickering among the posters. So help us by being civil to each other.

Munificent Mod hates R-andia. Are you a fellow C-hodi brother mod?

 

[Sanglamorre]

But the BJP is very interested this time. Avenging Galwan is the only way they can retain power in Bihar as elections are due.

Much of the calls for retribution are in fact coming from BJP party workers in Bihar, because they know they're toast without a military response.

Yeah, I'm seeing people very interested and angry though. The reason you aren't seeing a lot of discourse is because people are stunned at disbelief.

All hell will break loose today one way or another. This is much more serious than Pathankot. This will set narratives by opposition and BJP itself for years to come.

 

[AmitG]

Yeah sure.

The problem is not so much article 370, the problem is that the ministers in this govt act as if they are still in the opposition . There are too many loudmouths in it including the home minister. What was the need to chest thump and play up to the gallery in parliament by claiming that will give life to take back Aksai Chin.

Remember this is the Indian parliament not some election rally. What is said in parliament is watched by other nations and if you announce such things in parliament other nations take you seriously. It may have provoked the Chinese to try to take India down a peg. Take back Asai Chin by all means but first strategize, plan for it and get ready and strike. Which idiot announces such a thing before one is even ready? It is then left to the Indian army to get your chestnuts out of the fire leading to unnecessary loss of precious lives of our soldiers.

 

[Piyadassi]

These are pure sentiments of the people of India that will be the reason of the fall of PRC. Om Shanti

 

[Piyadassi]

Anyone with one iota of common sense and thinking capa ity would know that the Chinese would not let go POW out of goodwill gesture


They would have paraded them and made a spectacle like Pakis had done with Abhi. "Released them as a peace gesture"

We really have a bargaining chip. We just don't know what. Yet. But it appears to be a big bargaining chip , else you would have seen our POW being paraded for all media to see

I hope that is something related to Dalai Lama.

 

[COLDHEARTED AVIATOR]

Nehru to Modi---Phudddu bana gaye Modi ji

Its a joke..take it lightly.

 

[Sanglamorre]

Read the word 'may'.

It makes no difference in this context. It just lists possibilities, nothing deeper meant. You can swap out may with could have been and meaning will be same here.

This isn't an issue like the May I/Can I issue in English grammar.

 

[ladder]

It makes no difference in this context. It just lists possibilities, nothing deeper meant. You can swap out may with could have been and meaning will be same here.

This isn't an issue like the May I/Can I issue in English grammar.

The possibilities come into picture when you are not certain. But when you are certain?

 

[Sehwag213]

Well Home minister talked about aksai Chin in response to taunt by Congress members in parliament whether we consider it part of India.

 

[anand108]

I hope that is something related to Dalai Lama.

Ha ha.....
Good joke.....

 

[anand108]

Well Home minister talked about aksai Chin in response to taunt by Congress members in parliament whether we consider it part of India.

This is not a cricket match where you will get ball by ball commentary.

 

[COLDHEARTED AVIATOR]

Does not add anything productive to the discussion. Try to go through some thoughtful posts in last few pages

Chinese would not release POW out of goodwill without humiliating India unless they have been trapped with something more to be humiliated more in front of the whole world

True

OR

We gave them something else more lucrative.

 

[tigerhill]

I can for sure confirm
100 percent
India had chinese pow's
1 major and 7 soldiers
Jai hind

 

[Sanglamorre]

The possibilities come into picture when you are not certain. But when you are certain?

When you list all the possible possibilities, then one of them is certain. Unless we're talking of an UFO abduction level stuff, that lists all possible outcomes.

My point is, unless we're looking at the technicality of whether it was a declared war, those soldiers were MIA by this definition.

 

[another_armchair]

See what I mean? Revenge is guaranteed.

Only a martyr gets a farewell this grand.

Poor PLA soldiers. Would their families even get to see their bodies or will they get an Urn from their Govt at best?

Bodies of their soldiers who died in 1962 were left lying in the Himalayas, unclaimed for decades.

 

[Brood Father]

Lol.. I think if we won't be able to avenge the loss of 20 soldier then we should join china BRI and OBOR
We should then only focus all on Pakistan. China has shown itself to be a superpower not by killing and capturing Indian soldiers but by making sure that Indian government do not react at all and behave like a whipped cat

 

[Sanglamorre]

I can for sure confirm
100 percent
India had chinese pow's
1 major and 7 soldiers
Jai hind

Sir, so it was prisoner swap?

And...does it seem like the political leadership will be seeking to exact revenge?