Bangladesh Economy thread

Dharmic_Crusader

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 21, 2017
Messages
435
Likes
3,632
Country flag

Money whitening scope widened

The government incorporated an indemnity provision amending the Finance Act to bar relevant government agencies from asking any questions about the sources of such undisclosed money in income tax return




Infographic: Black Money whitening scope widened

Undisclosed money holders have yet another year to legalise their dirty money without facing any question about sources of income through investments in almost all sectors.
Black money invested in new factories can now be whitened by paying only a flat 10% tax.
Retaining such an option, Finance Minister AHM Mustafa Kamal on Tuesday moved the Finance Bill for the fiscal 2021-22 in parliament in presence of leader of the house and Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina and it was later passed by voice vote.
The government has offered a special package allowing investment of untaxed money in the manufacturing industry in the next fiscal year on the condition of paying only a 10% tax.

Besides, investment of such money will be allowed in the stock market subject to paying 25% regular tax plus a 5% penalty. The undisclosed money can also be parked as cash, bank deposits, and savings instruments on similar conditions, according to the Finance Act.

The black money owners will be required to pay Tk200-Tk6,000 per square metre to legalise investments in apartments and land.

The government incorporated an indemnity provision amending the Finance Act to bar relevant government agencies from asking any questions about the sources of such undisclosed money in income tax return.
National Board of Revenue (NBR) officials said in the first nine months of the outgoing fiscal year, 10,034 people have legalised cash and assets worth Tk142.95 billion under the scheme, paying Tk14.39 billion in taxes to the NBR.
Of them, a total of 9,693 people whitened Tk138.60 billion mainly in cash, fixed deposit receipts, savings certificates and assets, paying Tk13.90 billion in taxes against the disclosure.
At the same time, 341 people legalised Tk4.35 billion through investment in the capital market and paid Tk490 million in taxes.
There are currently no accurate statistics on the amount of black money in the country. But a finance ministry report in 2010 revealed that the amount would be around 37% of Bangladesh's GDP.



Commenting on the money whitening option in the bill, Mustafizur Rahman, a distinguished fellow of the Centre for Policy Dialogue said the opportunity to whiten black money is a big barrier to curbing corruption in the country.
He said the opportunity to whiten untaxed money is in conflict with the policy framework for tax collection. Observing that whitening black money is not justified in any way, he said this was discriminatory and an immoral decision
Under the Finance Act, the government also relieved mobile financial service providers from a higher corporate tax cutting it down to 30%, backtracking on the government's earlier decision to increase it up to 40% in the proposed budget.
In the budget for FY22, the finance minister had proposed increasing corporate taxes on MFS up to 40% from the existing 32.5%, to bring them into the category of banks, insurance companies and other financial organisations that have been paying a 40% tax.
Later, in the light of demands from MFS providers to consider them as service providers instead of financial institutions like banks, parliament has brought changes to the Finance Bill 2021 as per a proposal from the NBR.
As of March, the number of active MFS accounts is 3.46 crore, according to Bangladesh Bank data. Currently, there are 15 MFS service providers in the country, which have banking services too. At present, around Tk2,000 crores are transacted per day through MFS providers.
Restaurant businesses also got relief as the government reduced VAT on restaurant services. Now, a 10% VAT will be applicable for air-conditioned restaurants instead of the current 15%, while the rate has been slashed to 5% from 7.5% for non-air-conditioned ones.
Earlier, restaurant owners demanded a reduced VAT for all types of restaurants - lower, moderate and fine dining - in the proposed national budget for FY22.
Imran Hassan, general secretary of Bangladesh Restaurant Owner Association, said they wanted VAT to be divided into three slabs as per their class, 3-5% for lower and moderate categories, 7.5% for fine-dining restaurants, and 10% for five-star and four-star categories restaurants.
The government had made it mandatory for businesses to use formal channels such as banks and mobile financial services for transactions involving more than Tk50,000 from the proposed budget. It has moved away from this decision, transactions up to Tk5 lakh can now be made in cash with the purchase of raw materials by a company.
On the other hand, a salary of up to Tk20,000 can be given by hand in cash, which was limited to Tk15,000 in the proposed budget.
 

ezsasa

Designated Cynic
Mod
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
31,903
Likes
147,968
Country flag
If only these libtards at Soch are willing to give a positive spin to Indian economy related topics.


