1,000 Indian Workers Dead. The Grim Reality Of Qatar's FIFA World Cup Dream

Singh

Phat Cat
Super Mod
Joined
Feb 23, 2009
Messages
20,311
Likes
8,403
Country flag
The 2022 Qatar FIFA World Cup will kill more Indians than the numbers of players it will host. This is what Sharan Burrow, general secretary of the International Trade Union Confederation said last year, when news of Qatari human rights violations made headlines. A thousand Indians had already died, and a year later, we’ve only rescued Indians from the Gulf country when bombs fell, but ignored the darker, hidden world of Indian migrants in these nations.

Working in 50 degree heat, 12 hours a day, with no food.


In 2013, a Doha hospital reported that over a 1,000 workers were admitted to the trauma unit because of falling from heights, and a “significant” number of them died. Working 12 hours a day in 50 degree heat, without enough water - that’ll knock anyone out.

But their ordeal had begun much before that – many reported having lower salaries (which were rarely, or never paid), having their passports taken away, and working seven days a week. And as the 2022 deadline for the World Cup approaches, it is getting worse.

Being forced to live like animals


Migrant workers live in overcrowded accommodation with no air conditioning (a necessity in the scorching heat of the Middle East), and are exposed to overflowing sewage and uncovered septic tanks. Many are dumped and forgotten in squalid accommodations by companies who promised them a better life.

Here’s some excerpts from an International Trade Union Confederation Case study



“For three months, I and 15 others who arrived together were forced to sleep on the floor on a thin mattresses. We complained to the Qatar National Human Rights Committee about this and were moved into another accommodation. But even now eight people share one bedroom, sixteen people share a bathroom and thirty-five people share a kitchen…”

“The kitchen is not hygienic, the bedrooms are crowded, the drainage in the showers is clogged up and most importantly there is no safety equipment or emergency exits in the building, which puts our lives under serious risk."



“When I take one day off from work, two days pay is deducted from my salary. This is also the case when I am sick. One of my concerns is safety at work. My employer does not provide any boots or other safety equipment, not even a uniform. “

The Indian embassy reported that 237 Indians died in Qatar in 2012, and 191 in 2013 - many from "unnatural" heart failure. The year before, 169 Nepalese had died here. If they don’t die, many will kill themselves, due to mounting debts and not being able to return home.

There’s no escape


afp

Passports and other visa documentation is often taken away on arrival, and there’s no written proof of employment terms either. This is the Kafala system, which forces migrant workers to depend on their sponsors for pretty much everything. With their passport and visa, these sponsors conveniently terminate the possibility of workers escaping.

They’re being starved


Often, these workers aren't given enough food or any food for that matter, leaving them starving because they haven’t been paid salaries.

And tortured


What does the Indian government think?
Despite the high death count of Indian labourers in Qatar, our embassy in Qatar says this it is “quite normal”, according to Amnesty International.



Nikhil Eapen, Spokesperson, Amnesty International India, had written last year on their website about the government’s aloof stance: “Instead of simply saying that such deaths are normal, the Indian government should provide clearer and more transparent information because at this point, we are unable to say how these deaths took place - whether on construction sites, in labour camps, road accidents or as a result of natural causes.”

Could it be
But we think there might be an ulterior motive. In December last year, Prince of Qatar, Sheikh Hamad Bin Khalifa Al-Thani had spoken about committing 1 lakh crore Rupees to Modi’s goal of ‘smart cities’. With such a massive investment, maybe the government chose to sideline what may seem like a handful of Indians, for the bigger picture. At least that’s what it looks like.

http://m.indiatimes.com/news/india/...ty-of-qatars-fifa-world-cup-dream-232718.html
 

OneGrimPilgrim

Senior Member
Joined
May 18, 2015
Messages
5,243
Likes
6,810
Country flag
had read about this long back, but it had slipped out of memory. thanks for bringing this up!
 

blueblood

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
1,872
Likes
1,496
They chose this. They wanted quick money and they also knew how loving and caring Arabs are before they even stepped a foot in the country.

