India shouldn't worry about Re fall: Mr Yen

Mad Indian

Proud Bigot
Senior Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2012
Messages
12,835
Likes
7,762
Country flag
India shouldn’t worry about Re fall: Mr Yen - The Times of India

MUMBAI: Eisuke Sakakibara, a former Japanese minister of finance and economist, known as 'Mr Yen' because of his ability to move currency markets during the '90s, advises the Indian government to take advantage of the falling rupee by boosting exports and not to fret about it. The currency depreciation is a worldwide phenomenon caused by "simultaneous recession" in global economy, he tells TOI on a visit after becoming a board member at investment bank Avendus Capital.


You are here in the midst of what some people call an Indian currency crisis. What are your views on rupee's steepest fall ever in recent months?

What is happening right now is repatriation. Funds are now returning from emerging economies to US because of simultaneous recession worldwide. There's a flow from equities to bonds. It's a worldwide phenomenon triggered by the euro crisis. India is running a current account deficit and capital inflows supported the currency so far. So as long as capital continues to flow out, this depreciation will continue. How long...is uncertain. If I were the Indian government, I would tell the Indian people, 'Don't worry because it is to do with repatriation and not because of any weakness in the Indian economy' and try to take advantage of the situation by increasing exports.


Do you think the euro will survive as a single currency? How do you see the future of the Eurozone?

Germany and France forged European integration in the post-War era. But it's beginning to disintegrate because of the Greek crisis and the
US crisis. I think the problem is structure. The Greek crisis has been temporarily suspended but it's spreading to Spain and perhaps Italy. So the integration is at risk and this is a structural problem and I don't see any immediate way out of the European crisis. The crisis will continue and eventually hit European banks. Because bonds of south European countries are plummeting, the balance sheet of banks are deteriorating. I think it is a possibility that some French, German or Italian banks may have a problem and the fiscal crisis may eventually become a financial crisis. I would not be surprised if a major financial institution in Europe goes bankrupt.


A lot has been said about Japan's debt that's running at about 200% of its GDP...

It's true that debt is high but Japan is not in a financial crisis. While the debt is 180% of the GDP, the accumulated assets of the Japanese households is almost 240% of the GDP, which more than covers up the debt. And most of that debt is owned by Japanese
institutions unlike in the
case of US, where more than 70% of its debts are in the hands of foreigners.


There's rising interest of Japanese corporates in India. How do you see the Indo-Japanese deal corridor shaping up?

Yen has been strong and I see it that way for a while, giving the Japanese companies enough comfort to pursue international acquisitions. They have gone into China in a big way, but are now talking about China Plus One strategy. That's bringing lot of focus on the Indian market where they see better longer-term growth. India's younger population will sustain longer growth, possibly even 20 or 30 years after China peaks off. Japanese conglomerates, aided by low cost of capital, normally look at the long horizon.

________________________________________________________

Interesting Article :hmm:
 

Payeng

Daku Mongol Singh
Senior Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2009
Messages
2,522
Likes
777
Export increase and import decrease sounds good but in reality acts otherwise.
 

Ray

The Chairman
Professional
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
Messages
43,132
Likes
23,835
Make Hay while the Sun Shines?

But the Hay must be dry so as to be able to sell!
 

Yusuf

GUARDIAN
Super Mod
Joined
Mar 24, 2009
Messages
24,324
Likes
11,757
Country flag
there has be worthwhile exports.. we cannot just raw material.
 

SLASH

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 5, 2011
Messages
1,156
Likes
459
Short term devaluation of rupee will not help. Unless it is the government policy to keep the currency at this level it is too risky to get into export contracts. It is predicted that by August everything should come back to normal. Lets see
 

no smoking

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
5,015
Likes
2,311
Country flag
Short term devaluation of rupee will not help. Unless it is the government policy to keep the currency at this level it is too risky to get into export contracts. It is predicted that by August everything should come back to normal. Lets see
Generally, devaluation could benefit you in half year. beyond that date, the increase cost of your importation would offset your benefit in exportation. This devaluation of indian currency is not gov policy. It is simply the market response to india accumulated trading deficit. So, unless india can increase its exportation significantly or bring the foreign money inflow to a higher level, the things will become worse.
 

thakur_ritesh

Ambassador
Joined
Feb 19, 2009
Messages
4,435
Likes
1,733
My sense is, Rs. has possibly seen the lows it had to, at least for now, and Rs. should start to appreciate from now on.

More policy measures are on the way, and Kaushik Basu is again looking a little upbeat, and he is again making reference to certain key reforms, provided the political will on part of the coalition is there, the key word again remains, coalition.

Wait for the change to set in from the second half of the fiscal (Oct onwards, that is what he is hinting at).

If indeed it is so, Rs.50 to a dollar should be more like it that we should sustain in times to come, provided manufacturing is given the much needed push.

