nandu
Senior Member
- Joined
- Oct 5, 2009
- Messages
- 1,913
- Likes
- 163
The grob G-120TP wins the tender hands down, of the contenders apart from pzl 130 no other is an ab-initio trainer. Procuring any other would contradict HJT-36 utility in IAF. The RFI sent to 10 of which only grob is the only side by side seater to have ejection seats fitted in its ab-initio trainer, all the others such as sf-260,PAC CT/4 were taken out by a single clause of ejection seats. Our own NAL hansa which is priced at $ 1.3 million a piece, would have been a nice fix, if not for the lack of military certification and ejection seat requirement. The G-120TP has a rolls royce turboprop engine, a martin baker ejection seat, which makes this particular version cost $ 2.8 million, compared to the israeli G-120 that cost $1.3 with piston engine. But the Aircraft at this price is lucrative than others in the competition, which cost $ 10 +, its a no brainer why its taking so long for the decision.
I accept that the Aircraft is fairly new and we are the launch customer for the turboprop version. But it should be noted that the certification for G-120 TP version is the latest in the competition, with airframe life of 15,000 hrs the trainer would last well over half a century. Its a great bang for the buck.
One that constantly annoys me constantly is Defense Ministry bureaucrats holding talks for years to finalise an aircraft whose company may become solvent by the time the decision is made. It is an another thing that our know it all HAL always has to butt in and split the contract, they had their run on monopoly for decades. Duplicating technology is a serious wastage of resourses, and public funds being consumed for the same, is a serious crime against the country. If they would like to run their pet projects so much, let them form a group of like minded isolationists put your own money and develop HTT-40, and try selling it in the market like their foreign counterparts do , they wouldn't even get a fucking launch customer. they have taken the Indian taxpayer for too many long rides, too much, we are simply fed up. Indian taxpayers are now not even ready to spend a paisa to bankroll HAL licence production again and again. U want a market share. Enter into a deal with Gorb, licence produce 150 G-120 as part of your share, in India there is enough carbon composite technology for a feasible technology transfer. Hal may intoduce its own components to reduce costs. Indian government buying technology for HAL would again be like US AID for pakistan, they would only ask for more and more. The stupidest thing by IAF or MOD can do in porcurement is if they back the development of HTT-40, as a desi HAL project. There is a limit to frantic indegenisation calls.
When airfoces around the world are going for consolidation and ab initio training is being outsourced, IAF has to be idiot air force to construct and maintain logistics for two ab initio trainers. Take a look at our strategic ally Israeli air force, they have outsourced initial training to the private sector, IMI does this on grob-120 it has bought. the advanced training is done on T-6 ii texan. Once its fighter pilots couldn't cope with high performance aircraft they have opted for a technical solution, that a rash solution that MOD did on HAWK, I can assure you even after LCA induction low intensity crashes would be inevitable, not because of aircraft flaw, but in the training method employed. The HawkS have no role that sitara cannot fulfil, a stage 2a is superfulous, yet does not strike at the root of the problem. the LCA tejas for all its small size would be a mach 2 capable high performance aorcraft, and a new fighter pilot losing conscious is bound to happen periodically, which would still leave IAF with one of the highest crash rates in the world. Modern aircraft have impeccable safety records for pilots, let the IAF not bring it down by its lack of quality training. Buying KT-1 or tucano becos, they are highly capable aircraft would be the biggest blunder in IAF history.
http://theasiandefence.blogspot.com/2010/05/israel-air-force-is-modifying-its-pilot.html
The only aircraft out there is G-120 and I don't see why, we prolong these decisions. Like it or not it is a single vendor situation, But u asked for it. Still $ 2.8 million per plane makes the project for 181 trainers and logistics, can be capped at $ 1 billion, then no problem for 50 years. If the bureaucrats, even take longer than dec,2010, it would be no more than trying to milk hte vendors and CBI may need too step in. So it is in IAF's best interests to select the Grob G-120 in the quickest possible time, to ensure that it does not suffer any more delays.
the following article was by a former IAF officer Gp Capt AK Sharma (Retd), its a good read
http://www.defstrat.com/exec/frmArticleDetails.aspx?DID=245
The news does not belong here. the tread is exclusively for ab initio competition, advanced trainer thread is different. For example, ab initio trainers are slow below 500 km/hr,don't carry any weapons nor do have pylons for weaponS training, the Hawk with 1000 km/hr is fitted with ample pylons for a strike attack. Military trainers are exclusively required for advanced training and is only imparted to fifhter pilots, ab initio training is compulsory for all cadets and can be done even in a civilian flight school.well sorry for nuking this thread (if this news is true):
http://livefist.blogspot.com/2010/07/bae-hal-sort-out-problems-india-to-buy.html
Wednesday, July 21, 2010
BAE-HAL Sort Out Problems, India To Buy 57 More Hawk AJTs
BAE Systems has not only managed to fend off a low-intensity war with HAL over a host of problems with the Hawk advanced jet trainer license build programme, including a damages claim, but is on the threshold of receiving a fat follow-on order for 57 more Hawks to add to 66 already contracted for. All 57 will be manufactured by HAL in country. With this new development, India's RFI last year for 57 new jet trainers -- sent out when things had really soured between BAE and HAL -- is null and void, and the Hawk prevails after all. As was the plan earlier, 40 of the new order will be for the air force and 17 for the Indian Navy. HAL chairman Ashok Nayak told Hindustan Times correspondent Rahul Singh in Farnborough yesterday, "We have ironed out all niggles with BAE Systems. The deal is going to be signed soon." Just how both sides ironed out those niggles would be supremely interesting.
Yes he does. A simple honest method is to let newly qualified pilots do the flight testing rather than group captains who've had years of experience. Even a newly qualified of say an MKI is capable enough to handle the testing of a trainer. Being a freshly cleared MKI pilot, he'd know what what the students exactly need and how they feel when their basic training begins.You make several excellent points and this is area that India needs to improve on......That is the selection process of purchasing Military Hardware.