Source: Former neighbour worked in some bank. Also former roommate worked as a floor manager in some kind electronics super store chain.
 

rock127

Maulana Rockullah
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2009
Messages
10,569
Likes
25,230
Country flag
Fat lazy Sheikhs are such bloodsucking Iblis.

Their single talent today is that they are sitting on oil.
 

anupamsurey

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2014
Messages
1,032
Likes
514
Country flag
the people (of India) working in Arab are nothing but slaves, who cares for their lives.
The situation is same as it was during 90's my uncle (engineer) use to work there, had to leave thanks to Saddam.

now their are muslims in my city who proudly say, "hamare cicha saudi me hai ya hamare bhaijaan dubai me hai''.....sick people with sick mentality.

my uncle said any human even with slight dignity will not work in arab (if this is his first hand experience, then thanks but no thanks).
 

SafedSagar

Regular Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2014
Messages
209
Likes
319
Country flag
Could it be
But we think there might be an ulterior motive. In December last year, Prince of Qatar, Sheikh Hamad Bin Khalifa Al-Thani had spoken about committing 1 lakh crore Rupees to Modi’s goal of ‘smart cities’. With such a massive investment, maybe the government chose to sideline what may seem like a handful of Indians, for the bigger picture. At least that’s what it looks like.
Wah! But the main question is why did Darinder Moody kicked these guys just before the Sheikh Hamad Bin Khalifa Al-Thani promised to invest 1 lakh crore Rupees in deshatgard ‘smart cities’ project? Thank god the previous government took so much care and took all the necessary steps for the well being of the Indians struck in Qatar. This the very first time this is happening. :mad2: #KahaHaiAcheDin? #WillMoodyAnswer?
 

Johny_Baba

अज्ञानी
Senior Member
Joined
May 21, 2016
Messages
3,814
Likes
19,549
Country flag
Qatar World Cup: In 10 years, 2,711 migrant workers from India have died
Updated : February 23, 2021 03:40 PM IST
The number of Indians who have died are highest among migrant workers who majorly go from India, Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka.
Qatar World Cup: In 10 years, 2,711 migrant workers from India have died


CNBCTV18.com
CNBCTV18.COM

Share
It’s been over 10 years since Qatar won the right to host the 2022 football world cup. In these 10 years, over 6,750 migrant workers from five south Asian nations — India, Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka — have died in the country, stated a report published in the Guardian. Of these, the number of Indian migrant workers who have died is 2,711 — the highest among the five nations.
If broken down further, the findings mean that on average 12 migrant workers from these five nations have died each week since the night in December 2010 when Doha was celebrating Qatar’s victory to host the FIFA world cup.
Qatar has a migrant workforce of 20 lakh. The findings in the report, compiled from government sources, show the country’s failure to protect its migrant workforce. The devastated families who have lost their breadwinners are still struggling to gain compensation.
What’s perplexing is that many are not even aware of the circumstances under which their family members died. The report has a case study from India -- the family of 43-year-old Madhu Bollapally is still looking for answers. They were told he died of natural causes. In 2019, one day when his roommate got back to the dorm, he saw Bollapally’s body on the floor. They are not sure how a healthy man could have died of heart failure due to natural causes while working in Qatar.
Bollapally is survived by his wife, Latha, and 13-year-old son Rajesh. “He had no health problems. There was nothing wrong with him,” Rajesh told Guardian. Though he worked for six years in Qatar before his death, his family received just Rs 1.14 lakh as compensation and unpaid salary.
Among the causes, “natural deaths” are most common, attributed to the heart or respiratory failure. Data obtained by Guardian reveals that 69 percent of deaths among Indian, Nepali and Bangladeshi workers are categorised as “natural”. Shockingly, the figure stands at 80 per cent for Indians alone. Other major causes of deaths among Indians, Nepalis and Bangladeshis are road accidents (12 per cent), workplace accidents (7 per cent) and suicide (7 per cent).
Since winning the rights to host the world cup, Qatar has embarked on an unprecedented building drive to prepare for the mega event in 2022. Even though death records are not categorised by occupation or place of work, it is likely that many of those who have lost their lives were employed on these world cup infrastructure projects, Nick McGeehan, a director at FairSquare Projects, an advocacy group specialising in labour rights in the Gulf, told Guardian.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

