Seven blunders that will haunt India for posterity

Discussion in 'Defence & Strategic Issues' started by JBH22, Jul 29, 2010.

  1. JBH22

    JBH22 Senior Member Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jul 29, 2010
    Messages:
    3,620
    Likes Received:
    2,390
    History is most unforgiving. As historical mistakes cannot be undone, they have complex cascading effect on a nation’s future. Here is a saga of seven historical blunders that have changed the course of independent India’s history and cast a dark shadow over its future. These costly mistakes will continue to haunt India for generations. They have been recounted here in a chronological order with a view to highlight inadequacies of India’s decision making apparatus and leadership’s incompetence to act with vision.

    1. The Kashmir Mess

    There can be no better example of shooting in one’s own foot than India’s clumsy handling of the Kashmir issue. It is a saga of naivety, blinkered vision and inept leadership. Hari Singh was the reigning monarch of the state of Jammu and Kashmir in 1947. He was vacillating when tribal marauders invaded Kashmir in October 1947, duly backed by the Pakistan army. Unable to counter them, Hari Singh appealed to India for assistance and agreed to accede to India. Indian forces blunted the invasion and re-conquered vast areas.

    First, India erred by not insisting on unequivocal accession of the state to the Dominion of India and granted special status to it through Article 380 of the Constitution. Secondly, when on the verge of evicting all invaders and recapturing the complete state, India halted operations on 1 January 1949 and appealed to the Security Council. It is the only case in known history wherein a country, when on the threshold of complete victory, has voluntarily forsaken it in the misplaced hope of winning admiration of the world community. Thirdly and most shockingly, the Indian leadership made a highly unconstitutional offer of plebiscite in the UN.

    Forty percent area of the state continues to be under Pakistan’s control, providing it a strategic land route to China through the Karakoram ranges. As a fall out of the unresolved dispute, India and Pakistan have fought numerous wars and skirmishes with no solution in sight. Worse, the local politicians are holding India to ransom by playing the Pak card. Kashmir issue is a self created cancerous furuncle that defies all medications and continues to bleed the country.

    2. Ignoring Chinese Threats and Neglect of the Military

    Memories of the year 1962 will always trouble the Indian psyche. A nation of India’s size had lulled itself into believing that its protestations and platitudes of peaceful co-existence would be reciprocated by the world. It was often stated that a peace loving nation like India did not need military at all. The armed forces were neglected. Political leadership took pride in denigrating the military leadership and meddled in internal affairs of the services to promote sycophancy. Foreign policy was in shambles. Intelligence apparatus was rusted.

    Even though signs of China’s aggressive intentions were clearly discernible for years in advance, Indian leadership decided to keep its eyes shut in the fond hope that the problem would resolve itself. When China struck, the country was caught totally unprepared. Troops were rushed to snowbound areas with summer clothing and outdated rifles. Despite numerous sagas of gallantry, the country suffered terrible embarrassment. India was on its knees. With national morale and pride in tatters, India was forced to appeal to all nations for military aid. Inept and incompetent leadership had forced a proud nation to find solace in Lata Mangeshkar’s ‘Ae Mere Watan Ke Logo’.

    3. The Tashkent Agreement and Return of Haji Pir Pass

    Following the cease-fire after the Indo-Pak War of 1965, a Russian sponsored agreement was signed between India and Pakistan in Tashkent on 10 January 1966. Under the agreement, India agreed to return the strategic Haji Pir pass to Pakistan which it had captured in August 1965 against heavy odds and at a huge human cost. The pass connects Poonch and Uri sectors in Jammu and Kashmir and reduces the distance between the two sectors to 15 km whereas the alternate route entails a travel of over 200 km. India got nothing in return except an undertaking by Pakistan to abjure war, an undertaking which meant little as Pakistan never had any intention of honouring it.