@DivineLight in the twitter thread you were enquiring about what I meant by ongoing global campaign focused on delegitimisation of the state. Here is another example in this video, notice how this soch libtard is suggesting that NGOs are better at delivering things than the state( at 8:30).
 

DivineLight

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2019
Messages
1,139
Likes
5,314
If only these libtards at Soch are willing to give a positive spin to Indian economy related topics.

@DivineLight in the twitter thread you were enquiring about what I meant by ongoing global campaign focused on delegitimisation of the state. Here is another example in this video, notice how this soch libtard is suggesting that NGOs are better at delivering things than the state( at 8:30).
He seems to be big retard. NGOs won't make economy bloom. Also we have schemes schemes for poor in our country. What extra service these NGOs gonna provide? Skill development?

Also what's with these BD pr campaigns? :rofl:They should have waited till they reach $500B gdp atleast. It's way too early.
 

ezsasa

Designated Cynic
Mod
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
31,903
Likes
147,968
Country flag
He seems to be big retard. NGOs won't make economy bloom. Also we have schemes schemes for poor in our country. What extra service these NGOs gonna provide? Skill development?

Also what's with these BD pr campaigns? :rofl:They should have waited till they reach $500B gdp atleast. It's way too early.
BD PR videos were triggered by that GDP per capita news, and our Lutyens cabal will give free publicity to anything if they get to say “Moodi bad, Mudi should rejine”..
 

Crazywithmath

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2021
Messages
2,343
Likes
14,262
Country flag
He seems to be big retard. NGOs won't make economy bloom. Also we have schemes schemes for poor in our country. What extra service these NGOs gonna provide? Skill development?

Also what's with these BD pr campaigns? :rofl:They should have waited till they reach $500B gdp atleast. It's way too early.
I am tired of this bunch of self loathing Indians.
Just ask them to show a long term projection that says that BD will outperform India in the coming ... say 10-15 years. Guess what? There is none! India manipulates its gdp numbers and it is an open secret. Even the US gov was investigating against India for manipulation. This difference is clearly visible if you compare ppp data. Nigeria claims to have higher nominal gdp per capita than both India and BD. Does it matter?
N.B.- IMF data predicts India to have higher nominal gdp per capita until at least 2025 (predictions are not available beyond that) and they do not take reform push, pli, dfc, nip spending into account.
Bangladesh is NOT our competitor. Let them have their low end textiles till 2025 (GSP status will be gone after that). The way we are focusing industrially ( high end textiles, electronics, wafer, bulk drug, battery, automobiles, high value steel) we will be competing with ASEAN nations and Coronaland. Whether BD performs well or not should not even matter to us coz they are not gonna compete in these segments any time soon. But inko kaun samjhaye :facepalm:
 

ezsasa

Designated Cynic
Mod
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
31,903
Likes
147,968
Country flag
I am tired of this bunch of self loathing Indians.
Just ask them to show a long term projection that says that BD will outperform India in the coming ... say 10-15 years. Guess what? There is none! India manipulates its gdp numbers and it is an open secret. Even the US gov was investigating against India for manipulation. This difference is clearly visible if you compare ppp data. Nigeria claims to have higher nominal gdp per capita than both India and BD. Does it matter?
N.B.- IMF data predicts India to have higher nominal gdp per capita until at least 2025 (predictions are not available beyond that) and they do not take reform push, pli, dfc, nip spending into account.
Bangladesh is NOT our competitor. Let them have their low end textiles till 2025 (GSP status will be gone after that). The way we are focusing industrially ( high end textiles, electronics, wafer, bulk drug, battery, automobiles, high value steel) we will be competing with ASEAN nations and Coronaland. Whether BD performs well or not should not even matter to us coz they are not gonna compete in these segments any time soon. But inko kaun samjhaye :facepalm:
More often than not, people who make these kinds of videos are fuelling a narrative. Their objective is to make more and more Indians self loathing. previous generation was barkha types, this is the new generation, objective is the same.