6,750 Asian Migrant Workers Reported Dead Amid Prep For 2022 Qatar World Cup: Report

Last Updated: 24th February, 2021 17:55 IST6,750 Asian Migrant Workers Reported Dead Amid Prep For 2022 Qatar World Cup: Report
A British media report has claimed that nearly 7,000 migrant workers from Asian countries have died amid ongoing work for the 2022 FIFA World Cup in Qatar

Written By
Jitesh Vachhatani
facebooktwitter
Qatar World Cup


Ever since Qatar won the rights to host the 2022 FIFA World Cup back in 2010, the 22nd edition of the quadrennial football championship has come under intense scrutiny and has been marred with controversies. Right from reports of corruption in bidding and acquiring the rights to allegations of human rights abuses and Qatar's diplomatic crisis, the hosting rights won by the middle-eastern country have sparked a debates frequently. Now, a report by British news media has claimed that nearly 7,000 migrant workers from Asian countries have died in the last decade amid preparation for the 2022 Qatar World Cup due to unknown reasons.
In an investigative report by Britain's The Guardian, it has been claimed that for the past 10 years, since Qatar won rights for the 2022 World Cup, over 6,750 migrant workers from five South Asian countries - India, Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka - have died in Qatar. Amongst these 5 countries, the number of migrant workers from India stands the highest at 2,711. Dissecting the number further, the findings have claimed that on average nearly 12 migrant workers from the aforementioned countries have died every week since December 2010 when Qatar won the rights to host the 2022 World Cup. The report doesn't necessarily suggest that they have all died while working on the World Cup, it does draw a correlation and carries the opinion of a labour rights group's spokesperson who says that a significant portion of the workers who have died were only there because of the World Cup and Qatar winning rights to host it.
READ | Qatar World Cup: 40,000-seater Picturesque Al Rayyan Stadium To Be Inaugurated On Dec 18
Significantly, the report also states that the reason behind the deaths of migrant workers in Doha is still a mystery. Citing a case from India, where 43-year-old Madhu Bollapally was found dead in Qatar back in 2019, the report apprised that the family of the Indian migrant worker is still unaware of the reason behind his death. While authorities in Doha have claimed that Bollapally had fallen to natural causes, the family has disputed it by stating that he was completely healthy and had no reasons to have suffered heart failure. However, his family has received Rs 1.14 lakh as compensation for the 6 years Bollapally worked in Qatar, the report added.
80% of Indians amongst 'natural deaths'
Furthermore, The Guardian's report has claimed that amongst the deaths by 'natural causes,' the most common are attributed to heart or respiratory failure. Data obtained by Guardian reveals that 69 per cent of deaths among Indian, Nepali and Bangladeshi workers are categorised as “natural”, out of which, the number stands at 80 per cent for Indians alone.
READ | UN Court Rules In UAE's Favour In Discrimination Case Brought By Qatar After Doha Blockade
Prior to this, several reports have come to light that has claimed migrant workers in Qatar face inhumane labour conditions and have also been subjected to 'slavery'. When in 2015 the International Trade Union Confederation had claimed that over 1,200 workers had died while working for projects related to the World Cup, the Qatar government had quashed these claims, terming them baseless. To come clean in eyes of international media, the Qatar government had announced that it would do away with its 'Al-Kafala' system under pressure from the International Labour Organisation - a United Nations functionary.
The Kafala system often labelled as 'modern-day slavery', prohibits workers from changing jobs or even leaving the country without their employer's approval. Following the noise over the relocation of the FIFA 2022 World Cup, the Qatar government had signed a formal cooperation agreement with the ILO promising to abolish the Kafala system. However, several reports have claimed that the agreement stands only on paper and is far-away from being implemented despite being signed back in 2019. Owing to such reports, there has been intense demand for shifting the 2022 World Cup from Qatar.
READ | FIFA Clears Munir To Change Allegiance From Spain To Morocco
Qatar World Cup 2022

