Pak politicians want to resolve Kashmir — military won't allow this

[Ray]

Pak politicians want to resolve Kashmir — military won't allow this: Arif Jamal

Arif Jamal is a Pakistani journalist and South Asia expert based in America. His first book Shadow War analysed the Pakistan army's operations in Kashmir. Having researched the Lashkar-e-Taiba for his new book Call for Transnational Jihad, Jamal spoke with Aarti Tikoo Singh about challenges Pakistani politicians face in battling terror groups, dynamics between Nawaz Sharif and Narendra Modi, his view of the Pakistani military — and why he's a harsh critic of Imran Khan:


After Nawaz Sharif became Pakistan's PM, there were hopes for stability. Yet, Pakistan's making news for terror strikes, blasphemy cases, persecuting journalists, etc — why?
"Well, i think Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif sincerely wants to create peace in Pakistan. However, he cannot achieve this goal without reining in the Pakistani military. While Islamist proteges of the Pakistani military kill their opponents, the military itself is involved in the indiscriminate murders of nationalists and secularists in Balochistan and Sindh as well as of journalists.

The Sharif government is helpless before the military. On the one hand, the Pakistani military has unleashed Islamist organisations like the Jamat-ud-Dawa (JuD) to turn Baloch and Sindhi nationalists and secularists into jihadists. On the other hand, they kidnap, tor-ture and kill those they consider incorrigible.

Recently, the Pakistani military unleashed forces against the Geo group — one of the allegations against the group is that Geo revealed the Pakistani iden-tity of Ajmal Kasab, one of the 10 terrorists arrested during the November 2008 Mumbai attacks.



Despite these strains, the first meeting between PM Sharif and India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi has been termed positive — can the two make real progress on tough topics like Kashmir?
I think PM Sharif has a sincere desire for peace with India and inside Pakistan — he understands this is the best thing that can happen to Pakistan. There is a tremendous desire among Pakistani politicians to resolve Kashmir and other conflicts with India — Pakistani politicians understand that conflicts with India are bad for both Pakistan's democracy and economy.

However, the Pakistani military plays a disproportionate role in politics. The Pakistani military will never allow friendly relations with India because that means closing the jihad factory.

Now, i hope i'm proved wrong but it seems the Pakistani military would be eventually defeated by Muslim extremists. If that happens, it will spell disaster.



Given the limitations on Pakistani politicians, why are you such a harsh critic of Imran Khan and his party Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf (PTI)? Isn't this a strong political alter-native?

I am a harsh critic of Imran Khan for several reasons including how he supports introducing Islamic punishments in Pakistan — but does not want us to talk about his life.

Imran Khan can also do anything for personal or political gains. Imran Khan was the only Pakistani politician who criticised a ban on the JuD in 2008 in the wake of the Mumbai attacks. He's playing into the hands of the Pakistani military and jihadists just to be able to come to power — no wonder Imran Khan and Hafiz Saeed are leading the military's campaign against the Geo group.

It may come as a surprise that the political vocabulary, such as national ghariat and hameeyat, that Imran uses were terms introduced by Hafiz Saeed in the early 1990s — the PTI is soft Taliban.

Pak politicians want to resolve Kashmir — military won't allow this: Arif Jamal - The Times of India

*****************************************************

The manipulative power of the Army speaks out loud and clear.

Indeed, while other countries have an Army, in Pakistan, the Army has a country.

The duplicitous attitude of Imran Khan is so evident.

The man is a snake in the grass.

 

[maomao]

Re: Pak politicians want to resolve Kashmir — military won't allow thi

Sir, IK is an apple of NDTV and Jholachaps eye in India!! What does that suggest?

 

[abhi_the _gr8_maratha]

Re: Pak politicians want to resolve Kashmir — military won't allow thi

may be pakistani members will shed more light on this , @Neo your military!

 

[hit&run]

Re: Pak politicians want to resolve Kashmir — military won't allow thi

Peace with Pakistan is a gone case.

It is waste of time and resources for any government in India to contemplate it. If Indians are not ready to be at war with Pakistan at all the time on different fronts including geographical fronts, then we seriously need to educate ourselves.

The goodwill gestures with Pakistan and CBM that we witness, being done by different governments in power, should be seen as a realpolitik to keep geo-political steering of things at ease, not as a hope of peace deal striking between both.

Having said that I wouldn't mind Pakistani PM being summoned at short notice and treated like a school boy by PM of heavy weight India and told behind doors of Hyderabad house to behave or will be fixed.

 

[Glint]

Re: Pak politicians want to resolve Kashmir — military won't allow thi

may be pakistani members will shed more light on this , @Neo your military!

Nope, Neo can't shed more light on this situation either.

The article just proves that freedom is just another illusion in Pakistan which is based on pure hatred for India.

If they resolve Kashmir issue they won't have any reason to control the country and proper democracy would take place. People would start asking questions which would focus on development not India and the military cannot afford that can it.

 

[thakur_ritesh]

Re: Pak politicians want to resolve Kashmir — military won't allow thi

As they say, let us wake up and smell the coffee if we haven't yet!

When the politicians are in command, then the Army won't allow a resolution. When a dictator wants to resolve, the hardline factions within the Army won't allow a resolution. When a hardliner general is in command then the Jihadi elements won't allow a resolution, and just in case the Jihadi elements were to govern Pakistan, which they haven't yet, one wonders what their excuse will be then.

Moral of the story, like a dog who tries to catch his tail, and keeps going in circles, we are no different searching for that illusionary peace, and we haven't yet understood that none of them want peace, there exists an industry of terrorism that none of them will give up on.

 

[Virendra]

Re: Pak politicians want to resolve Kashmir — military won't allow thi

Pak politicians want to resolve Kashmir — military won't allow this

What a convenient alibi !!
There are far too many people in Pakistan who've forgotten how else to live and how else to identify themselves.

 

[Eastman]

Re: Pak politicians want to resolve Kashmir — military won't allow thi

From the Indian POV peace effort/resolving issue with Pakistan is a gone case, enuff tried and no more expectation unless we see some considerable effort from the other side