The ‘Missing’ Muslim Regiment

Mikesingh

Professional
Joined
Sep 7, 2015
Messages
7,353
Likes
30,450
Country flag
Without comprehensive rebuttal, Pakistani propaganda dupes the gullible across the board

Syed Ata Hasnain

Standing between Pakistani propaganda and the Indian nation can be a full time job, especially when it comes to issues about Indian Muslims. It is an enshrined doctrine in Pakistan that India’s fault lines will remain its Achilles heel. The recent controversy – generated by crude video clips inserted into social media networks and reinvigoration of a Pakistani media article of March 2010 – is nothing but a ham handed but potentially mischievous campaign by Pakistan’s Inter Services Public Relations (ISPR).

It’s an issue very few in India know much about: Indian Muslim presence in India’s armed forces and issues concerning alleged disloyalty to the nation, on which across the board gullibility is very high. The essence of the Pakistani disinformation is that a Muslim Regiment existed in the Indian Army till 1965, but was disbanded because in that conflict 20,000 Muslims refused to fight Pakistan.

Thereafter not a single Muslim participated in the 1971 conflict (another lie). Secondly, the percentage of Muslim servicemen as per the article is drastically below the ratio of Muslim population in India. The March 2010 article is more academic, highlighting research by an Indian Muslim scholar in the US who finds no rationale for this or for absence of reservation for Muslims in the armed forces.

Such projections obfuscate reality on the ground. Post-Independence, majority of Muslim officers and soldiers migrated to Pakistan, leaving a minuscule minority as the core or seed element of Indian Muslim servicemen distributed in different regiments and units. In that context new Muslim, Christian or Buddhist regiments made no sense as ethnic and regional identity took priority over faith as entities of representation. However, sub units comprising only Muslims do exist in many units of the Grenadiers, the Rajputana Rifles, Rajput Regiment and some cavalry regiments.

There was no Muslim Regiment ever and certainly not in 1965. But Muslims fighting as part of multi class regiments proved their absolute commitment and worth. Abdul Hamid’s Param Vir Chakra, although a legend, is insufficiently recalled today. Major (later Lt Gen) Mohammad Zaki and Major Abdul Rafey Khan both won the Vir Chakra, the latter posthumously even as he battled the Pakistani division commanded by his uncle, Maj Gen Sahibzada Yaqub Khan.

Such were the legends of Muslim warriors in 1965. The same followed in 1971. In later years Muslim bravehearts of the Indian army proved their mettle in Kargil and in fighting terror groups in J&K. Three army commanders, three corps commanders and a number of two star generals make up the community’s share of achievements in higher ranks.

The public needs to be educated on two aspects of manning in the Indian Army to counter Pakistani ‘psyops’. First, officer ranks. A commissioned officer goes to any regiment or unit irrespective of his ethnicity or faith or that of the regiment. He could be in command of mixed ‘All India All Class’ troops or of a sub unit comprising a single ethnicity.

I, a Muslim, was commissioned in Garhwal Rifles, a pure Hindu regiment with recruitment base only in Garhwal in Uttarakhand. Simply put, the faith of my troops became my faith; similarly their culture, language and food habits have never left me. Indian army officers uniquely remain comfortable with this arrangement, as do their families; it is an ethos not many Indians understand let alone Pakistanis who have never shared a bench or a tiffin box with people of another faith.

Manning below officer ranks is slightly different. Based upon social parameters each state has a recruitable male population (RMP) index. This is based upon the age profile and educational qualifications of the male population among other parameters. There is no reservation based upon profiling by faith, class, caste or ethnicity.

Rightly, in a diverse society the percentages by profile are not revealed as these will always become a subject of controversy which the close brotherhood of the uniform can ill afford. No doubt the Muslim representation at both officer and below officer level may not match its percentage of the population. But efforts to improve that are an ongoing phenomenon as education profiles and awareness improve.

In the officer cadre in particular, since it is open competition, regions with stronger education and awareness profile do have greater population percentage qualifying to be officers. Awareness makes a major difference and that is where the system may have erred in insufficient confidence building among some segments.

In my tours to educate various backward classes on opportunities i have been stumped by Muslim response, when they refuse to believe there is a place for them in the Indian army. Even the case of my own family, where father and son both became generals, is not easily believable by many Muslims.

This perception is exploited by Pakistan, with the additional misperception that it is not easy for them to follow their culture and faith in the forces. Exactly the opposite is true. The essence of India’s plural faith and culture is best symbolised by the armed forces but the projection of that to the recruiting base has been insufficient.

The ease with which Pakistan’s ISPR can exploit non-issues and half truths to advantage for its ‘psyops’ is a reflection of our studied weakness and longtime inability to develop a better communication strategy. More awareness among Indian Muslims and garnering the clergy in social outreach about the opportunities that India has to offer will go far in neutralising Pakistan’s intent.

The writer is former Commander of India’s Kashmir based 15 Corps

http://epaper.timesgroup.com/Olive/ODN/TimesOfIndia/#

The bottomline is that Muslims were not proportionately represented in the army because they lagged in educational attainment, not because they were not sought out in recruitment. But the scenario is changing now as there is more awareness and education among the Muslims.

Some conclude that the presence of Muslims in the Indian army is low because of anti-Muslim sentiment in the Indian military establishment. Nothing can be farther from the truth.
 

aditya10r

Mera Bharat mahan
Senior Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2016
Messages
5,720
Likes
11,620
Country flag
Jammu and Kashmir light infantry is half Muslim.

_________________________________________
 

Suryavanshi

Cheeni KLPDhokebaaz
Senior Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2017
Messages
16,330
Likes
70,171
What I don't get is why there is no Bengal regiment
 

tarunraju

Sanathan Pepe
Mod
Joined
Sep 18, 2009
Messages
9,080
Likes
40,077
Country flag
There is a Muslim Regiment, it's called "Pakistan Army."

The presence of predominantly Muslim regiments in British Indian Army is what made it easy for Muslim League and Jinnah to threaten civil war against India if he didn't get Pakistan.

Therefore, there will never be a "Muslim Regiment" in the Indian Army for the same reason as there are no "Hindu Regiments."
 

mayfair

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 26, 2010
Messages
6,032
Likes
13,109
What I don't get is why there is no Bengal regiment
There's no UP/MP/Odisha/Gujarat/Telugu/Kerala/Haryana regiment either. But these states continue to send a large number of troops to Bharat sena.

Bihar regiment is actually a near split between troops from present day Bengal and Bihar (and Jharkhand too). Their casualties in Uri attack included men from both the states. The Ghataks of this regiment that included both Biharis and Bengalis avenged the veergati of their fellow sainik by halaaling and bayoneting many tangos while the Paraf were busy taking the trash out surgically.

@hammer head @Immanuel @COLDHEARTED AVIATOR @reddevil9 @Mikesingh @Kunal Biswas can probably confirm.
 

COLDHEARTED AVIATOR

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2016
Messages
4,091
Likes
17,750
Country flag
There's no UP/MP/Odisha/Gujarat/Telugu/Kerala/Haryana regiment either. But these states continue to send a large number of troops to Bharat sena.

Bihar regiment is actually a near split between troops from present day Bengal and Bihar (and Jharkhand too). Their casualties in Uri attack included men from both the states. The Ghataks of this regiment that included both Biharis and Bengalis avenged the veergati of their fellow sainik by halaaling and bayoneting many tangos while the Paraf were busy taking the trash out surgically.

@hammer head @Immanuel @COLDHEARTED AVIATOR @reddevil9 @Mikesingh @Kunal Biswas can probably confirm.
UP,Orissa and Gujratis are in Bihar regtt.

MP people in Mahar regtt.

Harayana has Jat regtt.

Kerala,Telugu are in Madras regtt.

Muslims are mostly in Jakli/Jakrif and Grenadiers.
 

COLDHEARTED AVIATOR

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2016
Messages
4,091
Likes
17,750
Country flag
^^^My point exactly. Indian army is truly diverse with representatives from probably every district, every community of India, except perhaps Jarwa and Santhals of Andaman and Nicobar islands.
Yes.Even tribals of central India join IA.
 

Kunal Biswas

Member of the Year 2011
Ambassador
Joined
May 26, 2010
Messages
31,122
Likes
41,042
Indian Army consist of all kinds of people in India, Let it be from various religions or areas ..

And its not necessary you will find sikh in sikh regt or punjab regt but in Madras regt as well ..

=============

Muslim soldiers in army comes from mostly those families who have been in Army for generations, keeping their tradition alive, a typical character is very disciplined, Obedient and cleaver.
 
Last edited:

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top