The 2022 FIFA World Cup is slated to be held from November 21, 2022 onwards with the final being played on December 18. This will be the first World Cup to be held in an Arab country and also the first one to be played in a different time slot rather than the traditional May-July window. The reason behind the changed schedule is due to the extensively warm weather in the middle-east during May-June and has also led to the reduction of the timeframe to merely 28 days. The changed schedule has also invited criticism with the World Cup's schedule clashing with several domestic tournaments including the prestigious Premier League in England. The 2022 Qatar World Cup bid has also faced corruption charges in the past, however, an internal investigation by FIFA had cleared Qatar of any wrongdoing.
READ | Swiss Prosecutors Appeal Against Verdicts In FIFA Trial
 

Johny_Baba

अज्ञानी
Senior Member
Joined
May 21, 2016
Messages
3,814
Likes
19,549
Country flag
Qatar World Cup: In 10 years, 2,711 migrant workers from India have died
Updated : February 23, 2021 03:40 PM IST
The number of Indians who have died are highest among migrant workers who majorly go from India, Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka.
Qatar World Cup: In 10 years, 2,711 migrant workers from India have died


CNBCTV18.com
CNBCTV18.COM

Share
It’s been over 10 years since Qatar won the right to host the 2022 football world cup. In these 10 years, over 6,750 migrant workers from five south Asian nations — India, Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka — have died in the country, stated a report published in the Guardian. Of these, the number of Indian migrant workers who have died is 2,711 — the highest among the five nations.
If broken down further, the findings mean that on average 12 migrant workers from these five nations have died each week since the night in December 2010 when Doha was celebrating Qatar’s victory to host the FIFA world cup.
Qatar has a migrant workforce of 20 lakh. The findings in the report, compiled from government sources, show the country’s failure to protect its migrant workforce. The devastated families who have lost their breadwinners are still struggling to gain compensation.
What’s perplexing is that many are not even aware of the circumstances under which their family members died. The report has a case study from India -- the family of 43-year-old Madhu Bollapally is still looking for answers. They were told he died of natural causes. In 2019, one day when his roommate got back to the dorm, he saw Bollapally’s body on the floor. They are not sure how a healthy man could have died of heart failure due to natural causes while working in Qatar.
Bollapally is survived by his wife, Latha, and 13-year-old son Rajesh. “He had no health problems. There was nothing wrong with him,” Rajesh told Guardian. Though he worked for six years in Qatar before his death, his family received just Rs 1.14 lakh as compensation and unpaid salary.
Among the causes, “natural deaths” are most common, attributed to the heart or respiratory failure. Data obtained by Guardian reveals that 69 percent of deaths among Indian, Nepali and Bangladeshi workers are categorised as “natural”. Shockingly, the figure stands at 80 per cent for Indians alone. Other major causes of deaths among Indians, Nepalis and Bangladeshis are road accidents (12 per cent), workplace accidents (7 per cent) and suicide (7 per cent).
Since winning the rights to host the world cup, Qatar has embarked on an unprecedented building drive to prepare for the mega event in 2022. Even though death records are not categorised by occupation or place of work, it is likely that many of those who have lost their lives were employed on these world cup infrastructure projects, Nick McGeehan, a director at FairSquare Projects, an advocacy group specialising in labour rights in the Gulf, told Guardian.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

6,750 Asian Migrant Workers Reported Dead Amid Prep For 2022 Qatar World Cup: Report

Last Updated: 24th February, 2021 17:55 IST6,750 Asian Migrant Workers Reported Dead Amid Prep For 2022 Qatar World Cup: Report
A British media report has claimed that nearly 7,000 migrant workers from Asian countries have died amid ongoing work for the 2022 FIFA World Cup in Qatar

