Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Students

badguy2000

Respected Member
Senior Member
Joined
May 20, 2009
Messages
5,133
Likes
746
CHESTNUT HILL, MA—According to an alarming new report published Wednesday by the International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement, third-graders in China are beginning to lag behind U.S. high school students in math and science.
龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.comThe study, based on exam scores from thousands of students in 63 participating countries, confirmed that in mathematical and scientific literacy, American students from the ages of 14 to 18 have now actually pulled slightly ahead of their 8-year-old Chinese counterparts.
"This is certainly a wake-up call for China," said Dr. Michael Fornasier, an IEA senior fellow and coauthor of the report. "The test results unfortunately indicate that education standards in China have slipped to the extent that pre-teens are struggling to rank among even the average American high school student."
"Simply put, how can these third-graders be expected to eventually compete in the global marketplace if they're only receiving the equivalent of a U.S. high school education?" Fornasier added.
Fornasier stressed that while the gap is not yet dramatically sizable, it has widened over the past two years after American high schoolers tested marginally higher in algebra, biology, and chemistry than, shockingly, most of China's 8- and 9-year-olds.
"For decades, young children in China have scored at the expected level of their peers in American high schools, so this is a very worrying drop in performance," said Fornasier, adding that the majority of Chinese third-graders are now a full year behind the average U.S. 12th-grader in their knowledge of calculus. "In the chemistry portion of the exam, for example, Chinese children proved to be slightly deficient compared to American teenagers in their understanding of the periodic table, molecular structure, and the essential principles of atomic theory."
"And even when they did test at the same level in mathematics, it often took Chinese elementary school students 10 to 15 minutes longer to do simple things like factor a polynomial equation or compute the derivative of a continuous function," Fornasier added. "That just isn't normal."
In addition to disappointing marks from grade school children in China, 10-year-olds in Germany, South Korea, Japan, Switzerland, and New Guinea also reportedly tested an average of three percentage points lower than U.S. high school seniors in physics, with education officials from each country expressing deep concerns about the increasingly mediocre quality of their primary schools.
In light of the alarming study, many in China have called for considerable reforms of the country's education system, including implementing far stricter standards for teachers, investing in better learning materials, and increasing the length of school days.
"Our third grade classes clearly cannot afford to lag behind American high schools if they are to be successful in the future," read an official statement from China's Minister of Education, Yuan Guiren. "Frankly, the scores are unacceptable, and we have to turn this around immediately. If there's an American 17-year-old who can do something academically that a Chinese 8-year-old can't, that's a very big problem."
"At that rate, how do we expect our Chinese 13-year-olds to be ready for American colleges?" Yuan continued
Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Students in Math, Science | The Onion - America's Finest News Source
 

pmaitra

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2009
Messages
33,262
Likes
19,594
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

Comparing 8 year olds with 14 and 18 year olds? Very rhetorical article. Can we get a bit more objective?
 

satish007

Senior Member
Joined
May 7, 2011
Messages
1,458
Likes
203
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

welcome back, Badguy, why they jailed you?
What's you want your son become once he grow up?

I have a daughter, she wanted to become a housewife and after she knew housewife must do many housekeeping , she changed her mind, she want do nothing once she grow up.

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2013-03/12/content_16302338.htm
 
Last edited:

hello_10

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Nov 17, 2012
Messages
1,880
Likes
680
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

Comparing 8 year olds with 14 and 18 year olds? Very rhetorical article. Can we get a bit more objective?
a very good comment.... I too have seen 22-26 year old persons in class 7th-8th in Australia as they take so many breaks even in schools that its simply foolish to compare a country like India/China with US/Australia type countries. they just can't have an environment of studies, they can't do this........:wave:

