Did Communism and Stalin save the world from Nazism ?

[Akim]

(self-deleted)

You with such confidence talk about "stranger war", as though, your people passed her. I not humidityin sorting out of Indo-Pakistani and Sino-Vietnamese War, only on the basis of materials from a library.

 

[asianobserve]

Do you even understand what you are quoting?

Do you realize that this is a Soviet leaflet trying to counter the NATO propaganda?

FYI...

"It would be gross slander to assert that the conclusion of the Pact with the Hitlerites was part of the plan of the U.S.S.R.'s foreign policy."

"The claptrap of the slanderers of all hues to the effect that the U.S.S.R. should in no case have allowed itself to conclude the Pact with the Germans can only be regarded as ridiculous.

Funny, your arguments sounds like the above-quoted statements of Stalin in Falsifiers of History. Indeed you got your ideas on the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact from Soviet sources...

 

[pmaitra]

FYI...

"It would be gross slander to assert that the conclusion of the Pact with the Hitlerites was part of the plan of the U.S.S.R.'s foreign policy."

"The claptrap of the slanderers of all hues to the effect that the U.S.S.R. should in no case have allowed itself to conclude the Pact with the Germans can only be regarded as ridiculous.

Funny, your arguments sounds like the above-quoted statements of Stalin in Falsifiers of History. Indeed you got your ideas on the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact from Soviet sources...

I am assuming you wrote this harangue without actually having read the comments of Olga Dmitrieva, which I have posted a few minutes back.

Keep at it, regardless.

 

[Kunal Biswas]

I think Soviets had there revenge..

Nazi attacked Soviet at first place coz they know later in war Soviets will attack Germany..

-------------------------------

Now both are History..

 

[Akim]

To argue in our neighbourly relations from Malaysia somehow wrong. Nobody now counts Brest in Poland - by the Polish city, as well as Szczecin - by the German city.

 

[Kunal Biswas]

Ok, Time for some Humor..

 

[Akim]

And you my friend of Soviet propaganda!

You will look this film. He is taken off not on the Soviet film studio, and in Hollywood, when President Roosevelt was yet living.
Advice. you will drop the program Russian translation, I did not find a "clean" film. Rather than all it did not save specially.

 

[Kunal Biswas]

Continued:

 

[Kunal Biswas]

 

[Kunal Biswas]

 

[Iamanidiot]

OT no sane democratic country might have been fight something like stalingrad

 

[Kunal Biswas]

 

[asianobserve]

Russophiles will try to contort just to make it appear that the USSR had no choice but to embrace Hitler in 1939 or that the West compelled Stalin to make the embrace (Oh hu hu hu.... lame), but they cannot erase the fact that the USSR was the only non-Axis country that had a 10-year alliance/pact with NAZI Germany. The USSR by giving assurance of non-aggression to Hitler in 1939 help start WW2. Of course since it help start that war it's only natural that it share a bigger burden in helping end it....

BTW, the USSR even had a neat economic agreement with Hitler that supplied NAZI Germany with raw materials that no doubt were used in waging war across Europe. Ironically, the same raw materials may have been used against the USSR in Barbarossa...

 

[asianobserve]

 

[asianobserve]

So in answer to the main question of the thread, "Did Communism and Stalin Help save the World from Nazism?" The answer is partly yes. But also Stalin is to blame for the start of WW2 by entering into a 10-year pact with Hitler.... :thumb:

 

[Akim]

So in answer to the main question of the thread, "Did Communism and Stalin Help save the World from Nazism?" The answer is partly yes. But also Stalin is to blame for the start of WW2 by entering into a 10-year pact with Hitler.... :thumb:

But as Czechoslovakia which was given to Hitler Franse by a m England without a single shot?
But as Abyssinia. Which was betrayed by League of nations?

 

[Bhadra]

So it was Molotov Cocktail..??

 

[Bhadra]

Russophiles will try to contort just to make it appear that the USSR had no choice but to embrace Hitler in 1939 or that the West compelled Stalin to make the embrace (Oh hu hu hu.... lame), but they cannot erase the fact that the USSR was the only non-Axis country that had a 10-year alliance/pact with NAZI Germany. The USSR by giving assurance of non-aggression to Hitler in 1939 help start WW2. Of course since it help start that war it's only natural that it share a bigger burden in helping end it....

BTW, the USSR even had a neat economic agreement with Hitler that supplied NAZI Germany with raw materials that no doubt were used in waging war across Europe. Ironically, the same raw materials may have been used against the USSR in Barbarossa...

USSR was the only place where the real WWII was conducted. What did the US do> Only donated a few vehicles to USSR and finally fought for control of Berlin. Except for getting big slaps from Japan, everything else was of no consequences.

The foundation of WWII lie in Wilson declaration.

 

[pmaitra]

So in answer to the main question of the thread, "Did Communism and Stalin Help save the World from Nazism?" The answer is partly yes. But also Stalin is to blame for the start of WW2 by entering into a 10-year pact with Hitler.... :thumb:

Apropos the emboldened portion, the fault lies with Britain and France, not Stalin.

 

[asianobserve]

USSR was the only place where the real WWII was conducted.

Really?

Try to figure these destroyed cities in WW2....