Written By
Jitesh Vachhatani
facebooktwitter
Qatar World Cup


Ever since Qatar won the rights to host the 2022 FIFA World Cup back in 2010, the 22nd edition of the quadrennial football championship has come under intense scrutiny and has been marred with controversies. Right from reports of corruption in bidding and acquiring the rights to allegations of human rights abuses and Qatar's diplomatic crisis, the hosting rights won by the middle-eastern country have sparked a debates frequently. Now, a report by British news media has claimed that nearly 7,000 migrant workers from Asian countries have died in the last decade amid preparation for the 2022 Qatar World Cup due to unknown reasons.
In an investigative report by Britain's The Guardian, it has been claimed that for the past 10 years, since Qatar won rights for the 2022 World Cup, over 6,750 migrant workers from five South Asian countries - India, Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka - have died in Qatar. Amongst these 5 countries, the number of migrant workers from India stands the highest at 2,711. Dissecting the number further, the findings have claimed that on average nearly 12 migrant workers from the aforementioned countries have died every week since December 2010 when Qatar won the rights to host the 2022 World Cup. The report doesn't necessarily suggest that they have all died while working on the World Cup, it does draw a correlation and carries the opinion of a labour rights group's spokesperson who says that a significant portion of the workers who have died were only there because of the World Cup and Qatar winning rights to host it.
READ | Qatar World Cup: 40,000-seater Picturesque Al Rayyan Stadium To Be Inaugurated On Dec 18
Significantly, the report also states that the reason behind the deaths of migrant workers in Doha is still a mystery. Citing a case from India, where 43-year-old Madhu Bollapally was found dead in Qatar back in 2019, the report apprised that the family of the Indian migrant worker is still unaware of the reason behind his death. While authorities in Doha have claimed that Bollapally had fallen to natural causes, the family has disputed it by stating that he was completely healthy and had no reasons to have suffered heart failure. However, his family has received Rs 1.14 lakh as compensation for the 6 years Bollapally worked in Qatar, the report added.
80% of Indians amongst 'natural deaths'
Furthermore, The Guardian's report has claimed that amongst the deaths by 'natural causes,' the most common are attributed to heart or respiratory failure. Data obtained by Guardian reveals that 69 per cent of deaths among Indian, Nepali and Bangladeshi workers are categorised as “natural”, out of which, the number stands at 80 per cent for Indians alone.
READ | UN Court Rules In UAE's Favour In Discrimination Case Brought By Qatar After Doha Blockade
Prior to this, several reports have come to light that has claimed migrant workers in Qatar face inhumane labour conditions and have also been subjected to 'slavery'. When in 2015 the International Trade Union Confederation had claimed that over 1,200 workers had died while working for projects related to the World Cup, the Qatar government had quashed these claims, terming them baseless. To come clean in eyes of international media, the Qatar government had announced that it would do away with its 'Al-Kafala' system under pressure from the International Labour Organisation - a United Nations functionary.
The Kafala system often labelled as 'modern-day slavery', prohibits workers from changing jobs or even leaving the country without their employer's approval. Following the noise over the relocation of the FIFA 2022 World Cup, the Qatar government had signed a formal cooperation agreement with the ILO promising to abolish the Kafala system. However, several reports have claimed that the agreement stands only on paper and is far-away from being implemented despite being signed back in 2019. Owing to such reports, there has been intense demand for shifting the 2022 World Cup from Qatar.
READ | FIFA Clears Munir To Change Allegiance From Spain To Morocco
Qatar World Cup 2022

The 2022 FIFA World Cup is slated to be held from November 21, 2022 onwards with the final being played on December 18. This will be the first World Cup to be held in an Arab country and also the first one to be played in a different time slot rather than the traditional May-July window. The reason behind the changed schedule is due to the extensively warm weather in the middle-east during May-June and has also led to the reduction of the timeframe to merely 28 days. The changed schedule has also invited criticism with the World Cup's schedule clashing with several domestic tournaments including the prestigious Premier League in England. The 2022 Qatar World Cup bid has also faced corruption charges in the past, however, an internal investigation by FIFA had cleared Qatar of any wrongdoing.
READ | Swiss Prosecutors Appeal Against Verdicts In FIFA Trial
Even redditors took notice of this and made this comic about 5 years ago,

source -
 

sunshine

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
311
Likes
456
Country flag
But they send 60 to 80 billion dollars a year to India, hard-earned money.
 

