ashdoc
Senior Member
- Joined
- Jul 21, 2010
- Messages
- 2,980
- Likes
- 3,682
Recently I read two magazines ,both of which clearly state that China is dead serious about its claim over Arunachal .
THE WEEK newsmagazine carried on its front page the story CHINA PROVOKED--THE INSIDE STORY OF HOW INDIA FORTIFIED ARUNACHAL.
It states that India has now put such a large number of troops in arunachal ,especially mountain divisions ( that is ,divisions trained and equipped for mountain warfare ,each of 15,000 men ),including two brand new ones ,that china's aims have been effectively thwarted.
Also the military magazine FORCE carried a headline story DEFENDING TAWANG IN A LIMITED WAR .
On opening it however , I found about seven eight articles discussing India-china confrontation in depth.
It states that tawang in arunachal is clearly a tibetian monastary ,the second most important in tibetian buddhism ,and china feels that its conquest of tibet will remain incomplete unless tawang is conquered.
FORCE also discusses the India -china military balance in detail ,having a seperate articles on the air power balance between the two sides ,the comparison between India's road building on our side and china's rapid building of infrastructure on their side and also the comparison between the respective air forces.
WEEK claims that road building on our side has rapidly improved ,and now matches china's ,and FORCE gives details of this..
FORCE also agrees that India has so well fortified arunachal ,that if china tries a war like 1962 ,it will be utterly stopped in its tracks........India has not only prepared defences in depth ,but besides the two mountain divisions ,is creating two mobile strike divisions to confront china .
The four new divisions are being created entirely newly with new recruited troops ,so our army is being enlarged by 60,000 troops.
However , if China decides to go on high intensity war ,the scenario might be different ..........it can use air power to strike india ,even air-dropping troops in the brahmaputra valley to create panic.
The greatest advantage that china has over india is that of short range ballistic missiles ,which it has in large numbers.These can be used to fire salvo after salvo to destroy our air fields ,communications ,army depots etc.
India, on the other hand has been slow to induct the prithvi , which it has is some numbers , but less than the chinese.If inducted in large numbers ,it can be used in a similar manner to counter chinese agression.
India ,however has been inducting long range rockets like smerch and pinaka to counter this chinese threat ,and roads have been upgraded for carrying batteries of smerch and pinaka.
The other worry comes from china's rapid reaction forces. It has 3-4 divisions of RECMF ( resolving emergency combat mobile force ),which can be used to be inducted rapidly at any point of china's frontiers , including arunachal.This forms an extremely potent force.
China also has the capacity to airlift an entire division of 15,000 men in one go ,and a regiment of 3000 men in a single airlift.
FORCE states that india can put 14 divisions on the frontier in case of a full-scale war ,that is ,near 250,000 men,while keeping pakistan firmly in check on the other side.
However china can put nearly 30 divisions , a force of 500,000 men.Even in the cold desert of tibet ,infrastructure has been created to induct such a large force with its equipment.
It also has 5-6 logistics brigades which have stored fast expendible stores like ammunition and fuel ,and will each support a chinese army ,thus helping it maintain the tempo of war.
However India still can defend its frontier with 14 divisions ,as a defender requires less men ,especially in high mountain terrain which is forested.
FORCE states that by 2020 china will have 500 sukhois ....right now it has 271 sukhois .
India will have 272 sukhois by 2020 ....right now it has 115 .
Our sukhois are better than china's ,which has many old sukhoi-27s , and our pilots training and proficiency is better ,while china's pilots are poorly trained .China recognises this ,and is using pakistani pilots to improve training.
FORCE frets that our SAMs ( surface to air missiles ) are old ,and the process of replacing them has been delayed too long.
China will also use its old TU-16 bombers to lob cruise missiles at India.
FORCE also urges India to induct its AWACS fast to use as force-multipliers.
It also discusses the possibilities of china using tactical nukes ,if its campaign goes wrong .
Both WEEK and FORCE magazines agree that china will be ready to launch full scale war only by 2020.
