Pakistan cruise missiles pose key challenge to India

sayareakd

Mod
Joined
Feb 17, 2009
Messages
17,734
Likes
18,952
Country flag
With Pakistan arming itself with nuclear capable cruise missiles with stealth capabilities, a new dimension has been added to India's maritime security challenges, says leading Indian defence expert retired Commodore C. Uday Bhaskar.

"Taking a leaf from China, Pakistan seems to be investing in cruise missiles," he said, referring to Pakistan's indigenously developed cruise missile Babur, which can carry both nuclear and conventional warheads.

"This has lowered the index of stability in the region," Bhaskar said at an Asia-Pacific security seminar on India's Maritime Security Challenges at the East-West Centre Tuesday.

But in dealing with issues ranging from low intensity conflict and piracy to major-power strategic contests, India's key challenges were resource constraints, ship building capabilities, maritime infrastructure and the changing geo-political environment, he said.

The rapidly changing strategic environment in South Asia and emergence of an "extended global common" posed another challenge, said Bhaskar, currently a distinguished fellow with the Society for Policy Studies and a visiting fellow at the National Maritime Foundation in New Delhi.

Over the next decade, the US, China and India will form a critical strategic triangle and their individual relationships with the ASEAN, Iran and Pakistan will have significant regional and global implications, he said.

Given its distinctive geography and the recent shift of global maritime focus from the Atlantic-Pacific combine to the Indo-Pacific continuum, the importance of the Indian Ocean Region in India's national security calculus has greatly increased in the post-Cold War/post 9-11 era, Bhaskar said.

Yet the Indian Navy mandated to address this wide spectrum security domain received about a sixth of an overall defence budget of less than $40 billion in fiscal 2012-13, he said.

He noted that within the Indian military matrix, the navy was referred to as the "Cinderella service".

India's ship building capabilities too were "not really flattering", blighted as they were by time and cost overruns, Bhaskar said.

He listed the ability to build credibly fight capable ships as another key challenge.

The country's maritime infrastructure too was "less than rudimentary", he said. He added that that in terms of ports, India's top port Mumbai was listed at the 30th spot in the world.

However, Bhaskar said there was a growing awareness at the national level that over the next two decades India's future aspirations and anxieties will be increasingly shaped by its ability to address the challenges and opportunities of the maritime domain.

‘Pakistan cruise missiles pose key challenge to India’ | idrw.org
 

sayareakd

Mod
Joined
Feb 17, 2009
Messages
17,734
Likes
18,952
Country flag
We have all the tech to develop cruise missile defence as per this pic



Aerostat radar (Indian made and Israeli made are already available)




AWACs (Israeli is available and DRDO is under development)



MFCR



In addition to that we need space base assets to give info about launch of cruise missile from land from aircraft.
 

farhan_9909

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
5,895
Likes
497
With Pakistan arming itself with nuclear capable cruise missiles with stealth capabilities, a new dimension has been added to India's maritime security challenges, says leading Indian defence expert retired Commodore C. Uday Bhaskar.

"Taking a leaf from China, Pakistan seems to be investing in cruise missiles," he said, referring to Pakistan's indigenously developed cruise missile Babur, which can carry both nuclear and conventional warheads.


"This has lowered the index of stability in the region," Bhaskar said at an Asia-Pacific security seminar on India's Maritime Security Challenges at the East-West Centre Tuesday.

But in dealing with issues ranging from low intensity conflict and piracy to major-power strategic contests, India's key challenges were resource constraints, ship building capabilities, maritime infrastructure and the changing geo-political environment, he said.

The rapidly changing strategic environment in South Asia and emergence of an "extended global common" posed another challenge, said Bhaskar, currently a distinguished fellow with the Society for Policy Studies and a visiting fellow at the National Maritime Foundation in New Delhi.

Over the next decade, the US, China and India will form a critical strategic triangle and their individual relationships with the ASEAN, Iran and Pakistan will have significant regional and global implications, he said.

Given its distinctive geography and the recent shift of global maritime focus from the Atlantic-Pacific combine to the Indo-Pacific continuum, the importance of the Indian Ocean Region in India's national security calculus has greatly increased in the post-Cold War/post 9-11 era, Bhaskar said.

Yet the Indian Navy mandated to address this wide spectrum security domain received about a sixth of an overall defence budget of less than $40 billion in fiscal 2012-13, he said.

He noted that within the Indian military matrix, the navy was referred to as the "Cinderella service".

