When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justice

Voldemort

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2013
Messages
1,102
Likes
727
Country flag
Thiruvananthapuram, Sept. 24: The mission toMars is on track but for this former Isro scientist, it's still an orbit too far.
S.NambiNarayanan, who was falsely branded aspy in the 1994 Isro espionage case, is still waiting for justice — not legal clearance, which he has already got, but punishment for those behind the controversy that he claims delayed space projects by years.
Narayanan, who has always said there was an international angle to the conspiracy behind the scandal, today recalled his conversation with Narendra Modi in September last year. "All I can say is that time won't be like this always,Nambi Saab," he said, recalling Modi's words.
"I told him that both the Left and the Congress governments in Kerala were bent on saving those who wronged me. I wanted him to become PM so that the Centre could do something to get the investigation into the conspiracy going,"Narayanan said. A year on, he is still waiting.
Narayanan had been accused of leaking cryogenic engine technology, though India was then only in the process of acquiring the technology from Russia. "The local police never searched my office or home before or after arresting me on November 30, 1994. I suspect this was because if they had searched, they would have found nothing. But taking me into custody was the advice from their foreign masters," he said.
He spent 50 days in jail before the CBI, which took over the case from the local police, said he had been falsely implicated. The Supreme Court acquittedNarayanan in 1998.
Had thespy controversy not happened, could India have achieved what it did today much earlier?
"I will not say this or that project, but the scandal delayed Isro projects by 10 to 15 years,"Narayanan said. "That was the aim. But those who did such damage to India and me personally are still sitting safe."
A Kerala police officer who had investigated the case is now the state's chief information commissioner.Narayanan had also lodged complaints against the then IB deputy director, R.B. Sreekumar, who later went on retire as a DGP from Gujarat, accusing him of torturing him in custody. Sreekumar had invited the BJP's wrath by criticising Modi over the 2002 riots.
Earlier in the day, as Isro scientists readied to slow down the spacecraft to allow smooth orbit insertion,Narayanan broke a coconut at a city temple. His son-in-law S. Arunan is the project director for theMars Orbiter Mission.
-www.telegraphindia.com/1140925/jsp/nation/story_18870628.jsp#.VCQVSV0RWo8
 

Voldemort

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2013
Messages
1,102
Likes
727
Country flag
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

No prizes for guessing it was our 'strategic ally' USA/CIA behind this.
 

Free Karma

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2013
Messages
2,372
Likes
2,600
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

ISRO espionage case: Kerala HC allows former scientist's plea for action against police officer who framed him - The Times of India

The Kerala High Court on Monday allowed former ISRO scientist Nambi Narayanan's plea for action against the police officers who framed him in the espionage case of 1994. Considering the scientist's petition filed through advocate C Unnikrishnan, justice AV Ramakrishna Pillai quashed an order issued by the government to the effect that no action need to be taken against the police officers, which includes former director general of police Siby Mathews, how is presently the chief information commissioner of the state.

Government had argued that the report submitted by CBI after conducting a probe into the allegations of spying recommended for action against the police officials who erred, the Supreme Court's order or the chief judicial magistrate court's order didn't give any such direction. In the judgment pronounced on Monday, justice Pillai said he agrees to the petitioner's allegation that the government order is a mockery. Responding to government's submission that director general of police had conducted an enquiry into the allegations, the court said the probe against Siby Mathews, who was a DIG, by a superior officer is nothing but a farce.

"The State should not have dealt with Ext P1 report (CBI's report) in such a casual manner by conducting a namesake enquiry wherein the petitioner herein and other accused were not given an opportunity to participate," the judgment pronounced on Monday afternoon read. Government should have adjudicated the matter before a competent forum, the court held. The court also threw out government's contention that the petitioner did not complain about torture when he was presented before a magistrate on December 9, 1994.

"Here, I would like to point out that the arrest and detention of innocent persons on false accusations is nothing but torture," the court said. It is the definite case of the petitioner, who was a senior scientist at ISRO, that at the time of his arrest, no incriminating evidence was seized from his office or residence after conducting a search, the court pointed out. Such actions by the State government would sound the death knell of an egalitarian democratic society, the order stated.
 

