CCP downplaying India's progress for regime legitimacy

jat

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2009
Messages
244
Likes
203
Alright this is a new thread about CCP propaganda. Most people don't know but the CCP's propaganda brigade has big office, a big budget and the sole responsibility of stopping bad media, spinning news for favor of China, and of course CCP. One of the things CCP does for India's case, is downplay India's progress, weather economic, or military or science.
For instance, when India signs a high speed rail contract, news in China will talk about it briefly before explaining how China is exporting such technology while India still does not have this technology. Even though Japan provided this technology to China.
When it comes to science, like the MARS MOM mission, Chinese media congratulated India, but didn't mention China's failed mission or pointed at the gaps in ISRO or how poor India is.
Military, well, everything is joke according to Chinese media especially India. Entire programs, belittle India's might, its success in protecting the nation and severing Pakistan. According to Chinese state media, the Indian military is circus of corrupt ranks, poor soldiers, and poor equipment and training.
The program above is actually a popular PLA expert with a nice show...budget. This guy once said the J-10 is ahead of the F-16 latest block. But on this program, he points out the Delhi smog, Obama, bullet proof glass, the circus stunts on bikes, the camels. Every attempt to make India look like a circus and animal reserve. Cows on the road, and monkeys, and dogs with out showing the large environmental protection programs.
We don't know what hes saying in Chinese, but we can assume. I know Chinese won't want to translate the program for us, because debunk party propaganda. But consider this, these guys, in Chinese language talk more about Indian military issues than they do of PLA issues and even if they do, they try to spin a positive on it.
As a result, Chinese believe they are light years ahead of India like India is relative to Pakistan. Economic, or defense wise. The negative perception of India is far greater than what Koreans, of Japanese have of India. And this is not the result of border disputes. This is propaganda targeted at downplaying India's greatness, development or beauty.
Why spend millions and billion on propaganda? Well, party legitimacy. If Chinese people were aware that India isn't too far behind and developing rapidly with a democratic institution it would cause Chinese people to question their system. Its not about hate like we have with Pakistan but subliminal targeting of deep ingrained images. Billions for party legitimacy.
Therefore i'm starting a new thread. To highlight CCP propaganda and analyse it. Support would be greatly welcomed.
 

COLDHEARTED AVIATOR

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2016
Messages
4,086
Likes
17,728
Country flag
To me as a global SF and infantry follower the Chinese Army looks like a big joke.

Their documentaries about their training and tactics to clapping like a teenage japanese girl on seeing their president looks gayish.

A serious question is on their own equipment and skill with their paratroopers breaking ankles or sometimes reports of being too scared to jump.

Such is the level of propoganda that few units are trained and given budgets to compete in global competitions to get recognition.

China is basically a lighter version of North Korea and to have people to people relations or connect with such censored countries is not possible.
 

jat

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2009
Messages
244
Likes
203
To me as a global SF and infantry follower the Chinese Army looks like a big joke.

Their documentaries about their training and tactics to clapping like a teenage japanese girl on seeing their president looks gayish.

A serious question is on their own equipment and skill with their paratroopers breaking ankles or sometimes reports of being too scared to jump.

Such is the level of propoganda that few units are trained and given budgets to compete in global competitions to get recognition.

China is basically a lighter version of North Korea and to have people to people relations or connect with such censored countries is not possible.
yea, to the experts, but majority of the people with little knowledge or expertise will see China's strength. They do have strength, but far more weaknesses.
What I find funny is the ridicule they throw at Indian republic parades, which have gotten smaller in terms of defense equipment flaunting over the years. India has grown stronger, but showcases less defense equipment at the republic day parades. China OTOH makes them bigger every year. Totally different mentality. The strong don't show off, the weak bark louder to compensate as a general rule. But the perception is there.
Its important to note, that PLAs strength in engineer corps, artillery is high lighted little compared to the weaknesses being polished over to make them look like strengths. Training, and equipment of PLA infantry is behind even Pakistan and India. Yet PLA fanboys think they have super soldiers. Remember the damage control the Chinese media did when the peacekeeping mission in Congo backfired?
If I recall correctly, the biggest weakness of the PLA is its opera singer generals, and CCP leaders disguised as PLA generals. That would explain the lack of preparedness and dumb mistakes like Doklam.
 