They make money or take their careers forward by making others feel miserable about the society ala cultural marxism.
 

gslv markIII

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Messages
1,767
Likes
16,581
Country flag
They don't even calculate their GDP quarterly, lol... :rofl:
lol, even better...

DO GDP ESTIMATES CONSIDER REAL TIME CREDIBLE DATA:

To understand this paradox, one would need the estimation methodology and data sources used for GDP estimation. As a matter of fact, other than industries sector (except for construction) and crop sector, GDP estimates for majority of the sectors do not consider real time credible data. Indeed, more than half of the provisional GDP estimates are not based on credible real time data.

This is also reflected when the variations of sectoral GDP growth rates are examined. A simple standard deviation test for sectoral GDP growth rates shows that growth rate of services sector was by far the most stable. It may not be due to the resilience of the subsectors; rather it originated from the weaknesses in the estimation process.

There is a serious need to take urgent steps to address the weaknesses in the data for estimating a credible GDP growth. A number of surveys will need to be conducted on a regular basis. For example: (i) Annual Establishment & Institution Survey (AEIS); (ii) Private commercial mechanized transport survey; (iii) Survey of Private Education Services in Bangladesh; (iv)Survey of Private Health Establishments; (v) Survey of Non-profit Institutions Serving Households; (vi) Farm Forest Surveys. These surveys have not been conducted over the last decade. There is a need to improve data quality from a number of government agencies-- for example, Livestock Department, Directorate of Fisheries etc.

 

gslv markIII

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Messages
1,767
Likes
16,581
Country flag
lol...A country which is unable to export at least $1 billion worth of engineered products mocking Indian car exports (worth around $8 billion)... :rofl:

1626942336978.png


But hey, they export $100 million worth of bicycles...what a huuuuuuuge achievement!!! :rofl:

And talking about ''cars''.

:rofl:
1626942684944.png


Some 500 new cars & 300 reconditioned JDM 2000cc+ cars sold annually...

And billi claims that the standard family car in Bangladesh is a full-size sedan with a 2 liter engine.:rofl:

In comparison some 40,000 Mercs/Audis/ BMW/ JLR are sold annually in India. :pound:
 

gslv markIII

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Messages
1,767
Likes
16,581
Country flag
lol...


1626943575309.png


The World Bank has revised its GDP growth projection upwards for Bangladesh to 2 per cent for the last fiscal year, although the figure is still far lower than the government's estimate.

"Our provisional estimate is that the GDP had grown by 5.24 per cent in the last fiscal year. It is not reflected in their [World Bank] report," Finance Minister AHM Mustafa Kamal told The Daily Star.


 

Crazywithmath

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2021
Messages
2,343
Likes
14,262
Country flag
Lol. They do not have higher gdp per capita even on nominal terms. Post latest IMF estimates. They only temporarily surpassed India and that too because India was under complete lockdown. Anyway, currently delta variant is spanking them and do not expect them to achieve that ever again. These Raqibools and their delusions, lol. Someone post the most recent IMF estimates there.
 

FalconSlayers

धर्मो रक्षति रक्षितः
Senior Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2020
Messages
27,425
Likes
189,279
Country flag
Lol. They do not have higher gdp per capita even on nominal terms. Post latest IMF estimates. They only temporarily surpassed India and that too because India was under complete lockdown. Anyway, currently delta variant is spanking them and do not expect them to achieve that ever again. These Raqibools and their delusions, lol. Someone post the most recent IMF estimates there, lol.
Please share the data so that I can post it.
 

