The Agni-3 Vs Agni-5 Conundrum and some Questions

[no smoking]

Agni -5 is a 50 ton missile ..............officially it's range is 5000 km ...................but according to Chinese it's range is 8000+ Km .

http://pib.nic.in/newsite/printrelease.aspx?relid=155897

http://pib.nic.in/newsite/printrelease.aspx?relid=155897

I know what this Chinese said and I also know he has neither working experience in missile development, nor access to Chinese intelligent reports. He is not kind of authoritative source.

Agni -4 is a 17 Ton missile with official Range 4000-6000 km .
Agni -4 is the most advanced Indian missile .

Well, firstly most of the online sources (including Indian) suggest 3500-4000km, the best estimation is "more than 4000km";
Secondly, the playload of Agni-4 is only 800kg-1t

https://missilethreat.csis.org/missile/agni-4/
http://indianexpress.com/article/in...cessfully-launched-from-odisha-coast-4455382/

So, as this gentleman claimed, by simply increasing 7 ton (fuel???), Agni 5 doubles the range and playload simultaneously?

Just look at the similar missile that US, Russia and French have, comparing to what he claimed about Agni-5, you can find how "advance" this missile is.

 

[airtel]

I know what this Chinese said and I also know he has neither working experience in missile development, nor access to Chinese intelligent reports. He is not kind of authoritative source.

Your Chinese Experts said that " Agni-5 has a range of 8000+ km "

Indians never officially accepted that .

http://epaper.timesofindia.com/Repo...h-skin-custom&Path=TOIL/2012/04/21&ID=Ar00110

 

[sayareakd]

If we are no threat then why Global times is crying and threatening to go to UNSC and to arm Pakis with ICBMs?

We are peace-loving country, Buddha Smiling is good example.

 

[IndianHawk]

Your Chinese Experts said that " Agni-5 has a range of 8000+ km "

Indians never officially accepted that .

http://epaper.timesofindia.com/Repo...h-skin-custom&Path=TOIL/2012/04/21&ID=Ar00110

Chinese did that in order to scare Western capitals by raising the bogey of Indian hidden range.
They failed miserably no one in entire world showed any concern or fear of Indian ICBM except for usual chin-pak duo .

 

[hriday]

here what paki expert says.....they are paki expert...lol

 

[no smoking]

If we are no threat then why Global times is crying and threatening to go to UNSC and to arm Pakis with ICBMs?

Global times?
Are they a department of Chinese government? Oh, no!
Are they a department of PLA? oh, no!
Are they a department of CCP? Oh, no!

Since when global time replace Chinese government to make policy?

 

[no smoking]

Your Chinese Experts said that " Agni-5 has a range of 8000+ km "

Indians never officially accepted that .

http://epaper.timesofindia.com/Repo...h-skin-custom&Path=TOIL/2012/04/21&ID=Ar00110

Yes, quite a lot Indians here use him as the evidence.

 

[airtel]

Global times?
Are they a department of Chinese government? Oh, no!
Are they a department of PLA? oh, no!
Are they a department of CCP? Oh, no!

Since when global time replace Chinese government to make policy?

. .

The Global Times (simplified Chinese: 环球时报; traditional Chinese: 寰球時報; pinyin: Huánqiú Shíbào) is a daily Chinese newspaper under the auspices of the People's Daily newspaper, focusing on international issues from a communist Chinese perspective

http://en.people.cn/90001/90776/90882/6640215.html

The People's Daily is the biggest newspaper group in China. The paper is an official newspaper of the Chinese Communist Party,

 

[Indx TechStyle]

here what paki expert says.....they are paki expert...lol

LOL, Agni 3 will simply overshoot Pak, why they need even to bother about it.

 

[HariPrasad-1]

Wait, are you claiming that A5 can throw 1.5t to 8000km with only 24ton weight?
Are you understanding what you are talking about? If this is true, it is kind of missile 20 years ahead of any country in the world!
Do you have source to back it up?

Do you agree that Agni 5 has a range of 8000/km? I can provide you the reference of weight.

 

[Tarun Kumar]

Agni 5 has range of 10000 km not 8000km. It can go beyond 8000km and its weight is 50 tonne not 24 tonne.

 

[Adioz]

Do you agree that Agni 5 has a range of 8000/km? I can provide you the reference of weight.

Please provide the reference where it says Agni V weighs 23 tons. Considering that it was first tested in 2012, and we are now in 2017 with the most recent test being done late last year, I would be thrilled to know if we have actually done something so AWESOME . But I can't really celebrate until you give me the reference.

Agni 5 has range of 10000 km not 8000km. It can go beyond 8000km and its weight is 50 tonne not 24 tonne.

And this is why we must ALWAYS have an anchor in reality. So that we know how to come back to it after we are done daydreaming.

LOL, Agni 3 will simply overshoot Pak, why they need even to bother about it.

Because they are worried it will overshoot and hit them when they abandon their burning ship (Pakistan) and run away to Afghanistan under the protection of the "Taliban".

 

[sthf]

Global times?
Are they a department of Chinese government? Oh, no!
Are they a department of PLA? oh, no!
Are they a department of CCP? Oh, no!

Since when global time replace Chinese government to make policy?

Yes, quite a lot Indians here use him as the evidence.

Come on dude. No need to shy away from the official Chinese propaganda. India never said it has 8000km range, China did.