That gives us 10 years to prepare for what is certainly a looming confrontation...........
THE WEEK newsmagazine carried on its front page the story CHINA PROVOKED--THE INSIDE STORY OF HOW INDIA FORTIFIED ARUNACHAL.
It states that India has now put such a large number of troops in arunachal ,especially mountain divisions ( that is ,divisions trained and equipped for mountain warfare ,each of 15,000 men ),including two brand new ones ,that china's aims have been effectively thwarted.
Also the military magazine FORCE carried a headline story DEFENDING TAWANG IN A LIMITED WAR .
On opening it however , I found about seven eight articles discussing India-china confrontation in depth.
It states that tawang in arunachal is clearly a tibetian monastary ,the second most important in tibetian buddhism ,and china feels that its conquest of tibet will remain incomplete unless tawang is conquered.
FORCE also discusses the India -china military balance in detail ,having a seperate articles on the air power balance between the two sides ,the comparison between India's road building on our side and china's rapid building of infrastructure on their side and also the comparison between the respective air forces.
WEEK claims that road building on our side has rapidly improved ,and now matches china's ,and FORCE gives details of this..
FORCE also agrees that India has so well fortified arunachal ,that if china tries a war like 1962 ,it will be utterly stopped in its tracks........India has not only prepared defences in depth ,but besides the two mountain divisions ,is creating two mobile strike divisions to confront china .
The four new divisions are being created entirely newly with new recruited troops ,so our army is being enlarged by 60,000 troops.
However , if China decides to go on high intensity war ,the scenario might be different ..........it can use air power to strike india ,even air-dropping troops in the brahmaputra valley to create panic.
The greatest advantage that china has over india is that of short range ballistic missiles ,which it has in large numbers.These can be used to fire salvo after salvo to destroy our air fields ,communications ,army depots etc.
India, on the other hand has been slow to induct the prithvi , which it has is some numbers , but less than the chinese.If inducted in large numbers ,it can be used in a similar manner to counter chinese agression.
India ,however has been inducting long range rockets like smerch and pinaka to counter this chinese threat ,and roads have been upgraded for carrying batteries of smerch and pinaka.
The other worry comes from china's rapid reaction forces. It has 3-4 divisions of RECMF ( resolving emergency combat mobile force ),which can be used to be inducted rapidly at any point of china's frontiers , including arunachal.This forms an extremely potent force.
China also has the capacity to airlift an entire division of 15,000 men in one go ,and a regiment of 3000 men in a single airlift.
FORCE states that india can put 14 divisions on the frontier in case of a full-scale war ,that is ,near 250,000 men,while keeping pakistan firmly in check on the other side.
However china can put nearly 30 divisions , a force of 500,000 men.Even in the cold desert of tibet ,infrastructure has been created to induct such a large force with its equipment.
It also has 5-6 logistics brigades which have stored fast expendible stores like ammunition and fuel ,and will each support a chinese army ,thus helping it maintain the tempo of war.
However India still can defend its frontier with 14 divisions ,as a defender requires less men ,especially in high mountain terrain which is forested.
FORCE states that by 2020 china will have 500 sukhois ....right now it has 271 sukhois .
India will have 272 sukhois by 2020 ....right now it has 115 .
Our sukhois are better than china's ,which has many old sukhoi-27s , and our pilots training and proficiency is better ,while china's pilots are poorly trained .China recognises this ,and is using pakistani pilots to improve training.
FORCE frets that our SAMs ( surface to air missiles ) are old ,and the process of replacing them has been delayed too long.
China will also use its old TU-16 bombers to lob cruise missiles at India.
FORCE also urges India to induct its AWACS fast to use as force-multipliers.
It also discusses the possibilities of china using tactical nukes ,if its campaign goes wrong .
Both WEEK and FORCE magazines agree that china will be ready to launch full scale war only by 2020.
That gives us 10 years to prepare for what is certainly a looming confrontation...........
Attachments
-
220.9 KB Views: 143
-
223.3 KB Views: 170
Last edited: