Also france in the 2011 NSG meeting raised the point about the validity of the NON NPT clause for india. so to say france is denying ENR to india is completely fabricated. India will enter into ENR aggrangement with france based on the 2008 ENR regulations which are applicable to india. infact with whomsover India enters into nuclear fuel or ENR agreement, India will go by the 2008 agreement only, and not with the guidelines which were in place prior to 2008 nor will it go by 2011 guidelines which are not india specific. there general purpose NSG guidelines and then there are India specific guidelines period. India will go by India specific guidelines of 2008 that's the end of the story.