Just a simple question why recruiting IPS officers to paramil on deputation when there is direcct recruitment to the post of Asst commandants.Why always IPS officers to ledd the para millitary as every one knows that they dont have much training in the roles done by para military whicch are doing mainly CT ops
The question is not so simple as you project it to be
Historically IPS have been the finest police officers to lead the Police.
Good officers from non-IPS cadres were promoted to IPS cadre.
so, It was always a IPS who lead a police force. similar to their civil counterpart.(IAS)
But as you rightfully pointed out this cadre recently have been found wanting in their leadership for CAPF's who have a unique position between Armed forces and policing force.
So, the article from where I have quoted recommends few points to remove certain problems pertaining to IPS, among them are a few point related to IPS in CAPF's
The article proposes that IPS should be the only directly recruited officer in CAPF's from UPSC.
But,
The recommendation are to be followed after a series of reforms proposed in the article.
The prominent being creating a center cadre of IPS for CAPF's who would be of 20-24 years and undergo 5yrs of training including field work.
The other offices will be from armed forces and other officers from CAPF's who will have the option to get promoted as IPS later
The rest officers in CAPF's will be IPS from state cadres to improve inter-operatibility.
So, when young officers are recruited as IPS in centre cadre and given 5 yrs of training on specifics of operation on CAPF's then there will be no requirement of asst-commandant level direct requirement.
But, in the present format, the IPS still represents a feudal representative and they occupying top-level positions do hamper the operation as they are not exposed to that kind of operations in their careers.
Also asst-commandant officers who are promoted fair well because they have considerable experience of leading field operation.
What the CRPF lacks the most is efficient leadership. They have officers upto the rank of Commandant who come up from the rank of the Assistant Commandant when they join as young officers. These officers lead the troops in all operations. Unfortunately, the feudal mindset and police culture affects them as well. What is required are officers well trained in CI operations. Even more important are higher level leadership. This is where the rot lies since most of the DIGs and IGs and DGs are IPS officers who have never served in counter-insurgency operations. While they may have been excellent policemen, they have never led troops in CI operations and have no clue how to go about planning such operations. Thus on the ground, CRPF troops go around harassing villagers – adding fire to the fuel of LWE.
CRPF: A force in denial | India Security Monitor
But there is considerable tussle between IPS and non-iPS in CAPF's for promotion and due to skewed procedures deserving is not always promoted
The Central Police Organisations have a total number of 1416 posts of Class I officers out of which 269 i.e. 19%; are occupied by IPS officers and the bulk of these are in the ranks of DIsG, IsG and above. There are only 2 non-IPS I&G and 31 non-IPS DIsG and they belong to the respective CPOs. There are now 1114 officers in the Senior Time Scale belonging to these organisations who aspire for the higher posts in the Central Police Organisations.
Quoted from pdf from post no. 8
The data is old but gives a good picture.
But all is not lost in the current situation and tussle between IPS and non-IPS
First non-IPS officer to head BSF operations at Indo-Bangla border
First non-IPS officer to head BSF operations at Indo-Bangla border - Times Of India
But IPS is an excellent cadre but their training are not in sync with demand that CAPF's face.
Some of the recommendation might have been already accepted by PMO as
was proposed a lateral entry of CAPF, armed forces and state police forces into IPS cadre
UPSC to hold separate exams to fill vacant Indian Police Services posts
But unfortunately AFAIK this is presently under stay order.