India's ship building capabilities too were "not really flattering", blighted as they were by time and cost overruns, Bhaskar said.

He listed the ability to build credibly fight capable ships as another key challenge.

The country's maritime infrastructure too was "less than rudimentary", he said. He added that that in terms of ports, India's top port Mumbai was listed at the 30th spot in the world.

However, Bhaskar said there was a growing awareness at the national level that over the next two decades India's future aspirations and anxieties will be increasingly shaped by its ability to address the challenges and opportunities of the maritime domain.

'Pakistan cruise missiles pose key challenge to India' | idrw.org
 

pmaitra

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2009
Messages
33,262
Likes
19,594
How many cruise missiles does Pakistan have? If India and Pakistan get into a cruise missile race, Pakistan will be bankrupt in to time, and will be in self-collapse mode, without any invasion from outside.

Needless to say, cruise missiles need to be accurate, and thus they are expensive. If they are not accurate, their only utility would be to carry nuclear warheads. If they are used in that role, Pakistan will resemble the Indus Valley Civilization.
 

farhan_9909

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
5,895
Likes
497
How many cruise missiles does Pakistan have? If India and Pakistan get into a cruise missile race, Pakistan will be bankrupt in to time, and will be in self-collapse mode, without any invasion from outside.

Needless to say, cruise missiles need to be accurate, and thus they are expensive. If they are not accurate, their only utility would be to carry nuclear warheads. If they are used in that role, Pakistan will resemble the Indus Valley Civilization.
well india at the moment doesnt has any credible cruise missile that can be used to target land targets.

Brahmos is more of an anti ship cruise missile like cm-400akg but with very less only 2.5mach speed.
 

pmaitra

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2009
Messages
33,262
Likes
19,594
well india at the moment doesnt has any credible cruise missile that can be used to target land targets.

Brahmos is more of an anti ship cruise missile like cm-400akg but with very less only 2.5mach speed.
Ok, but I would still like to know, how many cruise missiles does Pakistan have, that it plans to use as cruise missiles, and not nuke delivery vehicles.
 

farhan_9909

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
5,895
Likes
497
Ok, but I would still like to know, how many cruise missiles does Pakistan have, that it plans to use as cruise missiles, and not nuke delivery vehicles.
types

Babur and Raa'd for land targets

C-802/03/harpoon/exocet and cm 400akg for antiship

numbers?dont know
 

Bhadra

Professional
Joined
Jul 11, 2011
Messages
11,991
Likes
23,758
Country flag
types

Babur and Raa'd for land targets

C-802/03/harpoon/exocet and cm 400akg for antiship

numbers?dont know
India has an open policy of not attacking Pakistan. So what use are these missiles for Pakistan unless Pakistan wants to attack India ?

Pakistan can not attack Iran, Saudi Arabia or China or USA?

Why have missiles ??

India needs those for China as China has never said they will not attack India !
 

farhan_9909

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
5,895
Likes
497
India has an open policy of not attacking Pakistan. So what use are these missiles for Pakistan unless Pakistan wants to attack India ?

Pakistan can not attack Iran, Saudi Arabia or China or USA?

Why have missiles ??

India needs those for China as China has never said they will not attack India !
we never said cruise missile are to attack india
 

sayareakd

Mod
Joined
Feb 17, 2009
Messages
17,734
Likes
18,952
Country flag
well india at the moment doesnt has any credible cruise missile that can be used to target land targets.

Brahmos is more of an anti ship cruise missile like cm-400akg but with very less only 2.5mach speed.
Brahmos anti ship is more difficult since the target is always on the move, plus ship sometimes have build in anti cruise missile defence. While land targets are stationary. Brahmos I land version accuracy has been shown in the video, Brahmos II version can taken out target from cluster of buildings or use of reflectors by enemy, Brahmos III has steep dive to be used on the other side of mountains which is on the shadow part to get natural defence against enemy attack, cant show you the pic, but it is so effective that IA has loved it.
 

DivineHeretic

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2013
Messages
1,153
Likes
1,897
Country flag


This picture is flawed, The AAD is designed as medium altitude BM interceptor, and not designed for use against a CM. Its speed of Mach 5 makes it impossible to manuevre and target a Cruise missile. Not to mention that CMs tend to have variable flight path to avoid interception by SAMs/AAMs.

In any case even if it could be used, it would be an overkill.
 