nimo_cn

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2009
Messages
4,032
Likes
883
Country flag
Alright this is a new thread about CCP propaganda. Most people don't know but the CCP's propaganda brigade has big office, a big budget and the sole responsibility of stopping bad media, spinning news for favor of China, and of course CCP. One of the things CCP does for India's case, is downplay India's progress, weather economic, or military or science.
For instance, when India signs a high speed rail contract, news in China will talk about it briefly before explaining how China is exporting such technology while India still does not have this technology. Even though Japan provided this technology to China.
When it comes to science, like the MARS MOM mission, Chinese media congratulated India, but didn't mention China's failed mission or pointed at the gaps in ISRO or how poor India is.
Military, well, everything is joke according to Chinese media especially India. Entire programs, belittle India's might, its success in protecting the nation and severing Pakistan. According to Chinese state media, the Indian military is circus of corrupt ranks, poor soldiers, and poor equipment and training.
The program above is actually a popular PLA expert with a nice show...budget. This guy once said the J-10 is ahead of the F-16 latest block. But on this program, he points out the Delhi smog, Obama, bullet proof glass, the circus stunts on bikes, the camels. Every attempt to make India look like a circus and animal reserve. Cows on the road, and monkeys, and dogs with out showing the large environmental protection programs.
We don't know what hes saying in Chinese, but we can assume. I know Chinese won't want to translate the program for us, because debunk party propaganda. But consider this, these guys, in Chinese language talk more about Indian military issues than they do of PLA issues and even if they do, they try to spin a positive on it.
As a result, Chinese believe they are light years ahead of India like India is relative to Pakistan. Economic, or defense wise. The negative perception of India is far greater than what Koreans, of Japanese have of India. And this is not the result of border disputes. This is propaganda targeted at downplaying India's greatness, development or beauty.
Why spend millions and billion on propaganda? Well, party legitimacy. If Chinese people were aware that India isn't too far behind and developing rapidly with a democratic institution it would cause Chinese people to question their system. Its not about hate like we have with Pakistan but subliminal targeting of deep ingrained images. Billions for party legitimacy.
Therefore i'm starting a new thread. To highlight CCP propaganda and analyse it. Support would be greatly welcomed.
this post is full of speculation and fabrication, but no substantial evidence. In order to understand Chinese propaganda, first you need to understand Chinese language. However, none of indian members who is commenting or going comment on this thread understand Chinese language, that is way how it works for indians, you people get to know China through second hand sources or imagination.
 

nimo_cn

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2009
Messages
4,032
Likes
883
Country flag
yea, to the experts, but majority of the people with little knowledge or expertise will see China's strength. They do have strength, but far more weaknesses.
What I find funny is the ridicule they throw at Indian republic parades, which have gotten smaller in terms of defense equipment flaunting over the years. India has grown stronger, but showcases less defense equipment at the republic day parades. China OTOH makes them bigger every year. Totally different mentality. The strong don't show off, the weak bark louder to compensate as a general rule. But the perception is there.
Its important to note, that PLAs strength in engineer corps, artillery is high lighted little compared to the weaknesses being polished over to make them look like strengths. Training, and equipment of PLA infantry is behind even Pakistan and India. Yet PLA fanboys think they have super soldiers. Remember the damage control the Chinese media did when the peacekeeping mission in Congo backfired?
If I recall correctly, the biggest weakness of the PLA is its opera singer generals, and CCP leaders disguised as PLA generals. That would explain the lack of preparedness and dumb mistakes like Doklam.
India showcases its military strength EVERY YEAR, it's apparent that India is more fond of military parade and bark more often.

Not only Chinese ridicule indian military parade, people all over the world do that, it's like a international sport, because indian military parade is truely funny.
 

jat

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2009
Messages
244
Likes
203
India showcases its military strength EVERY YEAR, it's apparent that India is more fond of military parade and bark more often.