Illusive

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2010
Messages
3,674
Likes
7,312
Country flag
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

A career destroyed.
 

Voldemort

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2013
Messages
1,102
Likes
727
Country flag
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Better late than never. Foreign agents must be plucked out. The fact that there is a strong government at the centre should also help.
 

tramp

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2009
Messages
1,464
Likes
580
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Not just a couple of careers.... its repercussion was far beyond that.. at national level.

India's cryo project stalled and was almost abandoned because of the key scientists' departure. The Americans almost succeeded by delaying our cryo rocket until 2014 while we should have had that tech by 1998-99. Nambi Narayanan himself has said after his exoneration that even with the nuclear sanctions after India's blasts in 1998, we could have flown cryo by 2002. Therefore more than ten years' delay.

The worst part is one of the top newspapers that was in the forefront of the maligning campaign had proven CIA connections from the past. They broke the story and sustained the tempo until he was exonerated. Then suddenly dropped the topic altogether.

There should be an inquiry on the involvement of media in the whole episode if such seditious activities are to be rooted out.

A career destroyed.
 

maomao

Veteran Hunter of Maleecha
Senior Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2010
Messages
5,033
Likes
8,354
Country flag
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Con-gress and its secularism has destroyed the country....this is only oen such case! Their lackies are to be found everywhere!
 

tramp

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2009
Messages
1,464
Likes
580
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

On hindsight, it is clear that the whole episode was a grand conspiracy involving Americans, a media house and may be some political leaders ....

For those who are not familiar with the political consequences of the case, it was the immediate past defence minister A.K. Antony who succeeded then chief minister K. Karunakaran in Kerala as a fallout of the case.

Con-gress and its secularism has destroyed the country....this is only oen such case! Their lackies are to be found everywhere!
 

Illusive

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2010
Messages
3,674
Likes
7,312
Country flag
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Not just a couple of careers.... its repercussion was far beyond that.. at national level.

India's cryo project stalled and was almost abandoned because of the key scientists' departure. The Americans almost succeeded by delaying our cryo rocket until 2014 while we should have had that tech by 1998-99. Nambi Narayanan himself has said after his exoneration that even with the nuclear sanctions after India's blasts in 1998, we could have flown cryo by 2002. Therefore more than ten years' delay.

The worst part is one of the top newspapers that was in the forefront of the maligning campaign had proven CIA connections from the past. They broke the story and sustained the tempo until he was exonerated. Then suddenly dropped the topic altogether.

There should be an inquiry on the involvement of media in the whole episode if such seditious activities are to be rooted out.
I was thinking the same thing when i was reading the title, we could have been celebrating a manned mission but the machine which puts him there thanks to our own follies is yet to be tested.
 
Last edited:

tramp

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2009
Messages
1,464
Likes
580
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Interesting mention about the case... And if the bankrupt Kerala govt says it does not have money to pay compensation, the court should order seizing of all the ministers' cars and auction to recover the money!!
Incidentally, the present chief minister Oommen Chandy, along with his mentor Antony, were political beneficiaries of the cooked up espionage case.
Nambi Narayanan
In 2001, the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) ordered the Kerala State Government to pay him a compensation of INR 1 crore (10 million).[7] He retired in 2001. The Kerala High Court ordered a compensation amount of Rs 10 lakhs to be paid to Nambi Narayanan based on an appeal from NHRC India in September 2012.

On October 3, 2012, The Hindu Reported that Kerala Government has dropped charges against police officials who were alleged to have falsely implicated Nambi Narayanan in the espionage case on the grounds that over 15 years had passed since the case was initiated. The top officer involved in the case, Siby Mathews is currently the Chief Information Commissioner in Kerala.[8]
 

W.G.Ewald

Defence Professionals/ DFI member of 2
Professional
Joined
Sep 28, 2011
Messages
14,139
Likes
8,594
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Once again the Indian mind injects drama into what should be the celebration of an exceptional accomplishment.

India would be supreme in the world were it not for the CIA, I have no doubt. :rolleyes:
 

Voldemort

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2013
Messages
1,102
Likes
727
Country flag
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Once again the Indian mind injects drama into what should be the celebration of an exceptional accomplishment.