    Return of the vital Haji Pir pass was a mistake of monumental proportions for which India is suffering to date. In addition to denying a direct link between Poonch and Uri sectors, the pass is being effectively used by Pakistan to sponsor infiltration of terrorists into India. Inability to resist Russian pressure was a manifestation of the boneless Indian foreign policy and shortsighted leadership.

    4. The Simla Agreement

    With the fall of Dhaka on 16 December 1971, India had scored a decisive victory over Pakistan. Over 96,000 Pak soldiers were taken Prisoners of War (PoWs). Later, an agreement was signed between the two countries on 2 July 1972 at Shimla. Both countries agreed to exchange all PoWs, respect the line of control (LOC) in Jammu and Kashmir and refrain from the use of threat or force. Additionally, Bhutto gave a solemn verbal undertaking to accept LOC as the de facto border.
    India released all Pak PoWs in good faith. Pakistan, on the other hand, released only 617 Indian PoWs while holding back 54 PoWs who are still languishing in Pakistani jails. The Indian Government has admitted this fact a number of times but has failed to secure their release. India failed to use the leverage of 96,000 Pak PoWs to discipline Pakistan. A rare opportunity was thus wasted. What to talk of establishing permanent peace in the sub-continent, India failed to ensure release of all Indian PoWs – a criminal omission by all accounts.

    Naivety of the Indian delegation can be seen from the fact that it allowed Pakistan to bluff its way through at Shimla. The Indian leadership was fooled into believing Pakistan’s sincerity. Unquestionably, Pakistan never intended to abide by its promises, both written and verbal. Fruits of a hard fought victory in the battlefield were frittered away on a negotiating table by bungling leadership.

    5. The Nuclear Muddle

    Subsequent to the Chinese Nuclear Test at Lop Nor in 1964, India showed rare courage in carrying out its first nuclear test on 18 May 1974 at Pokharan. Outside the five permanent members of the UN Security Council, India was the only nation to prove its nuclear capability. The whole country was ecstatic and every Indian felt proud of its scientific prowess. But Indians had not contended with their Government’s penchant for converting opportunity into adversity and squandering hard earned gains.

    Instead of asserting India’s newly acquired status of a nuclear power and demanding recognition, India turned apologetic and tried to convince the world that it had no nuclear ambitions. Strangely, it termed the Pokharan test as a ‘peaceful nuclear explosion’ – a term unheard of till then. The Defence Minister went to the extent of claiming that the Indian nuclear experiment was “only for mining, oil and gas prospecting, for finding underground sources of water, for diverting rivers, for scientific and technological knowledge.” It was a self-deprecating stance. Displaying acute inferiority complex, India did not want to be counted as a member of the exclusive nuclear club.

    Criticism and sanctions were expected and must have been factored in before opting for the nuclear test. Whereas a few more assertive follow-on tests would have forced the world to accept India as a member of the nuclear club, India went into an overdrive to placate the world through a self imposed moratorium on further testing. It lost out on all the advantages provided to it by its scientists. It suffered sanctions and yet failed to gain recognition as a nuclear power. The country missed golden opportunities due to the timidity and spinelessness of its leaders.

    6. Kandahar Hijack


    Hijacking of an Indian Airlines aircraft to Kandahar by Pakistani terrorists in December 1999 will continue to rile India’s self-respect for long. According to the Hindustan Times, India lost face and got reduced to begging for co-operation from the very regimes that were actively undermining its internal security. The hijacking revealed how ill-prepared India was to face up to the challenges of international terrorism.The eight day long ordeal was over when India’s National Security Adviser brazenly announced that an agreement had been reached for the release of all the hostages in exchange for three Kashmiri militants including Maulana Masood Azhar. Sadly, the Prime Minister claimed credit for forcing the hijackers to climb down on their demands. The worst was yet to follow. India’s Foreign Minister decided to accompany the released militants to Kandahar, as if seeing off honoured guests.