US/Australia type countries can't have environment of studying hard in schools, its not worth, neither they have the background to do so also. only the kids of Asians bring that background, but they finally lag with those who directly come from India, as there is simply no environment of doing something in life by 'studying hard'. these kids may only build body and have more fun since 13-14, the best time to enjoy life and thats what they do since then, which does help these nations have more medals in sports.... and its the time when Asian kids utilize for struggle on the side of education.... :ranger:
 

opesys

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2012
Messages
279
Likes
138
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

a very good comment.... I too have seen 22-26 year old persons in class 7th-8th in Australia as they take so many breaks even in schools that its simply foolish to compare a country like India/China with US/Australia type countries. they just can't have an environment of studies, they can't do this........:wave:

US/Australia type countries can't have environment of studying hard in schools, its not worth, neither they have the background to do so also. only the kids of Asians bring that background, but they finally lag with those who directly come from India, as there is simply no environment of doing something in life by 'studying hard'. these kids may only build body and have more fun since 13-14, the best time to enjoy life and thats what they do since then, which does help these nations have more medals in sports.... and its the time when Asian kids utilize for struggle on the side of education.... :ranger:
The kind of education that is promoted and followed in India/China is at best good for becoming good engineers and not scientists. Scientists who do research of fundamentals are mostly from the US or Europe. Education is never forced in the US so all those who survive high school and go on for higher studies are the ones who really want to do higher studies out of passion and not because for survival in the society which is the case in India/China. This does make a huge difference in creating cutting edge tech.
 

datguy79

Regular Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2012
Messages
702
Likes
945
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

My university is flooded with Chinese people, who are obviously pretty smart due to the years of hard work put in math/science, but can't form a single coherent sentence in English. Every year 60% of them fail the english exam required to graduate, which is at best a gr.9 level exam here.

Focusing so much on math and science has also made the Chinese fall decades behind in all arts disciplines, such as psychology, sociology, etc.
 

hello_10

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Nov 17, 2012
Messages
1,880
Likes
680
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

The kind of education that is promoted and followed in India/China is at best good for becoming good engineers and not scientists. Scientists who do research of fundamentals are mostly from the US or Europe. Education is never forced in the US so all those who survive high school and go on for higher studies are the ones who really want to do higher studies out of passion and not because for survival in the society which is the case in India/China. This does make a huge difference in creating cutting edge tech.
thats the dilution people have while sitting in India..... I studied my Master of Engineering and Master of Engineering Management from University of Technology Sydney, which is ranked quite high in world, but I couldn't see even a single Aussie doing Master of Engineering studies..... i just remember one who joined our class for a chapter which was common with bachelor of engineering.... even in BE classes, such a high ranked university and not even 10 whites you may find there.... but we did have 7-8 Europeans in our 60+ class.....

also I would share my experience here, we used to have assignment for the type of problems which we used to solves in 'close book' exams in India in our bachelor while so big formulas they use but still they used to give a week time to submit the solved problems, the assignments.....:tsk:

you would keep in you mind that Western Scientific Awards are given to the bosses for the works their Juniors do. i mean, even if they may arrange 4-5 whites for a project, and if they have just one Indian in that certain group, then he/she is the person who is doing the main works and rest are supporting him/her. they just can't produce a 'competent' professionals, even if they may have engineers. :wave:

I mean, even the 20th ranked swimmer of Australia would be better than Indian best as they have an environment to do so, a national level efforts with proper infrastructure. the same you find Indian cricket/hockey teams which perform good as India has a national level awareness for these sports. and in the same way, US/Australia can't have 'any' competent professional of the category of migrants they get :wave:. if you have a society to do something, then only you get few 100s the best, among 1000s very good, and 100,000 'good enough'. US's/Australian kids just can't be the reason of any technology US may develop, in the same way like how the best Indian swimmer can't be compared with even the 40th ranked US's one....:wave:


=> no matter how talented you was since your birth, you have to have 10-15 years of "quite hard work" on education, 2 millions kids do that then 200,000 are "good enough", and 20,000 are the creamy layers, and half of them are taken to the Western nations, finally..... the way we have been part of discussions, even with the professionals of reverse engineering team, they just can't understand, how can US have technology without migrants? i do remember a Polish girl who was fired on even Germany, while stating that 90%+ of their professional team is made of migrants, and mainly Indians and Polish do the main works for those German companies....:ranger:
 
Last edited:

hello_10

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Nov 17, 2012
Messages
1,880
Likes
680
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

My university is flooded with Chinese people, who are obviously pretty smart due to the years of hard work put in math/science, but can't form a single coherent sentence in English. Every year 60% of them fail the english exam required to graduate, which is at best a gr.9 level exam here.