sunshine

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
311
Likes
456
Country flag
This is particularly true for the Gulf region, from where more than 60% of India’s remittances flow in.
Economists are painting a rather gloomy picture about India’s nearly $80 billion overseas remittance fortune, the world’s highest. World Bank, which tracks the number closely for all countries, in April had projected India’s remittances to fall by about 23% in the calendar year 2020 to $64 billion, from $83 billion seen in 2019 as migrant labourers flew back home on perceived safety concerns or due to job losses. UBS, in a report dated July 23, said the drop could be 25% from its fiscal 2019-20 level of $76 billion, or 2.7% of the gross domestic product (GDP), to about $55-60 billion in fiscal 2020-21

“India’s current account deficit (CAD) excluding remittances would have been a high $101 billion (3.5% of GDP) versus $25 billion (0.9% of GDP) with transfers in FY20,” UBS wrote in its report.

Gulf countries constitute roughly 62% of India’s remittances. The recent sharp fall in global crude oil prices will affect the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) growth, while the weak US economic growth would also adversely impact employment there and therefore, the remittance to India. US and Canada account for nearly 20% of remittances to India.

India will not protest, if so, Indian workers will be replaced by Pakistani and Bangladeshi workers.
 

Tshering22

Sikkimese Saber
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
7,869
Likes
23,242
Country flag
They chose this. They wanted quick money and they also knew how loving and caring Arabs are before they even stepped a foot in the country.

Source: Former neighbour worked in some bank. Also former roommate worked as a floor manager in some kind electronics super store chain.
They did not choose this.

Sorry, but most of these workers are given a very false image of the Middle East. Remember, these are poor, semi-literate/illiterate people who do things like pick up bricks, move heavy stuff around, mix mortar, etc. They cannot differentiate fact from fiction.

Once they enter that country, they are powerless, as their employers' associates take away all their documents. These men are just trying to earn a decent living. If they were paid what they were promised, then they won't mind working in these conditions.

Also, some extra promising and crafty ones are encouraged to convert to Islam by bribing them who in turn get more people to do the same among their ranks. But even then, they are just given a false hope that conversion will improve their condition.

If anything, we as a country need to cater to our people, or simply stop complaining about other countries.
 

Tshering22

Sikkimese Saber
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
7,869
Likes
23,242
Country flag
India will not protest, if so, Indian workers will be replaced by Pakistani and Bangladeshi workers.
This seriously exposes our limitations.

If we cannot export more high-value stuff and instead just rely on remittances for such money, then it is really dangerous. One of the main reasons for rapid recovery in China after the COVID fiasco is that they have a strong export capacity. Whether there is a pandemic or not, the world still needs plates, cups, pens, pencils, machines, phones, cars, ships, trucks, etc. China makes everything in house.

This is where the PM, Nirmala Sitharaman and Jaishankar need to sit down and see what can be done to create backup plans for upsets like this. No one around the world knew that such a pandemic could upset the entire world order. But now we all do.

A serious plan is needed in investing in factories in India. Despite all the improvements in the ease of starting businesses, we have a long, long way to before we can truly say that starting businesses and easy access to initial financing is truly easy. We need to make land acquisition of non-agricultural land as easy as writing an essay in an elementary school for companies, factories and the heavy manufacturing sector.

Without creating local jobs, we cannot eternally be dependent on foreign remittances. Gulf countries are anyway turning away from oil-based income. That means it is expected that in the next decade or two, most of these expatriates living in the Gulf will leave and return to India. At that time, what will we do?

It is high time that the government rethinks about all this musical chair of politics and focuses on long-term contingency plans to rescue the economy from global upsets. Also, other measures such as Population Control Bill are necessary as this blue-collared class of people have the maximum offspring.
 

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top