An internal audit of the Army conducted in 2011 by the Controller of Defence Accounts has raised questions about the quantity and quality of food being fed to the men. The audit says normal military diet could be three times more than what is recommended by the ICMR. The Army has dismissed the findings.
The point that all categories need not have the same scale of rations.
The different arms and services are below.
Armoured Corps
Artillery
Army Air Defence
Army Aviation
Engineers
Corps of Signals
Mech Infantry
Infantry
Army Service Corps
Army Medical Corps
Army Dental Corps
Army Ordnance Corps
Corps of EME
Remount And Veterinary Corps
Army Education Corps
Corps of Military Police
Pioneer Corps
Army Postal Service
Territorial Army
Defence Security Corps
It maybe mentioned that they perform different tasks with different physical levels in their work environment. And each have a different mental level in work environment and both factors have different levels of stress. This is further different, even if from the same arms or services because the issues mentioned are different for personnel from these same arms and services working under different climatic zones and different elevations from the Mean Sea Level!
Therefore, in exactly scientific terms the ration scales will depend on the type of work, the physical exercise done, the climate where operating, the altitude where operating.
Now, according to the International Institute for Strategic Studies, in 2010 the Indian army had a strength of 1,129,900 active personnel and 960,000 reserve personnel.
Imagine if the parameters were to be applied as per scientific to calculate the different scales of rations, what a total confusion it would lead to!
Imagine the procurement problems as also calculating the transport required to move the rations (taking into consideration the requirement in different areas, for each different arms and services, and depending on the climatic conditions and also the elevation the said different types of troops from different arms and services.
Now, imagine for some reason, some troops are redeployed for some operational reason to an area with totally different parameters to what was forecast, planned, procured and moved! How does one now, at this late stage, cater for what can become a shortfall or become surplus.
Therefore, there has to be standardisation in ration scales. However, with add ons for the High Altitude and maybe for water and ice in the deserts for troops under canvas or training.