Discussion in 'Defence & Strategic Issues' started by Sabir, Aug 1, 2009.
if sino-india war were to broke out, india might win battles but be doomed to lose the war.
The main word in your entire sentence is "IF"
wars are won by winning battles
today,wars are won by assembling-lines in factories.
USA's factories proved it during WW II.
Wars are won in assembly lines. Do you mean your supply chain or your assembly line of factories?
German and Japanese assembly lines did not win wars for them, and their manufacturing was a much higher level then Chinese low cost low quality.
I just know that almost all chinese industry output ,from cars,ship-buildings,steels,electricity,concrete,tractors to toys and shoes,are 5-15 times more than Indias.
once fullly moblized, all those industry output would become the supply in battlefields.
Badguy making good toys does not help nations win wars.
Wars are won by men,not assembly line.Assembly line are for girls .....
Dont kid me mate. If there is a war, its going to last a few days or weeks. Not months or years that your great factories will come into play.
Before this thread degenerates, let me remind people that this thread is about India fighting a war on two fronts. No baiting.
going in wrong direction and what makes you think with better assembly line - chinese Men wont win more battles than Indian men ??????
chinese surely not just throwing its machines out there they have well trianed forces to handle those equipments.
During WW II ,USA's industry output= Germany's+Soviet's+UK's +Japan's>Germany's+Italy's+Japan's
Just a reminder China is not USA and never will be so try to answer things without this delusion. The defense pact with USA will give India an access to US assembly lines.
Yusuf bang on target. Assembly lines,out put were important in last decade. Today either or both parties will be annihilated in a full-fledged war much before feeling it necessary to look towords supply line.
It is like telling.... 1 Chinese Solider = 80 Indian + 40 American Soliders
So whats the point? Indo China war is not going to last 6 years. Enough damage can be done in 6 days for both sides to declare a ceasefire.
And this capacity can be 10-20 times more than the US industry itself. But, it doesn't mean that China can beat the US too.
If you are talking about assembly lines you need to talk about your military industry and not your civilian.
the frozen winter in Russia made many Germany soldiers lost their foots ,because Germany factories could not provided enough winter shoes
is there a chance - if the war will go to that 6 day level ????? seems almost impossible, china will face bigger loss with war .
because - india have travelled far less than chinese did on the road to proparity. if we loose it will be easier for us to regain the same level from 1900 to 1970's, because its wont be very far, but china will surely go back to 1920's . and it will take them ages to come to 2015 .
a war between these two countries is bound to involve the world making it a world war of biggest level possible and that time diplomacy of either countries will count alot .
where i think india leads because of envy china created to europe and america.
Separate names with a comma.