Pak-sarzameen
Regular Member
- Joined
- May 26, 2014
- Messages
- 38
- Likes
- 14
Why you people are getting sentimental?. I just analysed the event as a student of history."Jo Qaum Tareekh ko Masq karti hai, Tareekh khud usey Masq kar deti hai".
Those who play with history, get played by history in turn.
Hope that rings a few bells somewhere. I rest my case.
Wat virendra has said is true . U people are taught distorted history in and of PakistanWhy you people are getting sentimental?. I just analysed the event as a student of history.
where? in higher secondary board of madrasa?Why you people are getting sentimental?. I just analysed the event as a student of history.
Why you people are getting sentimental?. I just analysed the event as a student of history.
The fort fell after a fierce fighting.Why you people are getting sentimental?. I just analysed the event as a student of history.
Actually they died waiting for reinforcements which didnt arrive. If they were farangi officers trapped in saraghari fort, they wouldnt have died like that. By exaggerating the account, british covered up blunder on their part. The thought, that desi sepoys like sikhs, are just fodder for imperialist ambitions, could have been arisen, but they made the sikhs drunk with notion of invincibility and martial race. It was decided that saraghari day would be celebrated. Kis khoshi may?. In the honour of 21 sikh soldiers who bravely died invading tribal lands for farangis.The fort fell after a fierce fighting.
Sikhs defended the fort till their last breath, In doing so they killed many tribes men.
The fort is located on a high ground from where they can see the tribesmen arriving, they can shoot them at will.
They have given two choices
1) to leave the fort and with draw
2) Stay there and defend till last breath.
Sikhs being warriors did the second, reason why this battle is still remembered for bravery and determination.
Actually they died waiting for reinforcements which didnt arrive. If they were farangi officers trapped in saraghari fort, they wouldnt have died like that. By exaggerating the account, british covered up blunder on their part. The thought, that desi sepoys like sikhs, are just fodder for imperialist ambitions, could have been arisen, but they made the sikhs drunk with notion of invincibility and martial race. It was decided that saraghari day would be celebrated. Kis khoshi may?. In the honour of 21 sikh soldiers who bravely died invading tribal lands for farangis.
That sounds true of the pakis at kargil, where the paki commanders did not even accept their dead bodies in the beginning or the paki rangers who formed certain sections of the taliban... they were just sent to afghanistan as cannon fodder and were shot at when they tried to return to pakiland.
The battle of Saragrahi has to be taken in a different perspective. Yes the soldiers were being used by the brits, but given the desolation of the post they always had the chance of retreating. Instead of retreating (like the paki commanders of kargil or the talibani paki rangers)they stood their ground and fought till the last man.
You may find this post as reactive to pakis, but in the event that you do not have the slightest to recognize and appreciate true bravery on the battlefield, I had to resort to caustic comments involving pakis to make my point.
Quote Originally Posted by @Pak-sarzameen
Actually they died waiting for reinforcements which didnt arrive. If they were farangi officers trapped in saraghari fort, they wouldnt have died like that. By exaggerating the account, british covered up blunder on their part. The thought, that desi sepoys like sikhs, are just fodder for imperialist ambitions, could have been arisen, but they made the sikhs drunk with notion of invincibility and martial race. It was decided that saraghari day would be celebrated. Kis khoshi may?. In the honour of 21 sikh soldiers who bravely died invading tribal lands for farangis.
What I said has nothing sentimental, but only the most undisputed fact about History. That when you play with it, it plays you back, often out of the pages of time.Why you people are getting sentimental?. I just analysed the event as a student of history.
The choice was to surrender and convert or die I believe, please google.The fort fell after a fierce fighting.
Sikhs defended the fort till their last breath, In doing so they killed many tribes men.
The fort is located on a high ground from where they can see the tribesmen arriving, they can shoot them at will.
They have given two choices
1) to leave the fort and with draw
2) Stay there and defend till last breath.
Sikhs being warriors did the second, reason why this battle is still remembered for bravery and determination.
Very true.The fort fell after a fierce fighting.
Sikhs defended the fort till their last breath, In doing so they killed many tribes men.
The fort is located on a high ground from where they can see the tribesmen arriving, they can shoot them at will.
They have given two choices
1) to leave the fort and with draw
2) Stay there and defend till last breath.
Sikhs being warriors did the second, reason why this battle is still remembered for bravery and determination.
Thread starter | Similar threads | Forum | Replies | Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
P | Battle of Saragarhi: facts and fiction | Military History | 0 | |
Battle of Saragarhi - 21 Sikhs Versus 10,000 Pathans | Military History | 61 | ||
W | BW-20 Battle Rifle For Pakistan Army | Pakistan | 0 | |
W | Pakistan plans to buy 600 battle tanks; eyes Russian T-90 | Pakistan | 14 |