Chinese military unhappy with Indian media

1.44

Member of The Month SEPTEMBER 2009
Senior Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2009
Messages
4,359
Likes
23
Chinese military unhappy with Indian media


In a report titled 'China Refutes Trespass Claims' carried on September 10, The Global Times, the English-language daily published by the Communist Party-owned People's Daily group, has quoted a spokesperson of the Chinese ministry of national defence as saying that Chinese border patrols strictly abide by the relevant agreements on the Line of Actual Control along the India-China border and have never carried out 'provocative actions' towards India.

According to the newspaper, he said on September 9: 'The recent reports by Indian media of intrusions are groundless and irresponsible.' The previous day, Jiang Yu, a spokesperson of the Chinese foreign ministry, had described the India reports of a Chinese troop intrusion into Indian territory near Mount Gya in the Ladakh region as 'groundless and incorrect.'

The Global Times has quoted a source 'close to the Chinese military' as saying as follows: 'Indian media always quotes government officials as their sources, but the Chinese military has not received any protests from the Indian ministry of defence recently.' It further quotes the same source as saying that the reports have 'greatly displeased' officials in the Chinese military.

The paper also quotes Ouyang Wei, a Chinese military expert from the University of National Defence, as claiming that the negative reports on China by Indian media far exceeded negative reports on India in the Chinese media. He described this as a very significant problem in the bilateral relations and added: 'The Indian government should investigate the irresponsible reports, to find the sources of the fake news, and refute the rumours.'

Chinese non-governmental analysts have also been critical of the way sections of the Indian media sensationalised an incident involving the temporary detention of a plane of the UAE air force at Kolkata [ Images ] earlier this week for not correctly declaring that it was carrying a consignment of arms and ammunition and 'combat missiles' to China.

According to them, these arms and ammunition and missiles, which were manufactured in China, had been sent to Abu Dhabi for displaying in an international exhibition of military equipment and were being taken back to China after the exhibition was over. These analysts have expressed surprise over the manner in which the whole issue was sought to be sensationalised by sections of the Indian media as if it was a sinister development.

The same report stated on this incident as follows: 'Dai Xu, a renowned military expert, said that the actions by Indian authorities violated diplomatic rights as the cargo on board belong to China. Any inspection on board, which may have violated China's property rights and constituted spying on its military secrets, should be approved by both the UAE and China,'it quoted Dai as saying.

An unnamed military source told the Global Times the UAE airplane was on a mission transporting Chinese arms from an arms expo in Abu Dhabi. 'When the airplane stopped in Kolkata on Sunday to refuel, the UAE crew member used the empty cargo certificate it used when it flew to China to carry the weapons at the beginning.'

My comment: While it is important for the media to report instances of alleged Chinese troop intrusions into Indian territory, it should take care at the same time not to create an anti-China frenzy, which may get out of control. One was disturbed by the way a national television channel played up in a jingoistic manner the incident in the Ladakh sector in which a Chinese patrol is alleged to have intruded into Indian territory and painted China on a stone.

Two acknowledged experts on China, who have an excellent knowledge of the Chinese language, appeared on the programme -- a reputed academic of Delhi [ Images ] and a retired China expert of the Government of India. One would have expected the anchor to ask them to translate for the viewers what was written on the stone and to comment on the implications of it.

If he had done it, the entire jingoistic programme might have ended in a fizzle. He did not do so. Instead, most of the time, the viewers were subjected to an anti-China harangue by a retired army officer.

I myself do not know Chinese, but I am told by those who know Chinese that what was written on the stone was 'MiddleYellow River'. It could also be translated as central Yellow River.

Middle can also refer to China -- an allusion to the so-called Middle Kingdom. What should have been discussed at the very beginning of the programme was: Normally, detractors of China refer to it as suffering from the Middle Kingdom mentality. Would a Chinese soldier use it? Why the reference to the Yellow River? Where is this river?

Instead of having a balanced debate on such questions, the anchor went bang, bang, bang against China without first ascertaining from the two Chinese experts what exactly was written on the stone, which was shown in a sinister manner to viewers.

We have a very strong case against the Chinese on the border issue, which we should project in a non-sensational, non-jingoistic manner, but by indulging in such methods we might find our credibility weakened in the eyes of the international community.

Chinese military unhappy with Indian media : Rediff.com news
 

Yusuf

GUARDIAN
Super Mod
Joined
Mar 24, 2009
Messages
24,322
Likes
11,645
Country flag
They report so that we can " discuss" those reports here. A lot of posters thrive on such reports.
 

ajay_ijn

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 27, 2009
Messages
422
Likes
28
on TV, credit for this goes to Times Now and Headlines Today. they bring out experts for every other incident and create a kargil like situation. although we never know things can become like Kargil. although chinese are not stupid to attempt a kargil but they might simply misunderstand relations, troop deployments, posture, military excercises for something else.
 

Ray

The Chairman
Professional
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
Messages
43,133
Likes
23,734
That the Chinese are adopting these tactics, can that be denied?
 

Ray

The Chairman
Professional
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
Messages
43,133
Likes
23,734
Chinese border patrols strictly abide by the relevant agreements on the Line of Actual Control along the India-China border and have never carried out 'provocative actions' towards India.

:sarcastic:

Clever little ticks!
 

Rage

DFI TEAM
Senior Member
Joined
Feb 23, 2009
Messages
5,419
Likes
987
from de following comments,i do think india has future
india3,

How is that remotely related to: "Chinese Military unhappy with Indian media" ?

To be sure, our media ordinarily doesn't give a rat's behind about what you do or do not think. They will merely report it in their unfailing quest for sensationalism.

Now that the "PLA" has made its intentions clear, you can be sure there will be more rib-tickling by the persiflage Indian media.
 

F-14

Global Defence Moderator
Senior Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2009
Messages
1,563
Likes
25
Chinese border patrols strictly abide by the relevant agreements on the Line of Actual Control along the India-China border and have never carried out 'provocative actions' towards India.
so is it safe to deduce that the recent voilations were carried out by Mao's Spirit :rofl:
 

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top