Labour shortage for India Inc projects - CEOs point fingers at MNREGA

SLASH

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 5, 2011
Messages
1,156
Likes
459
Re: Labour shortage for India Inc projects - CEOs point fingers at MNR

What? Why would that make everyone happy?
In India, it is generally men in the household who go out of their villages to look for work in industrial areas. Women stay in the village and look after their kids. If MNREGA is restricted to women employment guarantee than it will be a good both the village households as well as the industry.
 

Ray

The Chairman
Professional
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
Messages
43,132
Likes
23,835
Re: Labour shortage for India Inc projects - CEOs point fingers at MNR

It is time to take stock and see what can be done.

Many schemes have been launched that are interrelated and dependent.

Unless each scheme is activated in its totality, concurrent launching will only cause confusion, heartburn and total misuse with the unscrupulous making a killing!

Unless the latter is the aim to refurbish the election coffers, the elections being around the corner!
 

tramp

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2009
Messages
1,464
Likes
580
Re: Labour shortage for India Inc projects - CEOs point fingers at MNR

It is time to take stock and see what can be done.

Many schemes have been launched that are interrelated and dependent.

Unless each scheme is activated in its totality, concurrent launching will only cause confusion, heartburn and total misuse with the unscrupulous making a killing!

Unless the latter is the aim to refurbish the election coffers, the elections being around the corner!
You do have a point there. Close monitoring with sufficient checks and balances are necessary and the failure to build proper and effective monitoring institutions may be the reason why many good programmes have foundered.
 

t_co

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2012
Messages
2,538
Likes
709
Re: Labour shortage for India Inc projects - CEOs point fingers at MNR

In India, it is generally men in the household who go out of their villages to look for work in industrial areas. Women stay in the village and look after their kids. If MNREGA is restricted to women employment guarantee than it will be a good both the village households as well as the industry.
Not sure why that necessitates a restriction; if men already prefer to go elsewhere for work, why do we need to bar them from staying in their home villages?
 

SLASH

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 5, 2011
Messages
1,156
Likes
459
Re: Labour shortage for India Inc projects - CEOs point fingers at MNR

Not sure why that necessitates a restriction; if men already prefer to go elsewhere for work, why do we need to bar them from staying in their home villages?
You are thinking of a world where everyone is ambitious and want to do something with their lives. Let me tell you many of these village folks would be happy to survive on subsistence. More doles given to them lazier they will get. He can see that even in many welfare states in the EU where the unemployment rate is so high. While economic downturn in one good reason for their unemployment, government welfare aid is also responsible.
 

AVERAGE INDIAN

EXORCIST
Senior Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2012
Messages
3,326
Likes
5,408
Country flag
Re: Labour shortage for India Inc projects - CEOs point fingers at MNR

As a fast growing developing economy, India needs skilled architects, plumbers and masons among others to contribute to the country's growth. However, the Indian construction industry complains of a shortage of skilled workers which is likely to worsen if more workers are not made employable. Towards this end, multiple skill development initiatives have been launched in the country but it appears that these are unable to create avenues for casual workers and are not of the scale needed. This is problematic because it can stall the country's growth plans and development goals. This paper aimed to explain why India faces a shortage of skilled workers despite multiple ongoing skill building initiatives. The main reason behind the lack of a sufficient number of skilled workers is the absence of training for casual workers, who dominate the Indian workforce. Lack of inclusiveness in the current vocational training system and poor coordination between government levels have resulted in the exclusion of casual workers from the ongoing vocational training initiatives. India has adopted an education-linked Western model of vocational training without first putting in place compulsory education policies. Rigid entry requirements that mandate secondary education as a pre-requisite, and long course durations, are mismatched with the profile of casual workers.
 

RedDragon

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2011
Messages
536
Likes
69
Re: Labour shortage for India Inc projects - CEOs point fingers at MNR

You are thinking of a world where everyone is ambitious and want to do something with their lives. Let me tell you many of these village folks would be happy to survive on subsistence. More doles given to them lazier they will get. He can see that even in many welfare states in the EU where the unemployment rate is so high. While economic downturn in one good reason for their unemployment, government welfare aid is also responsible.
" Let me tell you many of these village folks would be happy to survive on subsistence." They even don't have the ambitious to send their children to University or buy their son a appartment for marriage? Most Chinese parents will prepare these things or at least tried their best to prepare these things for their children, no matter how poor they are.
 

SLASH

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 5, 2011
Messages
1,156
Likes
459
Re: Labour shortage for India Inc projects - CEOs point fingers at MNR

" Let me tell you many of these village folks would be happy to survive on subsistence." They even don't have the ambitious to send their children to University or buy their son a appartment for marriage? Most Chinese parents will prepare these things or at least tried their best to prepare these things for their children, no matter how poor they are.
Let me also add that women do not marry men who do not have a house in China. In India people survive on quotas and subsidies.
 

RedDragon

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2011
Messages
536
Likes
69
Re: Labour shortage for India Inc projects - CEOs point fingers at MNR

Let me also add that women do not marry men who do not have a house in China. In India people survive on quotas and subsidies.
"Let me also add that women do not marry men who do not have a house in China."
No 100% true, because I know a lot of people who married without their own house. But it is true that a man don't have his own house will be difficult to find a wife.

"In India people survive on quotas and subsidies"
Do you think that is a good choice? I think ambition is good, if a person have ambition to change his life, he will think and work hard, when he change his life, he also create more value to the socity, this also changed his country. That's why so many migrate workers in China.
 

Tronic

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2009
Messages
1,915
Likes
1,282
Re: Labour shortage for India Inc projects - CEOs point fingers at MNR

Coming back to Punjab, where you claim there has been wage growth, can you please explain this report from last year? In Punjab, three farmers kill selves every two days

You seem to be completely cut off from reality.
Haven't visited in a while, so just saw this.

Farmers don't earn wages pmaitra. The ones who earn wages are the labour working in the farms, and those have been steadily going up. Hiring people for cheap is becoming more and more difficult as most poor people now prefer to work in factories. This means that farmers have to pay more to hire labour. Add a bad harvest into the mix; profit margins have diminished, while banks continue to hand out easy loans, eventually acquiring the land from the smaller farmers. It's no surprise the smaller farmers are committing suicide.

So yes technically, the wages have gone up, and that has added to the farmer's woes, as it is usually the farmers who pay the wages, not receive them.
 

pmaitra

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2009
Messages
33,262
Likes
19,594
Re: Labour shortage for India Inc projects - CEOs point fingers at MNR

Haven't visited in a while, so just saw this.

Farmers don't earn wages pmaitra. The ones who earn wages are the labour working in the farms, and those have been steadily going up. Hiring people for cheap is becoming more and more difficult as most poor people now prefer to work in factories. This means that farmers have to pay more to hire labour. Add a bad harvest into the mix; profit margins have diminished, while banks continue to hand out easy loans, eventually acquiring the land from the smaller farmers. It's no surprise the smaller farmers are committing suicide.

So yes technically, the wages have gone up, and that has added to the farmer's woes, as it is usually the farmers who pay the wages, not receive them.
Thanks for the response.

Yes, what I intended to mean is that the people who are actually working in the fields. I think the term farmer can mean different things depending upon the context. So basically what is happening is that smaller farmers can easily go into excessive debt as a result of poor harvest, and eventually lose their land.

Makes sense.
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top