Uncle Sam too senile to lead Asia

Discussion in 'International Politics' started by ajtr, Oct 12, 2010.

  1. ajtr

    ajtr Veteran Member Veteran Member

    Oct 2, 2009
    Likes Received:
    Uncle Sam too senile to lead Asia

    By Li Hongmei

    China will send its Defense Minister to attend a meeting in Hanoi of defense chiefs from the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) and eight other invited countries, which may witness the first handshake between the defense chiefs of China and the U.S. since the bilateral military ties were damaged in January following the Pentagon's decision to sell a nearly 6.4-billion-U.S.-dollar arms package to Taiwan.

    But the South China Sea issue, while high on the U.S. agenda, has been brushed off the Chinese list. China's consistent stance is that the South China Sea issue is not an issue between China and ASEAN, nor can the issue be discussed under the framework of ASEAN+8.

    Uncle Sam, instead, is expected to play the same old tune taking the South China Sea disputes to the international court in favor of its interests, while taking great lengths to align with ASEAN countries, and distance China from its neighbors.

    President Barack Obama last month told leaders of Southeast Asian nations the U.S. has an "enormous stake" in the region and intends to play a leadership role in Asia, explicitly delivering the message to the regional leaders that US is seeking the "US-ASEAN realignment" in Asia.

    Back to last November, Obama pledged that he would be a ‘Pacific president.' While the audience then present may have wondered about what exactly that statement meant, few in attendance doubted the sincerity or conviction of the president.

    As a matter of fact, the U.S. is trying to reset its relationship with ASEAN, especially since the latest series of ASEAN-hosted diplomatic meetings in Hanoi. When Secretary of State Hillary Clinton attempted desperately to involve her country in the regional affairs and internationalize the South China Sea issue, the meaning of a Pacific president is starting to become clearer.

    Three cases in particular warrant special mention---the East Asia Summit, the South China Sea and the Korean Peninsula. In all the three cases, what the United States has been trying to do is to draw closer the ASEAN countries, while distancing China from the decision-making process.

    The fact that the meeting convened in September in the United States more than betrays its true color of "comeback" to Asia, in that the U.S. has long planned to institutionalize and renew the U.S. engagement in ASEAN in creating "new regional security and trade architecture in Asia."

    On the flip side, the fact that the summit is taking place in New York, not Washington, and without the leader of ASEAN's largest country and economy, Indonesia, underlines the point that while the US policy intent is clearly substantive engagement, there is still much work to be done to engage ASEAN. In particular, With the United States' economy flagging and its global influence in decline, Uncle Sam would be walking with great difficulty on the way to meet its goal.

    Of late, the U.S. even goes so far as to state it is willing to help craft a legally binding "code of conduct" that will govern actions in the South China Sea in order to end a territorial dispute between ASEAN members and China that threatens regional stability.

    Beyond doubt, Uncle Sam will be not only interested in using its meddling hand to help ink the regional document, but it will push China to agree to it unconditionally.

    Viewed from a practical prism, the so-called US-ASEAN realignment as the US has been assiduously seeking after is far from an ironclad wholeness, but a patchwork. The Free Trade Pact the ASEAN countries have been yearning for cannot be granted by the U.S., owing to its mounting domestic pressure and sluggish economy. Likewise, the U.S. intention in aligning with ASEAN countries to encircle China and encroach upon China's regional preeminence seems nothing but an empty talk, as the ASEAN countries could not and would not start the conflict with China, a giant with whom they have already formed a well-established and win-win cooperative mechanism.

    Instead, on the chessboard of Uncle Sam, all the ASEAN countries as well as China are taken as the chess pieces which can be positioned at will and as he sees fit, even though the senile Uncle always overestimates his intelligence and obstinately believes he is the unchallenged player.

    The sad fact is that, although he has a splendid history left behind, today's Uncle Sam is unable to retrace his powerful yesterday. The robust emerging economies are enlivening the skyline of a new Asia, out of its own design. Uncle Sam is at the moment an unexpected guest to the region, let alone gaining the initiative and leading the hosts.

    The articles in this column represent the author's views only. They do not represent opinions of People's Daily or People's Daily Online.
  3. king98121

    king98121 New Member

    Sep 25, 2010
    Likes Received:
    The usa i think will try to emulate the divide and conquer ideology if all else fails and even if we are not as stupid as before it will leave a deep impact for example they are including china in almost everything this will naturally cause and create jealousy in other asian nations

    and if something like war breaks the only ones who will prosper will be the usa and europe

    its like they are watching rising economies china and india like dogs and least bothered about their own
  4. Ray

    Ray The Chairman Defence Professionals Moderator

    Apr 17, 2009
    Likes Received:
    No country in Asia is keen on ironclad alliances given the experience of SEATO.

    And yet, they cannot do without the USA given the sinister shadow of China, as they see it.

    Therefore, all agreements will be working relationships.

    The US will be satisfied since it would ensure that they do not join the Chinese camp!

    The US is playing it cool.

    Better safe, than sorry is their mantra or so it appears!
    Last edited: Oct 13, 2010
  5. mattster

    mattster Respected Member Senior Member

    May 30, 2009
    Likes Received:
    Another dumb article meant for Chinese consumption.

    The author forgets to mention a few key facts -

    1) its not the Americans who are pushing for these alignments and joint military exercises with the US. It is the ASEAN countries that are increasingly nervous about Chinese military intentions. Vietnam, Phiiipines, Malaysia, Japan, Taiwan, India, and even small Bhutan all have issues with China not the US.

    2) Asian countries like Japan and South Korea have been able to spend very little on defense because of US defense umbrella. This has allowed them to invest in other areas and grow their economy.

    3) India is the only country in the region with the potential to match China, but unfortunately India has fallen far behind China both economically and militarily.
    It remains to be seen if India can catch up. Rest assured ASEAN countries will not be waiting for India to come to their rescue if China is bullying them. They will have to seek US help.

Share This Page