Generally, devaluation could benefit you in half year. beyond that date, the increase cost of your importation would offset your benefit in exportation. This devaluation of indian currency is not gov policy. It is simply the market response to india accumulated trading deficit. So, unless india can increase its exportation significantly or bring the foreign money inflow to a higher level, the things will become worse.
There is one thing which is doing good, the exports. The growth is hovering around 20% or so, and again they are expecting a similar growth, so this hasn't been a disappointing area. More important is our manufacturing needs to be well taken care of, exports will do well.
 

sob

Mod
Joined
May 4, 2009
Messages
6,425
Likes
3,805
Country flag
MMS taking over the reins of the Finanace Ministry and has made all the right noises to sooth the nerves.

The result is there for all to see BSE Sensex is nearly 400 points up , 1US$= Rs. 55.95

The sheer cussedness of Pranab Da and the lack of faith in him was a big drag on the Indian economy. due to global scenario, Crude and Gold prices are tumbling down and this bodes well for India, as these two account for a large chunk of our import bill. This will also reduce the pressure on Rs.

MMS has nothing to loose. The Indian economy needs a roadmap to work on and not impediments like the former finance minister and the earlier Environment Minister, Jairam Ramesh.
 

Yusuf

GUARDIAN
Super Mod
Joined
Mar 24, 2009
Messages
24,324
Likes
11,757
Country flag
Fvcking fvcking bitch of a dollar. Rupee has gone up by 1.50 and I have made a total of $50,000 transfers after waiting for it to drop and it only went higher. Damn the fvcking shit.
 

thakur_ritesh

Ambassador
Joined
Feb 19, 2009
Messages
4,435
Likes
1,733
Fvcking fvcking bitch of a dollar. Rupee has gone up by 1.50 and I have made a total of $50,000 transfers after waiting for it to drop and it only went higher. Damn the fvcking shit.
WIth Pranab Mukherjee on his way out, you should have waited a little longer!
 

Yusuf

GUARDIAN
Super Mod
Joined
Mar 24, 2009
Messages
24,324
Likes
11,757
Country flag
WIth Pranab Mukherjee on his way out, you should have waited a little longer!
I waited till as long as I could. Then I had to as the shipment was getting delayed too long. Actually made a bigger loss. I ended up paying 2lacs as penalty for not taking delivery at port.

Total loss overall.
 

skumar7777

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2011
Messages
416
Likes
309
I waited till as long as I could. Then I had to as the shipment was getting delayed too long. Actually made a bigger loss. I ended up paying 2lacs as penalty for not taking delivery at port.

Total loss overall.
Hope you will make up for it in profit on your shipments.

If the government and the RBI clearly outline how the arrangement of oil importers getting minimum 50% of foreign currency from SBI or other banks will function, it will take some demand off the forex market. Some announcements of foreign investment coming in (Walmart and Coco Cola) have also helped.

A diesel price hike will help some more though it will also pinch pockets.

Overall, the net exporters of the world are awash with dollars and as they slowly begin buying tangibles in the net importers, the value of the dollar has to fall. Also arrangements between trading nations to use their own currencies, bypassing the dollar, should help reduce demand for the dollar.
 

no smoking

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
5,015
Likes
2,311
Country flag
There is one thing which is doing good, the exports. The growth is hovering around 20% or so, and again they are expecting a similar growth, so this hasn't been a disappointing area. More important is our manufacturing needs to be well taken care of, exports will do well.
Yes, it will help your manufacturing in certain period. But please keep that in mind: india is a country with huge trade deficit! That means your importation will be punched heavily due to the increase of cost! Certainly, after a certain period, this cost growth will pass to your manufacturing!
 

thakur_ritesh

Ambassador
Joined
Feb 19, 2009
Messages
4,435
Likes
1,733
Yes, it will help your manufacturing in certain period. But please keep that in mind: india is a country with huge trade deficit! That means your importation will be punched heavily due to the increase of cost! Certainly, after a certain period, this cost growth will pass to your manufacturing!
Absolutely.

What a significant push to manufacturing will also do is off-set the imports of finished goods to quite an extent, and it gets all the more important because with a bulging middle-class, and increase in their aspirations, its better most of such aspirations get fed to from within.

A good amount of our import bill is due to petroleum products, important for the country is to look for alternatives to our energy needs wherever possible. Then address the trade imbalance with which ever country we have.

Difficult, not easy, but the focus ought to be there of our polity. The good thing that has happened is, our prime minister has taken over the finance ministry, and things for a change are looking up. He still has 2 years to do all that.
 

afako

Hindufying India
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2010
Messages
3,721
Likes
21,192
Country flag
Infact the Stupid Government should see that the Rupee stays below 60 INR. The recent Commitments by IKEA($1.5Billion), Coco-Cola($5 Billion) is because of the Rupee Depreciation. Rupee did not see a quick Fix like last July.

