India, China, Pakistan dialogue on Afghanistan?

Discussion in 'Foreign Relations' started by LETHALFORCE, Sep 10, 2012.


    LETHALFORCE Moderator Moderator

    Feb 16, 2009
    Likes Received:
    India, China, Pakistan dialogue on Afghanistan? - The Times of India

    NEW DELHI: With the prospect of regional rivalries intensifying over Afghanistan, China is thinking of proposing a trilateral dialogue among New Delhi, Beijing and Islamabad on Afghanistan, a tricky proposition given the rivalry between India and Pakistan in the Afghan theatre.

    "Many Chinese scholars have proposed the idea. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs of China is keen on this trilateral dialogue," Zhang Jiadong, assistant director of the Centre for American Studies in Fudan University and a well regarded Chinese expert on international affairs, told IANS here.

    With the 2014 drawdown of US-led international combat troops from Afghanistan in mind, China is pushing for greater regional cooperation to stabilize Afghanistan, an approach India has always supported.

    Zhang said although China's involvement in Afghanistan is now limited, it is planning to expand its diplomatic and economic footprint in the country.

    "We are going to become more proactive in Afghanistan. Some Chinese scholars are suggesting a bigger role for China in Afghanistan," Zhang, who is visiting India, said.

    Compared to India pledging $2 billion for multifarious reconstruction activities in Afghanistan ranging from building hospitals, roads and schools to the parliament building, China's involvement in Afghanistan has remained primarily economic. Chinese state-owned companies have invested in copper mines and struck a lucrative energy deal in Afghanistan. But with the growing stakes in the Afghan endgame, this is set to change.

    But what should gladden New Delhi is China's positive view of India's reconstruction activities in Afghanistan. "There is a difference of perception between China and Pakistan on this," said Zhang.

    China recognises India as a key player in shaping Afghanistan in 2014, said Shen Xiaochen of Lanzhou University. In the post-2014 scenario, Shen said, China is sceptical of continued international assistance for Afghanistan. He stressed that against this backdrop, there should be greater cooperation between India and China for the stability of the violence-torn country.

    Zhang, however, replied vaguely when asked how the dialogue among India, China and Pakistan will play out given the deep suspicion Islamabad has about New Delhi's multifarious activities in that country which the Pakistani military establishment tends to regard as its strategic depth.

    China's all-weather friendship with Pakistan and the incestuous military ties between the two countries is going to be another complicating factor if such a trilateral dialogue were to see the light of the day.

    The rivalry between India and Pakistan over influence in Afghanistan is well-known and it is going to only intensify in the wake of the phased withdrawal of US-led multinational ISAF forces bu 2014.

    India fears a Taliban takeover as it will mean the installation of a hostile regime in Kabul which will be remote-controlled by Pakistan's ISI-military establishment. China fears that a Taliban-ruled Afghanistan may give sanctuary to the separatist group, the East Turkestan Islamic Movement, led by ethnic Uighurs, and impinge on the stability of its border regions in Xinjiang.

    With Afghan stability in mind and its larger ambitions in the region, China, said Zhang, is trying to pursue a balancing act between its relations with India and Pakistan. "Economically, we have closer ties with Pakistan. Militarily, we are closer to Pakistan. But we want stronger relations with both the countries," he said.

    While the prospects of a trilateral among India, Pakistan and China on Afghanistan look remote and problematic for now, consultations between New Delhi and Beijing on Afghanistan-Pakistan issues have already started.

    "There are good prospects of cooperation between India and China on Afghanistan. The dialogue has already begun," Srikanth Kondapallui, a China expert at Jawaharlal Nehru University, told IANS.

    Besides the threat from Taliban-associated militant networks in the region, what promises to bring India and China closer on Afghanistan is a shared investment-driven approach towards stabilising the violence-torn country.

    New Delhi hosted a regional investors' conclave on Afghanistan in April which was also attended by some Chinese companies.
  3. thakur_ritesh

    thakur_ritesh Administrator Administrator

    Feb 19, 2009
    Likes Received:
    Land of the GODS - "Dev Bhomi".
    Unlikely that such a dialogue will happen, even in a distant future.

    Pakistan will never be ready to share any space with us in Afghanistan, not even an inch, no such dialogue will be entertained by them. Though, India has been trying to court the Pakistanis with economics but nothing significant is going to yield out of it. Let us leave the Pakistani angle here for the moment.

    Intriguing is the fact that such a proposal is being pushed by the Chinese, and not by the Indians, though not through the official channels. Such a move should give us some sense on how far India and China have gone on their negotiations on Afghanistan, and the common interests there, though however limited those might remain.

    We should continue our dialogue on Afghanistan with them, for you never know what good might come, but at the same time keep everyone from the US to Russia to Iran engaged. Fact remains, all these countries, the US, the PRC, Russia, Iran, Turkey, CAR will have a role to play, and it remains in our best interest that we keep talking to all and keep working around a common solution based on those interests.

Share This Page