    Government’s poor crisis-management skills and extreme complacency in security matters allowed the hijackers to take off from Amritsar airport after 39 minutes halt for refueling, thereby letting the problem get out of control. India’s much vaunted decision making apparatus collapsed and was completely paralysed by the audacity of a bunch of motivated fanatics. It was a comprehensive failure of monumental proportions. India’s slack and amateurish functioning made the country earn the tag of a soft nation which it will find very difficult to shed.

    7. Illegal Immigration and Passage of IMDT Act

    It is a standard practice all over the world that the burden of proving one’s status as a bonafide citizen of a country falls on the accused. It is so for India as well under Foreigners Act, 1946. Political expediency forced the Government to make an exception for Assam. In one of the most short-sighted and anti-national moves, India passed Illegal Migrants – Determination by Tribunals (IMDT) Act of 1984 for Assam. It shifted the onus of proving illegal status of a suspected immigrant to the accuser, which was a tall and virtually impossible order. Detection and deportation of illegal immigrants became impossible.

    Whenever demands were raised for repealing the Act, Congress, Left Front and United Minorities Front resisted strongly. Illegal immigrants had become the most loyal vote bank of the Congress. Worse, every protest against the Act was dubbed as ‘anti-minority’, thereby imparting communal colour to an issue of national security. Government’s ‘pardon’ of all Bangladeshis who had come in before 1985 was another unconstitutional act that aggravated the problem.

    The Act was struck down as unconstitutional by the Supreme Court on July 13, 2005, more than 20 years after its enactment. The Apex Court was of the view that the influx of Bangladeshi nationals into Assam posed a threat to the integrity and security of northeastern region. Unfortunately immense damage had already been done to the demography of Assam and the local people of Assam had been reduced to minority status in certain districts. Illegal immigrants have come to have a stranglehold over electioneering to the extent that no party can hope to come to power without their support. Nearly 30 Islamic groups are thriving in the area to further their Islamist and Pan Bangla Desh agenda. It is incomprehensible that a nation’s leadership can stoop so low and endanger even national security for garnering votes.

    Finally, is India Wiser Today?

    Two features are common to all the above mentioned blunders. First, all decisions were taken by the political leadership and the bureaucracy. The military leadership was neither taken into confidence nor consulted. As a matter of fact it was deliberately kept out of the decision making loop. Although military is the primary stake holder in India’s nuclear prowess, it was not considered necessary to take it in confidence while taking decisions of strategic proportions
    Both Tashkant and Shimla Agreements were preceded by bitterly fought wars. They entailed negotiating the extent, scope and modalities of withdrawal from occupied areas. Even then, no need was felt to seek military’s advice and no service officer was included in the Indian delegations. Political leaders and the bureaucracy abrogated the right to negotiate military matters, in the egoistic belief that they were more qualified for the task. The results were disastrous, as mentioned above.

    The second common feature is that no political leader or bureaucrat was ever held accountable for monumental blunders made by them. On the contrary, every single bureaucrat made it to the higher grades and was even given lucrative post-retirement appointments. It is an obnoxious sight to see the guilty men of the above blunders masquerading as foreign policy experts on TV shows and unabashedly offering their pearls of wisdom.

    The above mentioned seven indefensible blunders have had enormous impact on the security, standing and history of India. Future generations will rue the fact that the Indian leadership failed the nation at critical junctures due to incompetence, ineptitude and selfish interests. Proclivity for perpetuating personal power made the leadership shortsighted and egocentric. But for the historical blunders, the current Indian geo-political scenario would have been totally different.

    Has India learnt any lesson? Unfortunately, none whatsoever. Even now, military leadership is consciously and willfully kept out of all decision making apparatus. Even issues that affect security of the nation are decided by the bureaucrats who do not possess even elementary knowledge of military matters. It is only in India that well connected retired bureaucrats are offered membership of the National Security Council (NSC) as a rehabilitation measure. Merit and expertise are of little consequence. Further, India is perhaps the only country in the world wherein NSC does not have a single military member. Bureaucrats and ex-police officers have made NSC their exclusive domain, thereby depriving the nation of expert military advice. Resultantly, recurring blunders will continue to cost the country dear.
     