Not only Chinese ridicule indian military parade, people all over the world do that, it's like a international sport, because indian military parade is truely funny.
Showcase military strength? Have you seen the republic day parade? Its not a military parade, its a celebration of Indian culture. Half the portion is a military parade with 90% being a regiment march and the rest are floats or hardware.
China parades its equipment. lol, Like a barking dog, pumping itself up to look bigger and meaner. India does nothing similar to a PLA parade. Its funny too you, but we and other people around the world find PLA marching like feminine clones hilarious. A lot more lols on PLA military parade, and I bet the PLA wasn't going for LOL.
As far as the Indian parade is concerned, its the greatest parade on planet earth. Camels, bike stunts, dances, floats, and fly pasts. You don't see India showing off ICBMs anymore or even short range tactical missiles. In fact, they have been removed. PLA still marches with huge number of missiles ranging from ICBMs and every kind of tank. I can smell Chinese insecurity in every propaganda video.
this post is full of speculation and fabrication, but no substantial evidence. In order to understand Chinese propaganda, first you need to understand Chinese language. However, none of indian members who is commenting or going comment on this thread understand Chinese language, that is way how it works for indians, you people get to know China through second hand sources or imagination.
Thats why i'm trying to learn the Chinese language and watch Chinese media in Chinese. I understand theres a difference in what Chinese media in English is saying and what Chinese language media says. There is substantive proof of what i'm highlighting. CCP- has a propaganda ministry with billions in budget?
I've seen enough, not heard enough, but rough translations at least points to the discussion.
Here is this moron again.
Now tell me. Is this moron with his own show and merchandise really blaming is brain farts of Ganges water or blaming Indians for drinking the water from ganges? Also Ganges, still cleaner than Chinese rivers. Thats the ironic part.
 

jat

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2009
Messages
244
Likes
203
In the first video, you can hear the audience laughing. Is this a comedy show? Its great they're mocking India. Its even funnier that Indian troops walked into sacred Chinese territory and told mighty China not build roads while still occupying sacred south Tibet. lol
 

Srinivas_K

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2009
Messages
7,417
Likes
12,935
Country flag
India showcases its military strength EVERY YEAR, it's apparent that India is more fond of military parade and bark more often.

Not only Chinese ridicule indian military parade, people all over the world do that, it's like a international sport, because indian military parade is truely funny.
And those grenade throwing exercises of pla are far better funny than any thing else related to military in the entire world.
 

HariPrasad-1

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2016
Messages
9,549
Likes
20,976
Country flag
this post is full of speculation and fabrication, but no substantial evidence. In order to understand Chinese propaganda, first you need to understand Chinese language. However, none of indian members who is commenting or going comment on this thread understand Chinese language, that is way how it works for indians, you people get to know China through second hand sources or imagination.
And chinese can understand everything without knowing local language.
 

jat

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2009
Messages
244
Likes
203
Heres another one. Worse than Pak media. They are "understanding" the indian military from the republic day parade. highlighting the Su-30 crash and the unfortunate crash of the hercules. T-90 tanks, highlighting the failure of these tanks at the tank battalion at russia. Then the Arjun tank, couldn't translate, but probably saying its expensive and a failure. Agni etc...pretty big budget show just to ridicule india and glorify pla.
 

jat

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2009
Messages
244
Likes
203
Another one, speculate, they are saying how the Indian military is only good for a joke parade and laughing about a naval falcrum crash.
 

HariPrasad-1

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2016
Messages
9,549
Likes
20,976
Country flag
India showcases its military strength EVERY YEAR, it's apparent that India is more fond of military parade and bark more often.

Not only Chinese ridicule indian military parade, people all over the world do that, it's like a international sport, because indian military parade is truely funny.
I appreciate comment because you can not do that in china because the CPC goon will abduct you and will put you in reeducation camp once again. Our parade is not only shows our military might but our vibrant culture which varies like anything from north to south and from east to west and still we have democracy. In some country like yours, there is hardly and difference but still you need a totalitarian to control you guys because your country will break otherwise. You guys need to be controlled on gun point and your government fixes execution quota. Better you look at yourself rather than commenting here and exposing your ill mentality.
 

jat

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2009
Messages
244
Likes
203
Another one. Translation
India joke military parade. Not like celestial middle kingdom. Perform joke yoga. Stupid bike stunts.
China mighty.

NOTE the maps of India displayed.
Heres coverage by chinese english media of republic day parade. Who in china watches english news? Who was suppose to be the consumer? my guess, is foreigners. They are trying to downgrade India's image to the world population. The are using Indias freedom of press against India. Ironic. Would China allow foreign press to do a unsupervised interviews in China?
 

jat

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2009
Messages
244
Likes
203
Heres amateur work. Basically highlighting the crap holes of India, to justify CCP. How india will never catch up. Ironic, as Taiwan and Japanese saw the same crap in China but were not as hostile.
Also ironic that Chinese don't like to compare, but yea, here there doing this.
 

