Himanshu Pandey
Regular Member
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2011
- Messages
- 176
- Likes
- 85
She (India) has left indelible imprints on one fourth of the human race in the course of a long succession of centuries. She has the right to reclaim ... her place amongst the great nations summarizing and symbolizing the spirit of humanity. From Persia to the Chinese sea, from the icy regions of Siberia to Islands of Java and Borneo, India has propagated her beliefs, her tales, and her civilization!" -- Sylvia Levi
A culture and civilization, which is in existence for several thousand of years which has so much unique characteristics in itself that sometime it is hard to call it just a nation. The name India had created so much romance in historians and spiritual people that it can be defined as an Ideology in itself and the prosperity and developed way of life mentioned in various history and epics books of India and world makes it as a mythical place. Then suddenly we face our present which has inequality, injustice, hunger, corruption where most of its citizen are fighting day to day basis to live, where mostly a person is honest because it doesn't have the chance to be corrupt and we face a question what is India a Nation, Idea o Myth.
A nation is defined on the basis of its belief of collective welfare, justice and equality. A nation may refer to a community of people who share a common language, culture, ethnicity, descent, and/or history. The culture of any 2 states is so much different that you can't call them a single culture, where a person of one state is not welcome in other state to work and the political parties with nationalist Ideology support regionalism for easy votes. Here still 1/4[SUP]th[/SUP] population still sleeps hungry. A nation where a pedestrian condemn a motorcyclist and a motorcyclist condemn a 4-wheeler. So what are the bases of nationalism of India? We don't have a similar culture, common civilization or beliefs from religion to society to political ideology. A Indian is different from other Indian. We love to play and condemn all the ideas of being a nation and this reason a lot of Europeans when came to India were unable to believe it is a single nation. So what are the pillars or definition of nation to define India as a nation?
Tolerance, Religion, Diversity, the ability to consolidate others in it, common ethics, all of these can be the pillar or none. For Some people the common practice to condemn government for all the wrong can be the pillar for some other even cricket will be one reason for some other the English and British rule was the reason and force to carve us as a nation. I differ from most of them. Tolerance for others and the ability to consolidate others and becoming one is the main pillar of India as a nation. If we go through the history of world not a single nation is there with so-many differences and still known as a single nation for most of in history. The reason to choose tolerance is that we harbor more cultural differences and several languages within a nation then whole Europe have harbored. The example of Yugoslavia, Austria-hungry Congo, Sudan, and Zambia proves that tolerance level of India and the belief to co-existence is most important pillar. The ability to consolidate is the 2[SUP]nd[/SUP] one because India as a civilization and nation faced most of the invasions from most of the civilization of world. Most of the invaders with time become a part of India and start believing in the Idea of India and this land become their homeland rather than a invaded land. So diversity which is supported by tolerance and consolidation is the reason for making India a nation with unique attributes.
The idea of India is much more romantic and complicated than anything else. For several years a lot of people came here in search of Knowledge, religion and spirituality. The Vedas, Upanishads and Gita are still shows spirituality to many (Hindus and other religion believers too). A lot of travelers from various civilizations came to India to gain. She had provided with knowledge, peace, prosperity and spirituality to all. The Greeks, Chinese, Egyptians, Sumerians, Romans, Europeans and others had came here to trade, to learn, to gain. The contribution of India in Mathematics, Astrology, metallurgy, and other fields are so much over the span of time that the way she looks or thinks become all together a different view and the ideas which had created or developed here become Indian way. How we think, see and work is one of the mysteries to most of the world. There were many who were able to understand it and they felt a bond with us and there are many others who are unable for it and condemn us until recently for being us. There are several places where still Indians face racism or criticism but with the globalization the reach and trade of India have increased and the Indian culture is again on acceptance term of world (yoga, Theory of karma, Indian food, Films and TV Shows). So the ideology of India is again attracting the world and promoting India as an Idea.
But with the problem we face in our day-2-day life, the frustration and hunger of a common Indian, the corruption in every part of life, the social injustice and lack of political will to solve the problems makes India a myth more than an Idea. The greatness of past and the problems of present are incomparable in first view but when we look more closely there is a relation between them. During the time of prosperity (from Indus Valley Civilization to Mughal Era) we somehow become a race of intolerable people who believe in being one of the best in humans. We had gone against the working class of society and were busy in internal fights when unity was required. A lot of superstitions and religious complexity got place in the society and at the time of British rule it was on its peak and because of various social reformers and government a lot have been removed. The problem we are facing today is work of ourselves and none is here to blame it. Same goes with myth of India we were so-much removed from our past for centuries that all those stories looks like myth rather than facts of history. Yes India is a myth but it is a myth which stands on the very foundation of reality. In last I can say India is a unique nation which played with Ideas and myth so brilliantly that they are interwoven and it is hard to find out where truth ends and from where myth starts but this complex structure of ideas and dreams is India.