This is the best thing to happen to the country in a Long Long Time. Exports become Competitive. We have invested a Trillion Dollar in Infrastructure in the Last 10 Years. So We do have a Decent Base to Support Manufacturing. The time is right.

Executives dealing with the projects of multinational carmakers say that over 100,000 sedans and SUVs manufactured in India are slated for export over the next 12 months. The depreciating rupee, which ended at a record low on Friday, is only likely to accelerate such plans.
After small cars, global auto companies like Nissan and Toyota start exporting sedans & SUVs from India - Economic Times

Nissan to make India export hub - Economic Times
 

thakur_ritesh

Ambassador
Joined
Feb 19, 2009
Messages
4,435
Likes
1,733
no smoking,

Something very interesting I found.

In fiscal 07-08 (April'07-March'08) India's exports were to the tune of 123b usd (Exports 2007 country ranks)

Last fiscal, '11-'12, the exports grew to 303b usd

I take this as an example because in 2007-08 the Rs. had appreciated to Rs.39 to a dollar (Monthly Exchange Rate Average (Indian Rupee, American Dollar) 2007 - x-rates), and then it touched 51-52 in '09. So the growth has happened irrespective of the fluctuations.

Infact, back in '07 India was ranked 29th in terms of exports, and now India is ranked 19th.

Another interesting observation, during the said period (2007-11), India's exports have grown 150%, which is the highest for any country ranked top 30 exporting countries in 2007, and then comes Australia and the PRC.

Now, I am not trying to draw any parallels here, since what the PRC exports in 2 months we do it in a fiscal, also the base effect, which is very low in our case, but the idea is to bring to focus that Indian exports have done well without a focused manufacturing policy and with a seriously fluctuating currency.

I am one of those who do believe, come 2020 and India's exports should definitely touch a trillion dollars, and then India will be considered in the big league of exporting countries. Here, India's exports in 2004 were at 57b usd (http://www.photius.com/rankings/economy/exports_2004_0.html), and it has multiplied by more than 5 times since, and from now till 2020, we have similar time line as we had since 2004.
 

no smoking

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
5,015
Likes
2,311
Country flag
Absolutely.

What a significant push to manufacturing will also do is off-set the imports of finished goods to quite an extent, and it gets all the more important because with a bulging middle-class, and increase in their aspirations, its better most of such aspirations get fed to from within.

A good amount of our import bill is due to petroleum products, important for the country is to look for alternatives to our energy needs wherever possible. Then address the trade imbalance with which ever country we have.

Difficult, not easy, but the focus ought to be there of our polity. The good thing that has happened is, our prime minister has taken over the finance ministry, and things for a change are looking up. He still has 2 years to do all that.
It is not difficult, it is damn hard. Building up a manufacutring base is a decades work. From 1980 to 1996, CCP leaders were haunted by the current account balance EVERYDAY until they finally start hundreds thousands sweatshops which they condemned since 1921. There is one saying in China: today's manufacturing is built on Chinese tear, blood and bodies! The question is: Is india society ready to face the great suffering resulted by this procedure.
 

no smoking

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
5,015
Likes
2,311
Country flag
no smoking,

Something very interesting I found.

In fiscal 07-08 (April'07-March'08) India's exports were to the tune of 123b usd (Exports 2007 country ranks)

Last fiscal, '11-'12, the exports grew to 303b usd

I take this as an example because in 2007-08 the Rs. had appreciated to Rs.39 to a dollar (Monthly Exchange Rate Average (Indian Rupee, American Dollar) 2007 - x-rates), and then it touched 51-52 in '09. So the growth has happened irrespective of the fluctuations.

Infact, back in '07 India was ranked 29th in terms of exports, and now India is ranked 19th.

Another interesting observation, during the said period (2007-11), India's exports have grown 150%, which is the highest for any country ranked top 30 exporting countries in 2007, and then comes Australia and the PRC.

Now, I am not trying to draw any parallels here, since what the PRC exports in 2 months we do it in a fiscal, also the base effect, which is very low in our case, but the idea is to bring to focus that Indian exports have done well without a focused manufacturing policy and with a seriously fluctuating currency.

I am one of those who do believe, come 2020 and India's exports should definitely touch a trillion dollars, and then India will be considered in the big league of exporting countries. Here, India's exports in 2004 were at 57b usd (Exports 2004 country rankings - Flags, Maps, Economy, Geography, Climate, Natural Resources, Current Issues, International Agreements, Population, Social Statistics, Political System), and it has multiplied by more than 5 times since, and from now till 2020, we have similar time line as we had since 2004.
I would rather say that india has done well in the easy part of the industrilization. You haven't touch the mine field yet!

Indeed, india's exportation growth is fast. But india's importation is growing even faster! So you have to focus on how to reduce your importation: finding alternative energy or building manufcaturing, either of them would take more than 10 years to complish. What is india going to do before that?
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top