Ten Questions for China's Heir Presumptive

Ray

The Chairman
Professional
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
Messages
43,132
Likes
23,835
Ten Questions for China's Heir Presumptive

WASHINGTON — The visit by China's vice president, Xi Jinping, to Washington this coming week offers a unique opportunity to take the measure of the man who will lead China for the next decade.

While Xi has traveled the world since being anointed Hu Jintao's designated successor in 2007, he has not been to the United States during this grooming period (he did visit earlier as a provincial official).

This will be a good opportunity for Xi to familiarize himself with America and vice versa. As he is not well known outside of China and enigmatic even inside the country, observers will be looking for clues to Xi's domestic and international orientation.

Here are 10 questions China watchers would like to know about Xi Jinping:

"¢1. Will Xi return to a politically reformist path for the Chinese Communist Party?

Since late 2009, the party has retrenched significantly — halting and rolling back reforms by Xi's predecessor, Zeng Qinghong. Can Xi stand up to the powerful conservative institutions that have blocked reforms — the state security apparatus, the military, the party propaganda system and large state-owned enterprises — or will he be beholden to them, as Hu Jintao has been? Will reformers such as Li Yuanchao, Wang Yang, Bo Xilai, Wang Huning and Liu Yandong be promoted to top Politburo positions along with Xi at the 18th Party Congress in October?

"¢ 2. Can Xi and the next prime minister (the contenders are reportedly Vice Prime Ministers Li Keqiang and Wang Qishan) turn the rhetoric of economic "rebalancing" into reality?

Many official speeches have been made over the past two years calling for a reorientation of the economy away from the export sector and the coastal regions to domestic consumption and the interior as the basis for a new and more sustainable growth model for China. To date the reality of investment has not matched the rhetoric.

"¢3. Will Xi be able to devise a more humane policy toward Tibet and Xinjiang, where ethnic unrest has steadily risen since 2008 and has spiked in recent weeks?

Government security forces have responded with a heavy hand, resulting in loss of life and heightened instability. A new, softer approach is needed. But will Xi have the political strength to stand up to the repressive apparatus and put in place conditions for a more stable coexistence between restive ethnic groups and the Chinese state?

"¢4. Can Xi and the party apparatus reign in the nationalism that is pushing the government to take extreme positions on territorial disputes with China's neighbors, to "stand up" to the United States and behave aggressively internationally?

"¢ 5. Will Xi be sufficiently confident to all the relaxation of tightened controls on mainstream media, social media, the Internet and educational institutions?

"¢6. Can Xi reign in the military, which has demonstrated a worrisome tendency in recent years to undertake actions that provoke China's neighbors and, seemingly, act independently of civilian party control?

"¢7. Will Xi authorize a foreign policy that is more about substance than rhetoric?

China's diplomatic platitudes have become increasingly incredulous in a dangerous world where real action is needed from Beijing. One hopeful indicator in this regard is a speech Xi gave at the Central Party School in late 2009, in which he explicitly criticized the pervasive tendency toward sloganeering in domestic and foreign policy, arguing that slogans needed to be replaced by substance and hard work.

"¢8. How will Xi handle the growing discontent across Africa, the Middle East, and Latin America over China's rapacious and mercantilist energy, aid and trade policies?

"¢9. Will Xi and the Chinese government begin to take more active and less passive, more supportive and less obstructionist, roles in global governance? Will China continue to stand with Russia in the United Nations Security Council against the will of the majority of other nations on issues like Syria and Iran — and become part of the solution instead of part of the problem?

"¢10. Will Xi have the strategic foresight to invest in advancing the relationship with the United States?

There is no more important relationship for either country in the world today, yet strategic mistrust permeates the current relationship. Advancing the relationship requires the active engagement of China's next leader — and the American president — to build strategic trust between the two great nations.

As Xi's visit is not likely to provide answers to these 10 questions, time will tell if he is a "transformational" leader who embraces and shapes positive changes for China at home and abroad, or whether he is another risk-averse apparatchik.

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/11/o...r-chinas-heir-presumptive.html?_r=1&ref=china
Xi Jumping is expected to be the next Helmsman who will guide the destiny of China.

The question are important.

One wonders what will be what the man will do.

What do you think he should do keeping the issues in the questions in view?

Maybe out Chinese posters could help!
 

AprilLyrics

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2011
Messages
380
Likes
54
Xi Jumping is expected to be the next Helmsman who will guide the destiny of China.