Srinivas_K

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2009
Messages
7,417
Likes
12,935
Country flag
India showcases its military strength EVERY YEAR, it's apparent that India is more fond of military parade and bark more often.

Not only Chinese ridicule indian military parade, people all over the world do that, it's like a international sport, because indian military parade is truely funny.
Can you post a winny the pooh meme?( I am not pushing you post the meme. Pls don't invite trouble for yourself by posting it)

Chinese are most ridiculed people in this world because of the CPC rule and human rights violations. Leader of the PLA and he is afraid of a cartoon character ... LoL.

 

SorryNotSorry

Regular Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2017
Messages
227
Likes
451
Country flag
India showcases its military strength EVERY YEAR, it's apparent that India is more fond of military parade and bark more often.

Not only Chinese ridicule indian military parade, people all over the world do that, it's like a international sport, because indian military parade is truely funny.
Oh yeah? The Chinese are the masters of “barking” then.
You also type surprisingly well, considering you’re using your paws.
 

Adioz

शक्तिः दुर्दम्येच्छाशक्त्याः आगच्छति
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2015
Messages
1,419
Likes
2,819
Alright this is a new thread about CCP propaganda. Most people don't know but the CCP's propaganda brigade has big office, a big budget and the sole responsibility of stopping bad media, spinning news for favor of China, and of course CCP. One of the things CCP does for India's case, is downplay India's progress, weather economic, or military or science.
For instance, when India signs a high speed rail contract, news in China will talk about it briefly before explaining how China is exporting such technology while India still does not have this technology. Even though Japan provided this technology to China.
When it comes to science, like the MARS MOM mission, Chinese media congratulated India, but didn't mention China's failed mission or pointed at the gaps in ISRO or how poor India is.
Military, well, everything is joke according to Chinese media especially India. Entire programs, belittle India's might, its success in protecting the nation and severing Pakistan. According to Chinese state media, the Indian military is circus of corrupt ranks, poor soldiers, and poor equipment and training.
The program above is actually a popular PLA expert with a nice show...budget. This guy once said the J-10 is ahead of the F-16 latest block. But on this program, he points out the Delhi smog, Obama, bullet proof glass, the circus stunts on bikes, the camels. Every attempt to make India look like a circus and animal reserve. Cows on the road, and monkeys, and dogs with out showing the large environmental protection programs.
We don't know what hes saying in Chinese, but we can assume. I know Chinese won't want to translate the program for us, because debunk party propaganda. But consider this, these guys, in Chinese language talk more about Indian military issues than they do of PLA issues and even if they do, they try to spin a positive on it.
As a result, Chinese believe they are light years ahead of India like India is relative to Pakistan. Economic, or defense wise. The negative perception of India is far greater than what Koreans, of Japanese have of India. And this is not the result of border disputes. This is propaganda targeted at downplaying India's greatness, development or beauty.
Why spend millions and billion on propaganda? Well, party legitimacy. If Chinese people were aware that India isn't too far behind and developing rapidly with a democratic institution it would cause Chinese people to question their system. Its not about hate like we have with Pakistan but subliminal targeting of deep ingrained images. Billions for party legitimacy.
Therefore i'm starting a new thread. To highlight CCP propaganda and analyse it. Support would be greatly welcomed.
Propaganda always comes back to bite you in your own a$$. Porkies are victims of their own false propaganda, but the veil is steadily being lifted off their eyes. Some of their citizens are waking up from a joyful genjutsu into their horror-filled reality. (Though this has happened countless times before as well, like when that Paki newspaper had the headline "Victory on all fronts" on the morning of 16 December 1971 :rofl:)

The Chinese will also realise one day that they underestimated India way too much. Although CCP censorship will ensure that it does not happen until a really big event. Lets just hope they wake up from this self-induced dream after Indian Armed Forces have delivered a tight-slap to the almighty PLA. The situation is going to test Chinese censorship to the fullest extent (especially since many poor parents are going to receive the bodies of their only sons).

BTW, how does CCP propaganda of India mix with Indian cinema (Dangal and 3 idiots) to give a mixed view to Chinese public? :hmm:
 
Last edited:

Latest Replies

Global Defence

Articles

Top