    A.V. likes this.
  2.  
  3. ajtr

    ajtr Veteran Member Veteran Member

    Joined:
    Oct 2, 2009
    Messages:
    12,038
    Likes Received:
    715
    8 ) Gifting Coco Islands to Burma by nehru today were chinese are sitting happily making it as their listening post thereby spying on ISRO launches at sriharikota and missile launches at wheeler's island.

    9) Not accepting the accession to India of Chittagong by nehru, which was 98% Budhist. The water link of NE was lost, Bangladesh link to China established via Burma. Chicken neck problem initiated.

    10) Stopping the advancing indian armies in 1948 there by failing to recover whole of J&K.

    11)Gifting the kilinochi island to srilanka by indira which later became LTTE base.
     
    Nagraj, Tshering22 and A.V. like this.
  4. Known_Unknown

    Known_Unknown Devil's Advocate Stars and Ambassadors

    Joined:
    Apr 21, 2009
    Messages:
    2,632
    Likes Received:
    1,664
    Location:
    Earth
    ^^All chaddi-walla's propaganda.

    http://www.burmanet.org/news/2007/0...s-the-great-coco-island-mystery-andrew-selth/

    Besides, the Coco Islands were never India's to give away. They were always part of Burma, and when Burma was separated from India by the British in 1937, they went along with it. Such revisionist nonsense spouted by the Sangh Parivar has no place in any credible debate.
     
  5. Mustang

    Mustang Regular Member

    Joined:
    Jul 29, 2010
    Messages:
    64
    Likes Received:
    0
    Enjoyed reading that ariticle known_unknown.

    Sometimes or actually most of the times, media wants some "scandalous" news to increase their viewership. When H1N1 started, media made a huge news out of it. now not even a single media is reporting it.
     
  6. JBH22

    JBH22 Senior Member Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jul 29, 2010
    Messages:
    3,620
    Likes Received:
    2,390
    Kindly elaborate where Sangh parivar comes into the picture? Chaddi-walla's propaganda is hell way better than we get across with Zaleel Hamid.
     
    Tshering22 likes this.
  7. Phenom

    Phenom Regular Member

    Joined:
    Mar 6, 2010
    Messages:
    878
    Likes Received:
    401
    Quite a few of them are related to Pakistan, so if Pakistan fails these mistakes would become less costly. But other like Kandhar Hijacking and Bangladeshi migrations will probably haunt India for a long time.
     
  8. Known_Unknown

    Known_Unknown Devil's Advocate Stars and Ambassadors

    Joined:
    Apr 21, 2009
    Messages:
    2,632
    Likes Received:
    1,664
    Location:
    Earth
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coco_Islands

    The defence minister of your NDA government and other chaddi wallas love to come up with conspiracy theories, don't they? Maybe because that's the only way they can think of to belittle the legacy of our great freedom fighters. Spreading rumours, half-truths and blatant lies in order to consolidate their ideological base is an integral part of their political strategy.
     
  9. JBH22

    JBH22 Senior Member Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jul 29, 2010
    Messages:
    3,620
    Likes Received:
    2,390
    I don't see how it becomes NDA and UPA crops up into this thread how are they related? UPA is no better with their spinless tenure..
     
    Tshering22 likes this.
  10. Neil

    Neil Senior Member Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jun 23, 2010
    Messages:
    2,610
    Likes Received:
    1,946
    Location:
    India
    1971 was the worst blunder India has gone through...we would have taken back our land-JnK easily....instead we chose to give away land that we had captured from pakistan....
     
  11. JBH22

    JBH22 Senior Member Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jul 29, 2010
    Messages:
    3,620
    Likes Received:
    2,390
    Indian leadership (under congress mostly) squandered each opportunity to strengthen India defenses.Many here won't acknowledge it as to Bjp the Kandahar incident will always haunt them.
     
