1. Here is what you said:
You made no mention this was a joke. Ergo, you are contradicting yourself. Ergo, the point that, absent the traditional logic of mutually assured destruction, Pakistani terrorists would have no incentive not to nuke India, still stands.
2. You have not addressed these two points:
This disproves your argument regarding the risk of nuclear terrorism in India following a Pakistani breakup.
Finally, you have stated:
I would like you to be more explicit here. How would India improve after two or three nukes are set off in India? Would such an improvement be worth the possible loss of a million Indian lives?
In fact China could provide terrorist with a nuke to explode in an Indan harbour - so all of my arguments about Pakistani nukes could be wrong. That is what I said.
The assumption that India lovers exist today and only they will be eliminated when Pakistan disintegrates is a baseless assumption made by you.
Pakistan has people who hate the US and a few who hate China. China haters are not many in number, but then even America haters were not many in number a short few years ago. Islamic groups in Pakistan started hating the US after the US put pressure on the Pakistan army to act against them.
The Chinese too have put pressure on the Pakistan army to act against Islamic groups who are supporting Uighurs. These are the people who will want revenge and they will only be encouraged by interested people in India.
For years Pakistan has told is people that the US will help them regain Kashmir and that China will pour in money and jobs and road links. China instead will start closing its borders - and that is creating more anger. When Pakistan breaks up US haters and China haters will have a free hand.No need for you to believe this. It is enough if I believe it. But I also believe that China must keep its promises to Pakistan. It is broken promises that Pakistanis dislike. If Pakistan disintegrates, the US will fare worse than China. China can escape by building roads and railways in Pakistan and creating jobs for your Pakistani friends. China has been an unreliable friend. You supplied Jf 17s. But where are the J 10s. You supplied enriched Uranium. But what about Plutonium? You are building nuclear reactors in Karachi - but thy are safeguarded. How will that help Pakistan against India?
China has a chance of keeping China lovers in Pakistan happy and wll fed. But you have to act now. I see China asleep at the borser with Pakistan - making purring noises and doing nothing.
Anger against China will rise as the country goes bankrupt and finds a wealthy China doing nothing. I look forward to either event. if you support Pakistan our risk will remain the same. if you fail to support them Inia's risk will decrease. much fun
And yes, Japan became a great nation after two nukes. maybe India will too? And maybe China will become even grater after a a few nukes. It may be good for the world.