I hear you but it is you have made outrageous claims like “overseas Indians are dumb…”.
No, it's common sense. Anyone who's clueless about a field is dumb regarding that field. It's government of the nation which is the real hand behind such things.
Your argument is strictly Indians are dumb and western people or Indians working under western are somewhat superior (as if Dutch, Aussies and Brits are launching space stations or landing humans on moon). You killed argument when I said "Indians overseas are so low in such business and at first place don't wish to come to India."
So no, I was not even remotely offensive, you were.
Your dismissal of foreign talent does not augur well. We have had foreign coaches for almost all of our Olympic athletes as Indian coaches are not exposed to highly competitive areas.
No, it's about experience. Just as India needed initial foreign help to start technologies, India has not invested in Olympic sports to develop skills. So, it took foreign strategies of seed.
There is a reason why American cricket team is pathetic. They simply didn't work on it. Same stories goes with Indian companies having foreign staff. They need experience of others.
Space sector is strategic and technology available to steal in public domain is too low as compared to ISRO's level.
Your qualifications are not suitable for rocketry decisions either.
I have told earlier, I'm an engineer but not a scientist. I'm enough competent with material science and welding technology that I can fabricate anything if you give me drwaings. Be it a sugar plant or rocket nozzle. This is not R&D and just engineering and you will reach at same level in 10-12 years if you work in heavy industries. I have worked on proton gantries and nuclear reactors too.
Mistakes happen in workshops at this level and you are not willing to listen it. Enginners and not scientists fabricate things.
If rocket succeeded many times and failed once, it's the fault of enginners, not scientist. And when there are thousands of parts, failures once in many times happen.
Studying aerospace is my hobby not my profession.
And since you haven't even studied that but just giving plain opinions, you should not be considered.
I have an engineering background too, btw.
Doesn't matter. You aren't willing talk on technical aspects either.
You just made claims first and ignored the responses you got. There is an old joke
Before thinking out of the box, there must be something inside the box. You can't offer solutions on anything if you don't even hold any basic knowledge of concept.
You don't have to be an ISRO insider to comment on aerospace. You can read on internet about why CE-7.5 is a big deal.
Also, you are attributing things to me that I never said - like replace Indian talent. I only said ISRO’s top leadership should gracefully resign from their leadership jobs as you don’t have to be rocket scientists to be in leadership jobs.
Both are completely nonsensical and can only be said by a 10-13 years revolutionary of school speeches. Leadership wasn't a part of problem at all. Sivan brought some of fastest accelerations to ISRO's programmes.
If you think otherwise, delightfully prove me wrong with how replacing a leadership will solve problem. As for "replacing talent", it was clearly so as far as I can read. You can explained that too.
I am all about adding more overseas Indian talent talent that has deep exposure to aerospace.
It's again strictly your belief. That's why I'm saying you never worked. Technology is not a single formula or blue print which anyone can just steal and become a superpower.
Can you provide any stats for Indians in western aerospace sector that they have deeper presence than others?
ISRO is one of 6-7 major space agencies and there are barely any companies it would need to spy on for technology. A Raj Kumar with a new aerospace start up in India or a western country has little to even advice ISRO. Bigger agencies are also strategic asset of their nation, employ their own people at most.
And let's imagine even if someone manages to bring classified SLS details from NASA to ISRO, what can ISRO do? Do you have any idea how long does it take to install fabrication, cranes and testing capacities. Or how difficult it is to guess material, it's heat treatment and welding technology.
Your approach is too simplistic, assumption based and desperate. World doesn't run on assumptions that west might be better racially to Africans might be uncivilised. It's for people without knowledge and understanding. All countries where they are today have worked their @$$e$ with failures to reach there.
Like a kid
Not worthy of responses anymore.
The amount of crap that ISRO and its scientists have got today from this forum is crazy. I understand the disappointment but if the only way you guys can let loose your frustration is by abusing the folks at ISRO, maybe you should stay off the forum and drown your sorrows elsewhere. ISRO more than does its share with what resources they have, they have had more success than not in all these years. It's a terrible indictment of all of us if instead of being supportive at the time of setbacks, we pile on the abuses. The good folks at ISRO don't deserve that.