Focusing so much on math and science has also made the Chinese fall decades behind in all arts disciplines, such as psychology, sociology, etc.
say it Asians, a very good word to cover 90%+ students of Engineering/Medicine studies of Western Universities. with confirming that the kids of Asians are also Asians, in fact, even if they have citizenship from their parents :wave:
 

satish007

Senior Member
Joined
May 7, 2011
Messages
1,458
Likes
203
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

thats the dilution people have while sitting in India..... I studied my Master of Engineering and Master of Engineering Management from University of Technology Sydney, which is ranked quite high in world, but I couldn't see even a single Aussie doing Master of Engineering studies
don't compare to Aussie , you know whats their ancestors are.
 

s002wjh

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 9, 2009
Messages
1,271
Likes
155
Country flag
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

chinas education are bit too stiff, seem like most high tech are invent in US/west. all the R&D in US dod/doe etc are american, and no one can say US don't have high tech/quality equipments. so while china is good at basic scentific theory/math, US/europe etc are still pulling ahead in advance scientific development.
 

LurkerBaba

Super Mod
Joined
Jul 2, 2010
Messages
7,882
Likes
8,125
Country flag
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

The article is satire
 

Daredevil

On Vacation!
Super Mod
Joined
Apr 5, 2009
Messages
11,615
Likes
5,772
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

My university is flooded with Chinese people, who are obviously pretty smart due to the years of hard work put in math/science, but can't form a single coherent sentence in English. Every year 60% of them fail the english exam required to graduate, which is at best a gr.9 level exam here.

Focusing so much on math and science has also made the Chinese fall decades behind in all arts disciplines, such as psychology, sociology, etc.
Exactly. I never understood how these Chinese students who cannot even form a coherent sentence in English pass TOEFL and GRE and get admission into top graduation schools in US. The most boring seminars almost invariably by Chinese (FOBs) because no one understands them.

FOB = Fresh-off the Boat
 

gokussj9

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2012
Messages
1,096
Likes
1,387
Country flag
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

Exactly. I never understood how these Chinese students who cannot even form a coherent sentence in English pass TOEFL and GRE and get admission into top graduation schools in US. The most boring seminars almost invariably by Chinese (FOBs) because no one understands them.

FOB = Fresh-off the Boat
Well GRE and TOEFL are just a part of the whole package. As long as you get a score above a certain level, you are safe. Most of the top universities go for you GPA and profile. More specifically, a bad score can hurt your chances but a good score does not guarantee anything.

PS: I had a really good score in GRE but still couldn't crack top 10. :yo: :cry:
 

W.G.Ewald

Defence Professionals/ DFI member of 2
Professional
Joined
Sep 28, 2011
Messages
14,139
Likes
8,594
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

Comparing 8 year olds with 14 and 18 year olds? Very rhetorical article. Can we get a bit more objective?
It's from The Onion, pmaitra. The Onion.:yuno:
 

p2prada

Senior Member
Joined
May 25, 2009
Messages
10,234
Likes
4,015
Re: Report: Chinese Third-Graders Falling Behind U.S. High School Stud

The chick in blue is haawt.
 