The question are important.

One wonders what will be what the man will do.

What do you think he should do keeping the issues in the questions in view?

Maybe out Chinese posters could help!
i think he is conservative. And he is a low-key person.
 

Ray

The Chairman
Professional
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
Messages
43,132
Likes
23,835
His wife is supposed to be a great singer!

An ideal combination!

But what will his take on the issues be?

"¢1. If he is a conservative then Xi will not return to a politically reformist path for the Chinese Communist Party. There will be NO reforms to be expected.


"¢ 2. One wonders if Xi and the next prime minister (the contenders are reportedly Vice Prime Ministers Li Keqiang and Wang Qishan) can turn the rhetoric of economic "rebalancing" into reality. Or would he? Given the way the economy of the world is going, if China is to sustain its Peaceful Rise, it will have to jiggle its economy and the only answer is creating a domestic market. Will he be able to do so?

"¢3. I don/t think that Xi be able to devise a more humane policy toward Tibet and Xinjiang, where ethnic unrest has steadily risen since 2008 and has spiked in recent weeks. It will go against the Han cultural supremacy policy that is a historical legacy and it will go against the other historical legacy of turning all people into Hans by assimilating them.

"¢4. Nationalism is an ideal vehicle to keep the mind of the people of the negativeness of Govt decisions. Therefore Xi and the party apparatus will continue to allow nationalism push the government even if it forces the Govt to take extreme positions on territorial disputes with China's neighbours and to "stand up" to the United States and behave aggressively internationally?

"¢ 5. Whether Xi is sufficiently confident to lift all the relaxation of tightened controls on mainstream media, social media, the Internet and educational institutions, he will not do so since it will give rise to dissident thoughts and that could be dangerous for Xi and the CCP.

"¢6. Can Xi reign in the military, which has demonstrated a worrisome tendency in recent years to undertake actions that provoke China's neighbors and, seemingly, act independently of civilian party control?

I don't think so. The military is getting confident by the day of its military arsenal and will be itching to tests its prowess and the tactical knowledge of its military commanders.

"¢7. Xi will not authorize a foreign policy that is more about substance than rhetoric because rhetoric is the staple of Chinese thought!

"¢8. This will be a challenge for China and Xi to handle the growing discontent across Africa, the Middle East, and Latin America over China's rapacious and mercantilist energy, aid and trade policies. It is too complex and Xi will not be able to solve it in the immediate future.

"¢9. Xi and the Chinese government will not begin to take more active and less passive, more supportive and less obstructionist, roles in global governance since it will go against the Chinese policy of having its feet on both boats. It will continue to stand with Russia in the United Nations Security Council against the will of the majority of other nations on issues like Syria and Iran — and become part of the solution instead of part of the problem because China's interest in Russia is greater than in distant and faraway lands as Syria and Iran.

"¢10. It will all depend in the perception of Xi as to what is meant to be the strategic foresight that China should invest in advancing the relationship with the United States.

There is no more important relationship for either country in the world today, yet strategic mistrust permeates the current relationship. Advancing the relationship requires the active engagement of China's next leader — and the American president — to build strategic trust between the two great nations.
 
Last edited:

Bhadra

Professional
Joined
Jul 11, 2011
Messages
11,991
Likes
23,758
Country flag
Add one more question to the list.
By what time frame Chinese will take over Pakistan, Nepal and Burma ?

May be Bangladesh not !
 

Tshering22

Sikkimese Saber
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
7,869
Likes
23,241
Country flag
I must say that it would be interesting to see the following:

VS


It would be a contest of a decade!
 

Tshering22

Sikkimese Saber
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
7,869
Likes
23,241
Country flag
Add one more question to the list.
By what time frame Chinese will take over Pakistan, Nepal and Burma ?
He doesn't frame the policies completely. The CCP does. So naturally, he would try to comply with that without annoying the rest of CCP members too much in the beginning.

May be Bangladesh not !
Depends on what we get there; Zia or Haseena.
 

Blackwater

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2012
Messages
21,156
Likes
12,211
Ten Questions for China's Heir Presumptive

1) Why copy?
2) Why copy?
3)Why copy?
4)Why copy?
5)Why copy?
6)Why paki?
7)Why paki?
8)Why paki?
9)Why paki?
10)Why paki?