Bhadra

Professional
Joined
Jul 11, 2011
Messages
11,991
Likes
23,758
Country flag
we never said cruise missile are to attack india
But I asserted that Pakistan can not attack any other country with cruise missiles but India.

Indian cruise missiles are for China not Pakistan.

India will not attack Pakistani Indians.
 

sayareakd

Mod
Joined
Feb 17, 2009
Messages
17,734
Likes
18,952
Country flag


This picture is flawed, The AAD is designed as medium altitude BM interceptor, and not designed for use against a CM. Its speed of Mach 5 makes it impossible to manuevre and target a Cruise missile. Not to mention that CMs tend to have variable flight path to avoid interception by SAMs/AAMs.

In any case even if it could be used, it would be an overkill.
yeah it is overkill, but they said it can be used for Cruise missiles. but it is highly maneuvering missile.

Even Akash can intercept cruise missiles



Hell even AAA can do the job if you can place the AAA near the target.
 

DivineHeretic

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2013
Messages
1,153
Likes
1,897
Country flag
How many cruise missiles does Pakistan have? If India and Pakistan get into a cruise missile race, Pakistan will be bankrupt in to time, and will be in self-collapse mode, without any invasion from outside.

Needless to say, cruise missiles need to be accurate, and thus they are expensive. If they are not accurate, their only utility would be to carry nuclear warheads. If they are used in that role, Pakistan will resemble the Indus Valley Civilization.
Just to add to that.

The Cruise missiles, especially the subsonic ones depend on avoiding detection to successfully target a site. Also the range of a CM is very much dependent on altitude.
For all the talk of terrain hugging characteristics, a CM only goes into this mode when near the target to achieve max range. From launch to mid course they fly at high altitude.

So long as they use they target the northern sites, that too launching from their northern zones i.e. In J&K, they have a fairly good possibility of hitting the target, with mountain ranges creating radar blind spots.
If they attempt to launch missiles from the lower reaches, targetting Delhi/Jaipur/Ambala/Mumbai etc, the LRTR and the AWACS network would pick up the missile right after launch, even if they launch it from Balochistan. Hell the LRTR/Swodrfish would pick up a Iranian missile test inside Iran. As such the IA/IAF ADC would get as much as 30-45 mins window to intercept the CM, and with the LR-SAM or even the BVR AAM will be able to take it down inside Pak airspace.

Talk about your nukes falling in your own house. This is the reason why CMs are not thought of as a reliable Nuclear delivery system. But then we are talking about Pak, who are the only ones to revive the battlefield nuke concept.
 

sayareakd

Mod
Joined
Feb 17, 2009
Messages
17,734
Likes
18,952
Country flag
The Arudhra radar is India's first self developed AESA 3D surveillance radar with multifunction capacity in the medium power capability range. It is a major achievement for the LRDE, along with DRDO, to have managed to develop such crucial 3D long range radars on its own. The Arudra radar has a range of 300 kilometers, twice the range of the 3D Rohini radar (150 km). With advanced "electronic counter-counter measures", the new radar being inducted will be integrated into the IACCS (integrated air command and control system). The IACCS is a fully-automated network being established to integrate the wide array of military radars with each other as well as with civilian radars. The IAF has significantly improved its air defence capabilities by acquiring the IACCS and connecting all of its modern as well as legacy radars under one single grid. IAF has plans to establish ten IACCS centres to cover virtually the entire country, with quick transfer of data from different radars as well as ground stations of AWACS to one central place.
IAF Beefs up Network-Centric Operations, Installs New Radars along Gujarat

Airfroce has its own network centric operations, it has got data from all the civilian radars in real time, plus its own radar are fused into one giving clear real time picture.
 

DivineHeretic

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2013
Messages
1,153
Likes
1,897
Country flag
yeah it is overkill, but they said it can be used for Cruise missiles. but it is highly maneuvering missile.

Even Akash can intercept cruise missiles



Hell even AAA can do the job if you can place the AAA near the target.
Yup, any SAM or even AAM can be used to bring down a CM once it is detected. The biggest challenge is the detection. I think the loudmouth DRDO chief meant that a comprehensive radar network is being developed to detect a CM, with integrated SAMs to bring it down. Even Akash can be used for this role, and even the Sypder system, but they need to be fully integrated into a single enity for seamless defence.


Cant say if AAD( basically a modified BM, that too a fairly heavy missile) can outmanuevre a CM, especially when it is travelling @ 5-7 times the speed of sound. The S-300 most certainly can, but neither are economic enough to be used on a CM.
 

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top