Super Flanker

Aviation and Defence Enthusiast
Senior Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2021
Messages
4,995
Likes
11,564
Country flag
I read the above article, like seriously? What the actual fuck? Why are we comparing Chinese 3rd Graders to High School students in the US on the basis of academics? So are Chinese Kids at the age of 13-14 going to be solving:
  • Complex mathematical integration, calculus, differentiation, Vectors, trigonometry etc..
  • Inorganic chemistry, organic chemistry, chemistry numerical problems etc...
  • Abstract physics such as about magnetism, forces, ray optics etc..?
In India, life is relaxed and chilled out till grade 10. Afterwards Grade 11 & 12 hit you in the face really hard. @rockdog @SexyChineseLady and other Chinese members, can you give us a rough idea idea about the science subjects and overall school curriculum in that of China because I think Asian countries have the hardest education curriculums such as that of India, Korea, Japan.
 

skywatcher

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2020
Messages
3,783
Likes
1,230
Country flag
I read the above article, like seriously? What the actual fuck? Why are we comparing Chinese 3rd Graders to High School students in the US on the basis of academics? So are Chinese Kids at the age of 13-14 going to be solving:
  • Complex mathematical integration, calculus, differentiation, Vectors, trigonometry etc..
  • Inorganic chemistry, organic chemistry, chemistry numerical problems etc...
  • Abstract physics such as about magnetism, forces, ray optics etc..?
In India, life is relaxed and chilled out till grade 10. Afterwards Grade 11 & 12 hit you in the face really hard. @rockdog @SexyChineseLady and other Chinese members, can you give us a rough idea idea about the science subjects and overall school curriculum in that of China because I think Asian countries have the hardest education curriculums such as that of India, Korea, Japan.
I once asked my 5 year old son: Show me what 3+5 is.
Son: I don't know what 3+5 is. What I only know is 3+5=5+3.
Me: Why?
Son: Because the integers under addition operation form an Abelian group.
Me: What? How come?!
Son: Get used to it.
i_f25.png


i_f25.png
 

skywatcher

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2020
Messages
3,783
Likes
1,230
Country flag
How to know if your kids have mathematical talent

Ask him 34 × 77=?

If he doesn't say what the solution is, but only tells you that the solution must be a bounded constant, then he is suitable for pure mathematics.

If he secretly takes out a calculator to calculate the result and only says the result is 2618 without giving the process, then he is suitable for engineering.

If he says apply Fast Fourier Transform to {4,3,0,0} {4,3,0,0 } {4,3,0,0 right } and {7,7,0,0} {7,7,0,0 } {7,7,0,0 right } to obtain {7,4-3i, 1,4+3i} {7,4-3 mathrm {i}, 1,4+3 mathrm {i} right } left {7,4-3 mathrm {i}, 1,4+3 mathrm {i} right } and {14,7-7i, 0,7+7i} left {14,7-7 mathrm {i}, 0,7+7 mathrm {i} right } left {14,7-7 mathrm {i}, Multiply 0,7+7 mathrm {i} right } and then reverse FFT to obtain {28,49,21,0} left {28,49,21,0 right } left {28,49,21,0 right }. Weighted addition yields 2618, and proves that using FFT algorithm to calculate large number multiplication has a complexity of O (nlog nlog log n) mathcal {O} (n log n) mathcal {O} (n log n log n) better than square complexity. Vertical multiplication of.
So congratulations, your kid has at least eight cores!
 

skywatcher

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2020
Messages
3,783
Likes
1,230
Country flag
I read the above article, like seriously? What the actual fuck? Why are we comparing Chinese 3rd Graders to High School students in the US on the basis of academics? So are Chinese Kids at the age of 13-14 going to be solving:
  • Complex mathematical integration, calculus, differentiation, Vectors, trigonometry etc..
  • Inorganic chemistry, organic chemistry, chemistry numerical problems etc...
  • Abstract physics such as about magnetism, forces, ray optics etc..
That can't be real. But I strongly recommend it!
There's no point of spending 10-12 years in elementary/middle school to learn some hundreds of or even thousands of year old shit. It's completely a waste of life.
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top