India would be supreme in the world were it not for the CIA, I have no doubt. :rolleyes:
No we are a poor third world country. And it seems US has nothing better to do than screw up space and nuclear projects of poor countries.
 

W.G.Ewald

Defence Professionals/ DFI member of 2
Professional
Joined
Sep 28, 2011
Messages
14,139
Likes
8,594
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

No we are a poor third world country. And it seems US has nothing better to do than screw up space and nuclear projects of poor countries.
Boo hoo. Narayanan case has nothing to do with MOM mission, AFAICT. Telegraph India story just trying to get people to read their site.

I see no evidence for your accusations.
 

Voldemort

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2013
Messages
1,102
Likes
727
Country flag
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Boo hoo. Narayanan case has nothing to do with MOM mission, AFAICT. Telegraph India story just trying to get people to read their site.

I see no evidence for your accusations.
Full story can be read here. US had brazenly tried to stop the Indo-Russian deal. defenceforumindia.com/forum/strategic-forces/47046-did-cia-moles-ib-fake-isro-spy-case-2.html
 

tramp

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2009
Messages
1,464
Likes
580
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Poor innocent Americans ... they have never done anything wrong ever... so do not even mention anything against them!
Can't you guys see that their conscience is as clear as the crystal!!

Once again the Indian mind injects drama into what should be the celebration of an exceptional accomplishment.

India would be supreme in the world were it not for the CIA, I have no doubt. :rolleyes:
 

tramp

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2009
Messages
1,464
Likes
580
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Not tried to stop... indeed stopped it. And paid that infernal tippler Yeltsin nearly $450 million as compensation. But Russian did in the end clandestinely help us out with the cryo development.

Full story can be read here. US had brazenly tried to stop the Indo-Russian deal. defenceforumindia.com/forum/strategic-forces/47046-did-cia-moles-ib-fake-isro-spy-case-2.html
 

tramp

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2009
Messages
1,464
Likes
580
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

You are indeed right. Narayan case has no direct link to MOM.

It was about the cryo development. But the hidden connection is that if the cryo development did not take as long as it eventually took, India could have used a GSLV for both Chandrayaan-1 and MOM, instead of the PSLV-XL.

Boo hoo. Narayanan case has nothing to do with MOM mission, AFAICT. Telegraph India story just trying to get people to read their site.

I see no evidence for your accusations.
 

W.G.Ewald

Defence Professionals/ DFI member of 2
Professional
Joined
Sep 28, 2011
Messages
14,139
Likes
8,594
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Poor innocent Americans ... they have never done anything wrong ever... so do not even mention anything against them!
Can't you guys see that their conscience is as clear as the crystal!!
It is DFIndians who wish to make India always the victim, so your characterization of Americans is an evasion.

The other half of equation is big strong Russia must save helpless India.

Isn't it embarrassing to Indians who do have pride in their country?
 

W.G.Ewald

Defence Professionals/ DFI member of 2
Professional
Joined
Sep 28, 2011
Messages
14,139
Likes
8,594
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Full story can be read here. US had brazenly tried to stop the Indo-Russian deal. defenceforumindia.com/forum/strategic-forces/47046-did-cia-moles-ib-fake-isro-spy-case-2.html
Your evidence is another thread on DFI? You should try harder. And here is a post in that thread:

The allegations of the author might be false but the way the case was hushed up is indeed confusing.
Inconclusive at best, conspiracy theory at worst.

This guy is a piece of work, and evidently couldn't get any traction with his ranting.

http://www.openthemagazine.com/article/books/why-my-book-didn-t-sell
 
Last edited:

Compersion

Senior Member
Joined
May 6, 2013
Messages
2,258
Likes
923
Country flag
Re: When the nation celebrates MOM, one ex ISRO scientist awaits justi

Was thinking Usa could have helped and supported in development of cryogenic engine ... Why Russia ... Perhaps they the Americans wanted ... Perhaps too expensive terms and did not want Russia to take advantage ... On the other side perhaps usa thought that Russia would loose significance after 1990s and India would eventually come around to usa.

The 11 and 13 May are dates that also Slapped India and usa relationship into reality. Now private companies are doing disruptive developments in space and also the defence and economic affairs and more connection with people know how and skills.
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top