Crazywithmath

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2021
Messages
2,343
Likes
14,262
Country flag
Please share the data so that I can post it.
It's available in wikipedia. List of countries by nominal GDP. Else you can visit the official imf website but they do not compare economies based on nominal GDP because they are less intelligent than Raqibools.:rofl: Only GDP (PPP) comparison is there (which is a more appropriate metric).
 

Crazywithmath

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2021
Messages
2,343
Likes
14,262
Country flag
It's available in wikipedia. List of countries by nominal GDP. Else you can visit the official imf website but they do not compare economies based on nominal GDP because they are less intelligent than Raqibools.:rofl: Only GDP (PPP) comparison is there (which is a more appropriate metric).
EDIT: So it seems like wikipedia is still carrying 2020 estimates (and not 2021). The last time I checked they had the 2021 estimates. Wait, am giving you projections from the IMF website.
 

gslv markIII

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Messages
1,767
Likes
16,581
Country flag
Lol. They do not have higher gdp per capita even on nominal terms. Post latest IMF estimates. They only temporarily surpassed India and that too because India was under complete lockdown. Anyway, currently delta variant is spanking them and do not expect them to achieve that ever again. These Raqibools and their delusions, lol. Someone post the most recent IMF estimates there.
No worries, they will simply manipulate the data.
 

Crazywithmath

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2021
Messages
2,343
Likes
14,262
Country flag
No worries, they will simply manipulate the data.
India has $2191
Bangladesh has $2122
Most recent (2021) IMF estimates.
Source: https://www.imf.org/en/Home
Go to 'World Economic Outlook 2021' and check it out. Even a simple google search 'XYZ country nominal GDP per capita 2021' will yield the desired results. However, we are living in a post truth world aren't we?
 

Crazywithmath

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2021
Messages
2,343
Likes
14,262
Country flag
India has $2191
Bangladesh has $2122
Most recent (2021) IMF estimates.
Source: https://www.imf.org/en/Home
Go to 'World Economic Outlook 2021' and check it out. Even a simple google search 'XYZ country nominal GDP per capita 2021' will yield the desired results. However, we are living in a post truth world aren't we?
Also allow me to show why their GDP data are inflated.

Here is the trend of exchange rates between Bangladeshi taka and dollar. Check the pattern between 2010-20. Their currency did not depreciate much.

Now here is the trend between Indian rupee and dollar. Just notice how massively India manipulates currency to keep nominal GDP artificially low to facilitate export.

India ia not alone. Many emerging economies with significant industrial bases do it. One more case being Vietnam.

This is the reason both India and Vietnam continue to be on the US watchlist for currency manipulation charges. (Japan, Korea, Thailand, Mexico, Italy, Switzerland are some of the remaining ones on the list)

Here are the details.

This is the reason IMF compared economies based on GDP(PPP) per capita. But Raqibools don't care about facts anyway, so leave it.
 

Crazywithmath

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2021
Messages
2,343
Likes
14,262
Country flag
Which means our currency is over valued?
The exact opposite. Massively undervalued. If anything is overvalued then it is BD currency. Undervalued currency keeps Indian nominal GDP per capita artificially low. This is clearly visible in GDP(PPP) data and this is also why IMF compares economies based on GDP(PPP) per capita. Also, BD until very recently used to have higher inflation which used to further inflate their nominal GDP per capita. Once Indian rupee starts appreciating a few years from now it will automatically result in higher nominal growth. But there is no point explaining actual economics to Bangladeshi madrassa economists.:yawn:
 

Crazywithmath

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2021
Messages
2,343
Likes
14,262
Country flag
Which means it is still undervalued.
It's more complicated than that. Emerging economies upon having higher growth shows opposite trends in currency valuations. If it's happening you are doing good. If it's not then there is something seriously wrong with that economy which in BD's case are low ECI, muted access to credit etc.
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top