Bhadra
New Member
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2011
- Messages
- 11,991
- Likes
- 23,756
Correct. I am not working with DG Artillery, nor anywhere near acquisition / procurement organisation of IA / MoD. I am too far away from any agency too.Bhadra, unlikely you know exact Army requirements. You are engaging in conjecture.
Idhar iss forum men jhak mar raha hoon.
Only RFI of AHQ is in public domain and PRFP is expected.
Yes it is interesting because it involves miniaturisation of implosion, fission - fusion and enhanced radiation technologies. The dude above claims that he has miniaturised neutron shell.Firing a nuke shell is an interesting capability. And it may be required. You cannot move missile carriers as these raise suspicion. Artillery is an ordinary item and is available in thousands.
US has M110 howitzer and M115 howitzer delivering 203mm W79 nuclear shell. They also developed 155mm W82 nuclear artillery shell probably to be delivered by M109 self-propelled, M114 towed howitzers and M198 towed howitzers.
Russian also have 152, 180, 203 and 240mm artillery shells and guns / howitzers.
However, due to large problems associated with nuclear artillery, nuclear shell have been withdrawn by both sides and TNW are based on short range mobile missiles.
Coming on to requirement :
TNW or nuclear shell means that you have a first strike declared nuclear doctrine and India has renounced retaliatory massive strike doctrine.
For a massive retaliation strikes, bigger Warheads are required / used rather than TNW.
In nuclear Warfare a capability means a doctrine as the other side will go by your capabilities rather than statements.
Management of artillery nuclear shells is difficult and problematic.
Weight definitely is an issue and as per news reported I have quoted in earlier post, Army has asked the manufacturer to look into it. How they do it is a matter of technologyWeight issue and accuracy are important no doubt and DRDO may be working on it. Aluminum forgings can reduce weight of carriage. The gun itself may stay heavy I think unless they can change the metallurgy.
So the issue of Nuclear shells, heavy chamber for that, neutron shell etc are bunkum and being inserted to justify a deficiency and confusion.