  12. sandeepdg

    sandeepdg Senior Member Senior Member

    Joined:
    Sep 5, 2009
    Messages:
    2,333
    Likes Received:
    216
    Location:
    Gurgaon/Noida
    I guess we will have to live with most of these blunders for a long long time !!!
     
  13. prateikf

    prateikf Regular Member

    Joined:
    Jul 14, 2009
    Messages:
    211
    Likes Received:
    42
    very good article. the Indian govt. is the most foolish in the world. rest assured they will continue to repeat these blunders for as long as possible. Even now the indian govt. is talking to the pakis though it is evidet that they did absolutely nothing after 26/11.
    what happened to the so many dossiers given by our govt. to the govt. of Pornistan?(Pornistan sounds far better than pakistan)
     
  14. JBH22

    JBH22 Senior Member Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jul 29, 2010
    Messages:
    3,620
    Likes Received:
    2,390
    India is on the path of development after so many painstaking effort let's not destroy everything the enemy has a sh!tty economy already living on foreign aid they are waiting for that war doesn't mean India is scared we kicked their butt 4 times when we had "inferior" hardware but "superior" will to fight and better soldiers. what need to be done a strong political establishment that knows how to strengthen India's internal security improve RAW and IB and we continue with our economic development. When the people across border will see where we are and where they are they'll realise what a waste of time it was though on the downside Freaks like Zaleel Hamid will feast on conspiracy theories how Jewish-Hindu nexus destroyed their "beautiful,mighty" nation.:emot180:
     
  15. Yusuf

    Yusuf GUARDIAN Administrator

    Joined:
    Mar 24, 2009
    Messages:
    24,274
    Likes Received:
    11,290
    Location:
    BANGalore
    While past is a good experience for the future, I think it would be a good idea as to where we can go wrong now and in near future with respect to foreign policy. What we should and should not do. And this is not wrt to pakistan but in overall global scheme as we are now looking at the big picture. That for me is more important right now. We have to firmly seat ourselves at the high table of global geopolitical affairs.
     
  16. Iamanidiot

    Iamanidiot Elite Member Elite Member

    Joined:
    Dec 21, 2009
    Messages:
    5,326
    Likes Received:
    1,493
    Enough of this Nehru bashing going on in the forum.Nehru did more yeomen service to india in post-independent india than any other leader.It is because of his democratic behaviour the strengthening of indias democratic institutions became strong.His presence held the people together for the first 16 years of the indian republic with his towering personality.IF not for him we might have become a banana republic.so give the great man his due.No more righty bashing against nehru please.He may have been naive in the international republic but his domestic policy is unrivalled in third world countries at that time.He never subjected us Indians to the perils Mao did to the chinese at that time
     
  17. JBH22

    JBH22 Senior Member Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jul 29, 2010
    Messages:
    3,620
    Likes Received:
    2,390
    Naive he wasn't that stupid don't you remember he was one of the leaders along Nasser and Sukato of the Non-aligned movement of course there he got much glory but he overlook national security don't deny that.He did BLUNDERS which cannot be forgiven and also some GOOD things which equally cannot be forgotten.
     
  18. S.A.T.A

    S.A.T.A Senior Member Senior Member

    Joined:
    Mar 28, 2009
    Messages:
    1,804
    Likes Received:
    453
    Accepting the partition of the homeland was the only blunder that should keep every generation of Indians fuming,remaining are mere consequences of the same.However our civilizational blunder wasn't Nehru's fault alone or Gandhi's or sardar's,it was a collective failure to read the writing on the great wall of history,the evolution of a natural nation state cannot be disrupted without triggering a cascading socio-political after affect.

    It was perhaps our misfortune that at the time of the birth of our republic,India was blessed with more statesmen than hardnosed political leaders.The question now is how set about undoing the blunders.
     