If there is one place on the face of earth where all the dreams of living men have found a home from the very earliest days when man began the dream of existence, it is India!"
--French scholar Romaine Rolland
A culture and civilization, which is in existence for several thousand of years which has so much unique characteristics in itself that sometime it is hard to call it just a nation. The name India had created so much romance in historians and spiritual people that it can be defined as an Ideology in itself and the prosperity and developed way of life mentioned in various history and epics books of India and world makes it as a mythical place. Then suddenly we face our present which has inequality, injustice, hunger, corruption where most of its citizen are fighting day to day basis to live, where mostly a person is honest because it doesn't have the chance to be corrupt and we face a question what is India a Nation, Idea o Myth.
A nation is defined on the basis of its belief of collective welfare, justice and equality. A nation may refer to a community of people who share a common language, culture, ethnicity, descent, and/or history. The culture of any 2 states is so much different that you can't call them a single culture, where a person of one state is not welcome in other state to work and the political parties with nationalist Ideology support regionalism for easy votes. Here still 1/4[SUP]th[/SUP] population still sleeps hungry. A nation where a pedestrian condemn a motorcyclist and a motorcyclist condemn a 4-wheeler. So what are the bases of nationalism of India? We don't have a similar culture, common civilization or beliefs from religion to society to political ideology. A Indian is different from other Indian. We love to play and condemn all the ideas of being a nation and this reason a lot of Europeans when came to India were unable to believe it is a single nation. So what are the pillars or definition of nation to define India as a nation?
Tolerance, Religion, Diversity, the ability to consolidate others in it, common ethics, all of these can be the pillar or none. For Some people the common practice to condemn government for all the wrong can be the pillar for some other even cricket will be one reason for some other the English and British rule was the reason and force to carve us as a nation. I differ from most of them. Tolerance for others and the ability to consolidate others and becoming one is the main pillar of India as a nation. If we go through the history of world not a single nation is there with so-many differences and still known as a single nation for most of in history. The reason to choose tolerance is that we harbor more cultural differences and several languages within a nation then whole Europe have harbored. The example of Yugoslavia, Austria-hungry Congo, Sudan, and Zambia proves that tolerance level of India and the belief to co-existence is most important pillar. The ability to consolidate is the 2[SUP]nd[/SUP] one because India as a civilization and nation faced most of the invasions from most of the civilization of world. Most of the invaders with time become a part of India and start believing in the Idea of India and this land become their homeland rather than a invaded land. So diversity which is supported by tolerance and consolidation is the reason for making India a nation with unique attributes.
The idea of India is much more romantic and complicated than anything else. For several years a lot of people came here in search of Knowledge, religion and spirituality. The Vedas, Upanishads and Gita are still shows spirituality to many (Hindus and other religion believers too). A lot of travelers from various civilizations came to India to gain. She had provided with knowledge, peace, prosperity and spirituality to all. The Greeks, Chinese, Egyptians, Sumerians, Romans, Europeans and others had came here to trade, to learn, to gain. The contribution of India in Mathematics, Astrology, metallurgy, and other fields are so much over the span of time that the way she looks or thinks become all together a different view and the ideas which had created or developed here become Indian way. How we think, see and work is one of the mysteries to most of the world. There were many who were able to understand it and they felt a bond with us and there are many others who are unable for it and condemn us until recently for being us. There are several places where still Indians face racism or criticism but with the globalization the reach and trade of India have increased and the Indian culture is again on acceptance term of world (yoga, Theory of karma, Indian food, Films and TV Shows). So the ideology of India is again attracting the world and promoting India as an Idea.
But with the problem we face in our day-2-day life, the frustration and hunger of a common Indian, the corruption in every part of life, the social injustice and lack of political will to solve the problems makes India a myth more than an Idea. The greatness of past and the problems of present are incomparable in first view but when we look more closely there is a relation between them. During the time of prosperity (from Indus Valley Civilization to Mughal Era) we somehow become a race of intolerable people who believe in being one of the best in humans. We had gone against the working class of society and were busy in internal fights when unity was required. A lot of superstitions and religious complexity got place in the society and at the time of British rule it was on its peak and because of various social reformers and government a lot have been removed. The problem we are facing today is work of ourselves and none is here to blame it. Same goes with myth of India we were so-much removed from our past for centuries that all those stories looks like myth rather than facts of history. Yes India is a myth but it is a myth which stands on the very foundation of reality. In last I can say India is a unique nation which played with Ideas and myth so brilliantly that they are interwoven and it is hard to find out where truth ends and from where myth starts but this complex structure of ideas and dreams is India.
If there is one place on the face of earth where all the dreams of living men have found a home from the very earliest days when man began the dream of existence, it is India!"
--French scholar Romaine Rolland