:p:p:p
 

redragon

Regular Member
Joined
Sep 20, 2009
Messages
956
Likes
58
Country flag
Ten Questions for China's Heir Presumptive

1) Why copy?
2) Why copy?
3)Why copy?
4)Why copy?
5)Why copy?
6)Why paki?
7)Why paki?
8)Why paki?
9)Why paki?
10)Why paki?


:p:p:p
That was brilliant, you nailed what Indian are always hooked with.
 

SPIEZ

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2011
Messages
3,508
Likes
1,021
Country flag
A serious question, how does China elect it's leader with a single party policy :confused2: ?
 

Ray

The Chairman
Professional
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
Messages
43,132
Likes
23,835
I don't think the Chinese posters are cleared by their Party to answer the question and so they will go down the usual way - obfuscate and tangentially spiral the discussion in to oblivion!

One cannot blame them.

They are not empowered as citizens to speak as a citizen in a democracy can!

I sympathise with them and their anguish!
 

Ray

The Chairman
Professional
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
Messages
43,132
Likes
23,835
I really wonder what is the policies that Xi Jumping will follow.

Their face reveals nothing!

Poker face!

Is he a Northern Chinese or is he a happy go lucky Southern Chinese, who love and understand the good things of life.

The Northern chaps are as cold as their terrain and the cold wind and their winters.

They used to have earthen bed with fire going on under them so that they could sleep!
 
Last edited:

AprilLyrics

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2011
Messages
380
Likes
54
A serious question, how does China elect it's leader with a single party policy :confused2: ?
this is not like most western countries' electoral politics.but there is similarities.

as we all know,CCP is the ruling party of china.so the president of the CCP should be the president of china naturally.or,the power will be separated.and that would lead to problems for policy implementation.just imagine that Obama is the president,but Republican Party controled the senate and House of Representatives.of cause,china is not two-party politics,the problem should not be that serious.but as CCP is the ruling power,if china have two leaders,a leader of CCP and a leader of the country,there should be problems.

back to your question,how:

how does Sarkozy become the leader of UMP
how does merkel become the leader of CDU
how does YASUO FUKUDA became the leader of Partai Liberal Democrat Jepang

there r some similarities.

in a word,china combines country leader with party leader.once the party leader is confirmed,the country leader is confirmed.in some other countries,a party leader should be confirmed first,then they competes to be the country leader.
 

AprilLyrics

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2011
Messages
380
Likes
54
I really wonder what is the policies that Xi Jumping will follow.

Their face reveals nothing!

Poker face!

Is he a Northern Chinese or is he a happy go lucky Southern Chinese, who love and understand the good things of life.

The Northern chaps are as cold as their terrain and the cold wind and their winters.

They used to have earthen bed with fire going on under them so that they could sleep!
en,maybe u can see what Bo Xilai is doing in Chongqing.But Xi is a low-key man.i mean Xi wont do things Aggressively like Bo,but i think they have similar concept.
 

LTE-TDD

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2011
Messages
211
Likes
20
I don't think the Chinese posters are cleared by their Party to answer the question and so they will go down the usual way - obfuscate and tangentially spiral the discussion in to oblivion!

One cannot blame them.

They are not empowered as citizens to speak as a citizen in a democracy can!

I sympathise with them and their anguish!

How Indian elect your corrupted government or how you make them corrupted ?
 

nimo_cn

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2009
Messages
4,032
Likes
883
Country flag
I don't think the Chinese posters are cleared by their Party to answer the question and so they will go down the usual way - obfuscate and tangentially spiral the discussion in to oblivion!

One cannot blame them.

They are not empowered as citizens to speak as a citizen in a democracy can!

I sympathise with them and their anguish!
@Chinese members

Why are you still replying him after reading this?

He has made it clear that anyone who can not give answers satisfying him is fooled by CPC. How many of you are capable of doing that?
 

AprilLyrics

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2011
Messages
380
Likes
54
@Chinese members

Why are you still replying him after reading this?

He has made it clear that anyone who can not give answers satisfying him is fooled by CPC. How many of you are capable of doing that?
you're right.i didn't see his reply.
 
Last edited:

Tianshan

Regular Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2011
Messages
675
Likes
249
@Chinese members

Why are you still replying him after reading this?

He has made it clear that anyone who can not give answers satisfying him is fooled by CPC. How many of you are capable of doing that?
yes, unfortunately they do not seem to be interested in objective answers.

if they dont like the answer, then we are brainwashed. if they like the answer, then we have defeated the brainwashing.

it doesnt matter if it is true or not or objective or not.
 

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top