  19. ejazr

    ejazr Stars and Ambassadors Stars and Ambassadors

    Joined:
    Oct 8, 2009
    Messages:
    4,518
    Likes Received:
    1,378
    Location:
    Hyderabad and Sydney
    Nothing happens in a global vacuum. All regional politics happens in the shadow of greatpower politics. The reason Nehru had to contend with the LoC was the pressure put by UK and American tostop hostilities. India was a nely emrgent country with massive refugee crisis and a improvesihed population. India could not have afforded a military conflict insuch a way espicially since the Gilgit Areas were populated by pro-Pakistani muslims unlike the valley Kashmiris. However, gifting away NWFP even after winning the elections there was a blunder. But the UK and US needed these crucial areas like the air base in Gilgit to use against USSR. Their role played int he partition as shown in declassfied documents can not be put out of the picture.

    SEcondly in 71, Indira Gandhi again was pressured by the US to live W. Pakistan alone and the USSR also prevailed on this. Moreover, the IA could not have moved qucikly all its armour from the East Pakistan side towards W. Pakistan to take advantage of the situation. You must recal that India won a war withing 2 weeks. And as time goes by great powers intervene to contain conflicts.
     
  20. Energon

    Energon DFI stars Stars and Ambassadors

    Joined:
    Jun 3, 2009
    Messages:
    1,199
    Likes Received:
    760
    After reading your thorough list of all the wrongs I was reminded of the Rime of the Ancient Mariner... 'Water water everywhere nor any a drop to drink'.

    I couldn't find in your list, the follies responsible for India's greatest perennial plight (which is technically also the greatest humanitarian disaster after Mao's caper)- Crushing poverty, hunger, deprivation, shocking disparity, abysmal standard of living, social stagnation, injustice, inhuman social hierarchy and all other such factors which contribute toward making most parts of India inhospitable to a dignified human life. A lot of posters were very upset when I said this the last time, so I'll repeat it again. India is now and has been for a while one of the worst places on the planet to be born as a human being. The statistical probability of an Indian suffering and dying a horrible death from these issues is far, far greater than being killed by a Kashmiri jihadi, a Chinese invasion, a Pakistani terrorist, an illegal Bangladeshi immigrant or in a nuclear holocaust.

    It is the persistent depraved pyramidal society governed by poor economic and social policies making the state incapable of providing a vast majority of its people the basic necessities of life that has kept post independence India a weak under developed nation which remains paralyzed in the face of external threat. What you have listed here are merely symptoms of a greater disease. It is also the reason why nothing ever gets resolved; at which point everybody starts lamenting over the lack of "killer instinct" of the vegetarian Indian.

    If you really want a list, I suggest you look into all the disastrous decisions that have been made over time leading to India's current state. I am fairly certain that it is here that the solutions lie to alleviate most of India's chronic problems, not just socially, but also in terms of national security.

    Peace
     
    Last edited: Aug 10, 2010
    A.V. likes this.
  21. Energon

    Energon DFI stars Stars and Ambassadors

    Joined:
    Jun 3, 2009
    Messages:
    1,199
    Likes Received:
    760
    India despite the heroics of the freedom fighters was still a poor, enervated and debilitated entity, and certainly not in a position to categorically accept or reject what the retreating colonizers doled out.

    For all practical purposes balkanization is the natural evolutionary course for weak states that are unable to govern themselves. I honestly think it would have happened one way or another. The schisms were far too deep and the resources scarce for people to revert back to recognizing the greater Indian entity (with which you identify).

    I think everyone in or hailing from the subcontinent (including me) is inculcated with this great fear and derision of balkanization and instinctively react with extreme emotions of rage or sorrow at the thought of secessions/ divisions etc. and for good measure too, given the sheer carnage that was unfolded upon our older generations during partition. However, people like Jared Diamond (Guns germs and steel) have rightfully pointed out that balkanization of weak states actually tends to be beneficial in the long run by serving as a national Darwinian mechanism of sort. Given how things have developed over the last 63 years, it seems like his observation may hold true not just for Europe but also for South Asia.
     
    A.V. likes this.

Share This Page